Aston Villa - Villa 0-0 Blues - Match Report
UK time is: 17:44:32
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Aston Villa 0 - Birmingham City 0

Villa Park

31/10/10 - 12pm

Attendance: 40,688

Villa 0-0 Blues - Match Report

Let`s get the negative out of the way first; that was an appalling game of football between two teams who didn`t want to lose the game, as opposed to two teams that wanted to win it.

Unfortunately, getting the negatives out of the way so early doesn`t necessarily mean that there are many positives to talk about either, with the only three I can think of being that we didn`t lose, got a point and kept a clean sheet.

I can`t understand why we played in such a negative way. Why didn`t we play with two strikers at home from the start? Why was Ciaran Clark deployed in midfield when that is clearly not his best position when we had Ireland and Bannan on the bench?

The game was a fairly scrappy affair, which is understandable given the equal weight of apprehension and passion that is present in most derbies that are played in English football. Having said that, Villa had the first decent chance of the game, after Ashley Young pinged a low ball towards goal that only needed the slightest glance off Heskey`s boot to make the net bulge. As it happened, Heskey couldn`t make the required contact.

Ben Foster had an extremely lucky escape after his attempted clearance was ferociously charged down by our very own Nige, stand-in captain Reo-Coker.

Villa then could have stood accused of being jammy themselves, with the hyperactive Croyden-born midfielder committing what I think was hand-ball in the Blues penalty area. That was at least my initial reaction, and I was surprised that Blues weren`t given a penalty.

At the interval, the atmosphere was strangely subdued in B6, with most supporters recognising that they had just seen a load of absolute dross. Even my usual, ever-so-slightly superstitious half-time trip to the toilet to empty my bladder was strange, mostly because of the urine that covered the floor after a toilet had become blocked and had overflown. At least it gives me an excuse to chuck my trainers into the washing machine.

Blues sent on Cameron Jerome, possibly sensing that the Villa defence could be got at, and that proved to be the case as an again below-par Richard Dunne was easily ghosted past by the much maligned front-man, only for him to cross straight into Brad Friedel`s hands, showing exactly why he is 'much-maligned`, even by Bluenoses themselves.

One interesting feature of the game was Craig Gardner`s battle with Reo-Coker, and after a bad challenge in the first half had seen a yellow card head Gardner`s way, as well as a few choice words by Reo-Coker himself, tempers again flared in the second half when another foul was committed on Nige by Gardner. This time though it was met by an even worse reaction which meant that Reo-Coker entered the referee`s book, which in turn probably played a big part in his later substitution. I must admit that I was both surprised and annoyed by Craig Gardner. I seem to remember him being a fairly good football player while he was at Villa, and it is a shame to see what the atmosphere at St. Andrews has turned him into - another member of the Blues midfield who would now be more suited to rugby.

Our little Scotsman Barry Bannan came on and did fairly well considering the circumstances, although Houllier`s failure to put Ireland onto the pitch completely baffled me. Houllier must know that in Premier League derbies one thing that is a massive help is the presence of midfielders who can battle, and win that battle too, but instead he just made our physical presence even more miniscule. However, the Frenchman`s change nearly paid off, with Bannan hitting a lovely strike that just looked like it was going to creep in, but Foster made a good save.

Big John came on for Nigel Reo-Coker in the dying embers of the game and he nodded on a ball which set-up a glorious chance for Ciaran Clark that he looked destined to score from, but he unfortunately sent his header wide whilst also managing to get a smack from Ben Foster in the process.

The game finished with Ashley Young attempting to jink past Liam Ridgewell to create some space for himself, which he then used to thunder a shot against what was almost the angle of bar and post.

I was really disappointed with our lack of attacking threat today. I`m not willing to criticise Houllier yet as he hasn`t had time to mould this team into his own, but I don`t believe that he`s going to help himself by putting square pegs into round holes. Clark did admirably in the circumstances considering his manager asked him to play a role that is completely unfamiliar to him, and when it was clear that we needed a more mobile presence to help Heskey up front his answer was to bring Carew on instead of Delfouneso, who, you guessed it, is the least mobile of the two.

Still, as I`ve been writing this report, I`ve managed to think of another positive. At least the two stoners I talked about in my Burnley report weren`t there today, so I knew that my head was going to be safe...

By - Big_Marlon

Star Player

Ciaran Clark

Player Ratings

Brad Friedel 7


Luke Young 6


Richard Dunne 6


James Collins 7


Stephen Warnock 6


Ashley Young 7


Stewart Downing 7


Steve Sidwell 5


Ciaran Clark 8


Nigel Reo-Coker 6


Emile Heskey 7


Sub: Barry Bannan 6


Sub: John Carew 6


The Journalist

Writer: Mike Field Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Sunday October 31 2010

Time: 7:48PM

Your Comments (oldest first)

Change to most recent first
Failure to put Ireland on baffled you? I'm surprised by that comment. Ireland has not shown he has the physical presence or attitude to play in a game like that. Further Bannan showed exactly why he got on the pitch ahead of him. Tenacity, effort and no little skill surely made that obvious. A point from another thread is an interesting one. GH is having to play players bought for a different system and certainly we have no decent strikers which has been the main problem for several years. Final thought, is Clark the new Barry?
Report Abuse
31/10/2010 22:47:00

Plus NRC did not show a captain mentallity today. He was the experienced midfielder and should not have let Gardner get to him. Very poor judgement.
Report Abuse
01/11/2010 00:02:00

I actually think it took a lot of guts for GH to put Clark in that position in such an important game. It shows he is not afraid to take risks and he will judge players in his own way and in his own time. I like that and although the performance was dead poor I'm happy to see the younger players getting more chances. I think extra power up front and the return of Delph in Jan with see us pick up more positive results in the second half of the season. Actually it will be quite a nice change to having a great start to the season and dip off towards the end, this year I think we will do an Everton.
Report Abuse
01/11/2010 01:38:00

Another good write up Big M. Plenty to talk about after that game for sure.
Report Abuse
01/11/2010 09:43:00

Thom85, you think you will lose only 2 games in the last 24 games of the season??? Your going to need to find some goals, when is Gabby coming back? Seems he is vitally important to your team
Report Abuse
01/11/2010 09:46:00

I'm saying we will only lose two, I'm saying that come January, if GH invests in the right kind of player (I.E a good striker) then we will have a much better second half to the season. We don't exactly leak a lot of goals (newcastle aside) at the moment, so if we had some solid firepower and if Ireland can hit some form we will be a threat. Gabbys not that important for me, I don't know how everyone else feels. To me he's just another one of our four non goalscoring strikers to choose from.
Report Abuse
01/11/2010 09:56:00

He offers you the counter attack football which you guys thrive, to me Villa are always most dangerous on the break, as Agbonlahor is deadly on the break, with Heskey and Carew it slows your football and to me it looks like you struggle to break teams down. How much do you Villa fans reckon GH will have to spend in January???
Report Abuse
01/11/2010 10:07:00

I think GH is trying to build a team that doesn't have to thrive on counter attacking football and thats the problem at the moment. Its a transitional phase for us. The style of football is changing, slowly but surely, Ive definitely noticed that in the last few games. Gabbys finshing has got worse and I think he has lost a yard of pace. Not good enough really for someone who is still supposed to be developing his game. I'm hoping he will have at least 15m to purchase a decent target man from abroad. I think Carews time is up although I still think Heskey will have a part to play this season.
Report Abuse
01/11/2010 10:13:00

I totally agree with you that we struggle to break teams down by the way
Report Abuse
01/11/2010 10:14:00

At least your not conceding goals, your defence has really gelled, dont think Brum really didnt have a chance off the top of my head. Any ideas for who the target man might be?? Any preferneces??
Report Abuse
01/11/2010 10:30:00

Flipping good qn Rob - nobody springs to mind for me! Lets hope GH can pull a rabbit out of the hat!
Report Abuse
01/11/2010 13:26:00

I fail to understand how Foster almost punching Clark out of VP is not a penalty. He missed the ball and took out the player, if a defender had done the same to the opposition he would have been carded and we would be shooting from the spot! that aside, it was not a very inspiring game, as someone has said, two local teams scared of losing to the the other and that does not promote an exciting blend of football unfortunately.
Report Abuse
01/11/2010 13:49:00

Gordonsleftboot - I couldn't agree more. Ireland doesn't like a tackle and personally, I'd consider starting Bannan next week against Fulham. It was nice to see a centre midfielder constantly on the move and wanting the ball at his feet, something we have been missing badly since Barry left. I also can't understand this fixation with a player having one position and one position only. Clark has come through as a Centre Back admittedly, but is obviously comfortable enough on the ball and positionally aware to play further forward. I can't see how that's a bad thing, especially with our lack of depth currently. Or to put it another way, it wasn't because Clark played Midfield that we drew the game.
Report Abuse
01/11/2010 14:00:00

That 6 for Warnock is a tad harsh. I thought he did alright yesteday considering he was trying to cover two of their players at times. Although useless end ball, Carr did okay getting up in support but with Ash not being bothered at all in the first half, it left a lot for Warnock to do. When Jerome came on Warnock was done for pace a couple of times but that's what fresh legs up top do for you.
Report Abuse
01/11/2010 15:43:00

Oh and Collins had Zigic in his pocket. ALL day!
Report Abuse
01/11/2010 15:43:00

A non-event really wasn't it? Neither side played particularly well. Lot of effort, huff and puff, but very little football of note. A draw was probably the fair result, as either side could have sneaked it. We finished the stronger of the two sides, but never really looked convincing.
Report Abuse
19/11/2010 09:51:00

No love lost between Nigel Reo-Coker and ex-Villan Craig Gardner was there? They seemed to be at each others throats from the start. Should make for interesting viewing when we head over to St Andrews for the Carling Cup quarter-final.
Report Abuse
19/11/2010 09:54:00


Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Pride of Lions 488
2. The Fear 289
3. Fulford 246
4. ClivetheVillan 240
5. sirdennis 172
6. JuanPabloAngel 168
7. revdpete 163
8. DeanoVilla 135
9. Wurzel 113
10. He'sBiggerThanMe&You 89

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
14. WBA 25 7 8 10 -9 29
15. AFC Bournemouth 25 7 7 11 -12 28
16. Swansea 25 6 9 10 -9 27
17. Newcastle 25 6 6 13 -18 24
18. Norwich 25 6 5 14 -20 23
19. Sunderland 25 5 5 15 -19 20
20. Aston Villa 25 3 7 15 -20 16

Aston Villa Fixtures (view all)

Breaking League News

Mourinho to United Rumours Gather Momentum
Man Utd : 10/02/2016 17:11:00
I Wonder Who'd Win?
Man Utd : 10/02/2016 17:06:00
Challenging For A Place At The Euros
Southampton : 10/02/2016 16:54:00
Zaha Offers Something Different
Crystal Palace : 10/02/2016 16:36:00
Deeney Deserves England Chance
Watford : 10/02/2016 16:20:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Norwich MotM
Suggested By:  Site Staff
Bunn 7%
Richards 1%
Okore 10%
Lescott 8%
Cissokho 0%
Bacuna 0%
Gana 32%
Westwood 1%
Gil 7%
Agbonlahor 26%
Veretout 7%
Sub - Clark 1%