UK time is: 10:32:51
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Aston Villa 1 - Manchester City 1

Villa Park

05/09/2009

Attendance: 37 924

Villa Match The New Billionaries Of City

Well, personally I think that was a good match! Reading the match thread in the forum there seem to be mixed opinions and certainly big question marks over John Carew, Ashley Young and naturally enough, over Emile Heskey who I SO wanted to endear himself to us Villa fans last night... sadly not! Is it true he has arse pads instead of shin pads?! Sorry, that is a bit catty I know! lol

What I enjoyed about last night was that the effort was there and most of the players seemed up for it. Now fair enough, I'm quite easy to please because all I really want to see is a team full of players who are interesting in performing for us, win lose or draw it is the effort i want to see and apart from the petty booing I thought the atmosphere was the best of the season as well.

We could have scored early on and it would have been a shocker as it would have come from open play not a set piece. Gabby was so unlucky and Shay Given, as he so often is, was there to make a great save. I thought the first half was largely ours and the goal by Stephen Dunne deserved. I also thought the guy was quality for not over celebrating in a show of respect to the fans who had idolised him all those years, they reciprocated by clapping him. Looked mighty strange mind you, the oppo fans clapping a Villa goal!!!! I don't think we'd have done the same if Barry had scored... then again, Barry I think our worried himself from the game, he looked shaky from the time he came out onward, not a bad performance but not the commanding sort of showing his is capable of.

Now I could get picky and point out the frailties but do you know what? I really don't fancy doing so, after an awful showing v Blackburn Rovers Villa came out and most at least put in the effort. You could look at why we think we've won after one goal and why our strikers don't shoot but then you could also look on the other side of things and see just how solid a defence we a appear to have now. If only we'd brought in an out and out goalscorer like Darren Bent, instead of relying on Carew who is either not fit, not interested or....?... and Heskey I think will cause us problems this season UNLESS they hit form, then who knows?! Gabby isn't perfect and at his age he won't be but he is leading the line, he is causing a threat and he is giving defenders plenty to worry about. I hope that Ashley Young takes note of Gabby's attitude this season, maybe being dropped from the England set up will also give him a wake up call. Hopefully the lad isn't too badly injured from the crunching second half tackle, then again, a rest or being on the bench for a game or two might not do him any harm?

The interesting thing at the end - when we were 1-1 and no complaints at Man Cities goal, it was a good build up, I didn't like seeing Stephen Ireland coming on as he looks a quality player and so he proved as he started the move finished by that orrible little bloke Bellamy who despite being a right little **** (add your own word!) is a quality player who I'd not have minded seeing in a Villa shirt! Where was I? Oh yes, at the end when the 5 minutes extra time came up, it was Mark Hughes who was angry and therefore you would assume worrying about us sneaking a late win. He let the fourth official know what he thought. Funnily enough, I'd asked him as he returned to his bench before the second half 'how much extra time tonight then Mark' to which he replied 'bloody loads I hope if we are still losing!' Fair play to the bloke, that is the second season in a row he's responded to my banter!

A few other opinions as I'm aware this isn't so much a match report as a ramble...!

Deanovilla: Good point against a potential title challenger. I'd have taken it at the start, just disappointed in the way we lost the lead. Carew was shocking, Young was shocking, Milner was average. Gabby was IMMENSE!!! Brilliant. He's really looking the part, and he was our attack, single handedly. More from Deano in a bit as I'm going to use his ratings!

ClaretAndBlue82 'Proud of the lads tonight they all worked so hard...We were playing a team who have spent 200mil in the last year and matched them all over the field. I'm happy.'

Randy_Stand: 'I said i would have taken a point before the game so I'm reasonably happy. We played well. Think the sub was crying out to be made 10 mins before the equalizer. Should have had NRC on for Carew then. The back four were excellent, apart from Cuellar's distribution. Petrov ran his balls off. Sidwell ineffective. Young was taking kicks from everyone. Milner was alright. Gabby was great, I thought he led the line well. Might not have played Carew, he did bugger all game and i think some of you guys slagging Heskey off tonight are a tad harsh. Emile Heskey did more in the few minutes he came on than John Carew did in the whole match.

Last point, fair play to Gareth Barry. He had a tough night tonight. Had a poor game by his standards, pressure got to him. He got torrents of abuse tonight from the Villa faithful. I stood silent, neither boo or clap but at the end he turned to the whole ground and applauded the Villa and Citeh fans. I would not have done that if Villa fans were calling me a w*****. So whatever you think about the guy, he has some decency there. Overall a decent night, I'm reasonably happy.'

Star Player

Ratings below from Deano. My man of the match was James Collins who I thought was solid as anything but can't really separate him and Dunne who was also immense and nearly got a brace, oh so close!

Player Ratings


Friedel 7

JF: Looking MUCH better than last season I think. Has he settled in now? A couple of very important saves.

Cueller 6

JF: Feel sorry for him, he isn't a right-back, simple as that. He does well enough but Luke Young will no doubt re-claim that position. Surprised we bought Habib Beye as cover for right-back and yet play a central defender who is obviously not comfortable in that position? Bit baffling that MON.

Warnock 6

JF: looks like he is settling in, 6 might be a bit harsh, not sure. Then again, never saw the problem with Shorey either! Would say Warnock is probably better tracking back and defending?!

Dunne 8

JF: Solid in defense, great goal and so nearly got a 2nd!

Collins 8

JF: what a great signing, never paid any attention to him before we bought him but I'm paying attention now.. wow! Solid and won every header.

Milner 6

JF: Good solid performance without wowing. I do like Milner though, tough player with some great touches. He'd have got another point from me but deanovilla is a meanie!

Young 4

JF: agreed, this chap has so much potential and has to be careful now not to blow it just as he is bursting on the England scene (and obviously he has been dropped due to his poor form) He hasn't made it yet, he is mostly potential, he MUST realise that potential because he has bags of it. His passing was woeful and looks like he needs a rest?

Sidwell 7

JF, would have said 6 but he does put in the dirty work and the scruffy stuff, certainly the midfield weren't totally overpowered as they often are last night.

Petrov 6

JF: Too much sideways, even MON (after I yelled it to be honest!!!!) started telling him to get the ball forward. Still better performance than a few from this season so hopefully starting to hit some form. Would love to see him shoot more, we need goals from midfield.

Carew 4

JF: agree with Deano, Carew was woeful, the most undeserving of Holte End heroes when on this form. It is all well and good waving at us and kissing the badge, what we want is the 100% full bloodied Carew that we see all too seldom but who is awesome when on tune. Wake up John otherwise you'll no doubt be replaced.

Gabby 8

JF: Led the line well, gave the defenders plenty to worry about, nearly scored early on with a neat flick, still needs to be supplied with the ball more to shoot.

Emile Heskey

on for Carew (68mins) I SO wanted this to be his night but either our tactics don't suit him or.....? Sorry, useless and baffling. We should have gone 4-5-1. Why oh why didn't we buy a top striker this summer, a Darren Bent sort could have made THE difference to this season.

Reo-Coker

On for Ashley Young (80mins) Not on long enough to make an impact really and also he is NOT A WINGER - OR A RIGHT BACK - or anything else, he is a central midfielder!




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!

The Journalist

Writer: J P Fear Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Tuesday October 6 2009

Time: 12:20PM

Your Comments

Would have given Dunne MOTM just for scoring the goal. Agree with everything else.
mattyslost
I'm glad you finally realize that Collins is a good signing.
RussianHammer
Totally agree with you about Friedel. Maybe he feels more relaxed having the new defence in front of him? Maybe he's realised how close Guzan is to the 1st team? Or maybe it's just his brand new GK kit? :-) (Footballers are a superstitious bunch after all.) I wasn't optimistic after the starting line-up was announced but what a good performance. Our best 4-4-2 display since ...
StuLinney
I really don't get all the JC bashing; he won a lot of balls but never had anyone to knock it on to cuz no one was bombing on after we scored, making him look bad perhaps but really not his fault. Think most of the Barry stuff is blown out of proportion - was pantomime rather than hate or anything, he got a good round of aplause at the end of the game which was nice.
SchoolBoyError
I thought Carew worked really hard, just didnt have a great game but put lots of effert in.
astonsteve
Why is everyone slagging off ash? are you people not watching the same games, he has been playing amazingly well except that he has 3 markers per game now due to the lack of quality elsewhere. If he went to somewhere like arsenal or god forbid united teams would not be able to allocate so many players to marking him, he'd have more space and tear teams apart.
goodb_2
For my part, I nearly cried when I saw 442 but it turned out to be a good performance. Thought the back four looked solid and only cuellar's distribution let him down. Sidwell was immense in the middle, Petrov and Milner both worked hard (ok they ran their socks off) but both had below par games by their own standards. Young was playing well until he got tackled and then spent the rest of the game looking for sympathy. Gabby was amazing, Carew was a handful for the first half but we tended to go route one too much for my liking. Heskey, well enough said.
AVbornandbred
I have to say, JF, 6 is a bit on the harsh side for Warnock. Confident, surging runs and excellent in defence. If he plays as well as last night, he's got to be in with a chance for South Africa. Cashley Hole is ( I hate to say it) a class apart, but is Wayne Bridge any better than Warnock? Not on last night's showing.
Rawlie
Some of you guys talk rubbish!
Blitz
Why did we have 2 fullbacks on the bench ( OR ANYONE ELSE FOR THAT MATTER.) MON was always going to bring on his 2 favourites no matter what injuries we had or what tactical changes (LOL) were needed. ******** pathetic not to see Albrighton get a game when Ash is injured. What is the point of having back-ups. Heskey has had too many chances and he is a waste of space. Carew may have had an off day but he still did more than Heskey ever does. Citeh were there for the taking and looked average at the back.
Villan444
Carew played well.. He was running everwere. Gabby and him was all over ManCity defence.!
Blitz
yeah, said similar Rawlie, have a look at the bit of waffle under the rating, as the ratings were by Deano, thought I'd take someone elses for a change.

Not sure others / me talk rubbish Blitz, isn't footie all about opinions?
The Fear
Not sure people are overly bashing JC, Schoolboyerror (great username by the way!) just think it is pretty clear he's not hit form yet, if and when he does, if he does, great as he can be unplayable. Listening to Big Ron on WM the other week (Blackburn) he was saying similar, that the least you'd expect is the player to jump for the ball, MON shouted the same to him at home v Cardiff. Thing is though, I do think maybe he is being asked to come deep which then looks strange as I would always be looking for a striker to be terrorising the box and they can't score from midfield. Hopefully he'll click soon

Yes Russian Hammer, Collins is settling in very nicely, didn't see anyone against the signing or moaning if memory serves me right, just most of us / many of us at least hadn't paid much attention so it didn't dazzle but VERY impressed with him and the fact he is only 25 ish is great also, as he can be at the centre of our defence for many years to come!
The Fear
I thought Young deserved more than 4 and gave Zabaleta a hard time.
Buzz Lightyear
Agree with all the scores but one. I would have given Sidwell a 4 as he was simply dreadful last night. Tom 'C' Ross was saying how well he and Petrov ran the midfield last night; must have been watching a different game to me, Sidwell was dire. Good performance last night though and if we can get everybody firing on the same day, we can beat anybody. Nice to see O'Neil bite the bullet and play Reo-Coker as well.
juddy
Sidwell was *****e, I agree with the poster who said Young can not do anything because he is being doubled and tripled. Do you guys not notice that when he gets it, there is one player stepping to, the other is trailing about five yards behind him on the inside and another player steps behind the first defender. He has absolutely no where to go. You would think that teams wouldnt do this but they realize he is the only quality attacker so they dont mind leaving Heskey, Carew, Sidwell, Petrov open to pass to. I feel for Young, I also believe that if he had a team where he could be marked man to man then he would be on fire again. It sucks when everywhere you look you have a player three yards from you, not even Messi or Ronaldo could deal with that. Also....Heskey....really? no albrighton, NRC(earlier), delph, even Fonzo before feckin Heskey.
All hail MON
Maybe when Downing comes in we could try him on the left and young in the free role behind gabby. Harder to mark that way.
Thom85
Well, marvellous, wasn't it, isn't it? Good team, up for the battle, 4-4-2 was it, or 5-4-3-2-1 Thunderbirds are go, Ahhh Young boys, jumpers for goalposts, Saturday lunch time, got to go, Mums just called me in for food, has the wrestling started yet mum? No! still Dickie Davies waffling about the latest result at Aintree, Dickie Dunne nodding one past the goalie Given half a chance, but couldn't stop it, Marvelous!
steff_the_villan
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Pride of Lions 872
2. The Fear 775
3. ClivetheVillan 310
4. Barney2004 245
5. Villan57 226
6. Villan Of The North 202
7. tarzan 193
8. sirdennis 192
9. BlackCountry Villa 184
10. Sussex Villan 181

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
11. Crystal Palace 34 12 4 18 -14 40
12. West Ham 34 10 7 17 -9 37
13. Hull City 33 10 6 17 -6 36
14. Aston Villa 33 9 7 17 -14 34
15. Swansea 34 8 9 17 -5 33
16. WBA 33 6 15 12 -11 33
17. Norwich 34 8 8 18 -27 32

Breaking League News

Possible NUFC Line Up v Swansea
Newcastle : 19/04/2014 10:27:00
Liverpool: Lawro Predicts Norwich Result
Liverpool : 19/04/2014 08:49:00
Manchester City vs West Bromwich Albion
Man City : 19/04/2014 08:38:00
FAWSL Highlights: Liverpool 1-0 Man City
Man City : 19/04/2014 08:04:00
Adams Gives Injury Update
Norwich : 19/04/2014 07:00:00
Ole Looking For Back To Back Victories
Cardiff : 18/04/2014 22:35:00
Gunnarsson Has Full Support & Trust
Cardiff : 18/04/2014 22:22:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Villa v Southampton will:
Suggested By:  Mystic Mug
Win 34%
Lose 46%
Draw 20%