Aston Villa - Glensider Away At Hull
UK time is: 08:52:17
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Hull 0 - Aston Villa 1

KC Stadium


Attendance: 24 727

Glensider Away At Hull

I'm not altogether sure that we were fully up for the long trek up to Humberside as we set off from Brummagem earlier this afternoon. The Christmas festivities and celebrations having taken their toll on each and every one of us in varying ways these past few days, but, the lads were back in action, hoping to reclaim fourth spot from north Londons finest, so duty called, work has to take a back-burner, and for the final time in 2008, we were back on the road again.

At least all four of us were as one when it came to our predictions for the game ahead, all going for a relatively comfortable Villa victory, and that united front has to have been a first so far this season. I'm not sure whether that vote of confidence in the lads is a good thing though. Its always when we're expecting a thoroughly enjoyable away-day that we seem to suffer the unexpected set-back, a dis-jointed performance, and find ourselves enduring a miserable and disappointing drive home.

If we thought it were somewhat on the bracing side as we left Brum, it was decidedly mediterranean here compared to the frigid temperatures that greeted us up in Tiger Country. Fortunately all four of us had traveled prepared, all sporting new attire recently acquired from gift-giving loved ones. Memo to the wife. Add a couple of fur-lined jock straps to the sweaters and socks next Christmas, will you?

Martin certainly didn't spring any surprises on us, sensibly going with the great bunch of lads that were so unfortunate not to see off Whining Wengers lot on Boxing Day, so the 'Good Guys' lined up as follows:-

Brad in goal, Nige, Curtis, Zat, Luke at the back, James, Stilyan, Steve, Gareth the skipper again (good to see him back in that role again) and Ash across the middle, and Gabby as per usual, creating havoc up front.

On the subs bench we had the usual crew of Guzan, Salifou, Delfouneso, Harewood, Shorey, Osbourne and Gardner.

Their line-up consisted of ex-Villan Boaz Myhill in goal, the 50 year old (surely?) Nicky Barmby in midfield, and nine others who to be honest, I've never heard of.

On the bench though was Geovanni, which I found somewhat surprising, along with Marlon King and the ex-Bolton stalwart Giannakopoulos. No place anywhere for that other Villa old-boy George Boateng, you know, that other guy who couldn't wait to exit Villa Park to better himself, and abruptly headed off to Middlesbrough! {He was out following a training ground injury JF}

Clearly their omission was a continuation of Phil Browns rant against his team's first half performance in Manchester on Boxing Day. For a team so clearly short on premiership quality though, I can't help but feel that he's cutting off his nose to spite his face, in what are clearly becoming worrying times for Hull City Football Club.

Great atmosphere in house at The KC Stadium. I don’t know whether that translated to the tv screen, but give the home support their due, they were certainly ready and willing to get behind their team. Plaudits too for the Villa contingent. We once again journeyed in numbers, and once again fully contributed to the volume of noise created.

The home side started brightly, and had the ball in the back of our net inside the opening five minutes, but fortunately referee Bennett disallowed the effort, ruling that Barmby had impeded Brad Friedel, before Nigel Reo-Coker got a final touch to put the ball into our net.

The challenge on Brad looked innocuous enough to me, but I wasn't going to complain too long and loud.

A lot of strong tackles were flying in during the opening exchanges, as we attempted to get ourselves into the game, mainly by getting Ashley involved more, but it wasn't until the thirty minute mark that anyone was yellow carded, Hull defender Zayatte booked for fouling Gabby.

Ironically enough, the man who was destined to become our hero late on, and I'm talking about Zarate here, was lucky to stay on the pitch a short while after his booking, when once again he barged into Gabby, but escaped this time with a talking to from referee Bennett.

Definitely a scrappy first half. Neither side really looking particularly threatening, although I did think that we'd slightly shaded it, and looked to have enough in reserve to hopefully step up a gear and return home to Brum with three more points in the bag.

No changes at the break, both managers clearly happy enough with what they'd seen, but most of us in the Villa end seemed to think that the game had 0-0 written all over it, unless someone could conjure up the bit of quality and magic that had been clearly lacking throughout the first forty-five.

Gareth got himself booked shortly after the restart, but that was the only real action of note, neither keeper having yet to make a save.

The first effort on target, and I use the word 'effort' somewhat loosely, was a Gareth Barry shot through a ruck of players, comfortably collected by Myhill.

We weren't playing well, there was no escaping the fact, but we have that uncanny knack of riding our luck, and creating something out of nothing to collect the points. Not a bad habit to have.

Hull started to look the side more likely to break the deadlock, yet with two minutes of normal time remaining, Ash broke clear on the right to put in one of his trademark wicked crosses, crosses that invite someone, one of our lads, the opposition, anyone, to get a touch, and send the ball into the back of the net.

Poor old Zayatte, lucky to still be on the pitch, was the unlucky individual who got the final touch to this beaut. 1-0 to Marts lads, cue celebrations on and off the pitch.

The drama though wasn't over, Michael Turner sending a header clipping against the crossbar, only for referee Bennett to point to the penalty spot, believing that Ashley had palmed the ball over the top.

Pandemonium ensued, before Bennett reversed his decision, after consulting with a linesman.

So, another three points on the road, three points gained from a decidely below par showing. Weren't we saying that after Upton Park though? Clearly we're doing something right.

So back to Brum we travel, up early for work, then prepare ourselves for the trip to Gillingham on Sunday.

Into the new year we go, fourth in the table, everything to play for. What an exciting 2009 it promises to be.

Happy New Year to all, and I'll leave you with my marks out of ten from the game:-

Player Ratings

Brad Friedel - 6


Nigel Reo-Coker - 5


Curtis Davies - 6


Zat Knight - 6


Luke Young - 7


James Milner - 6


Gareth Barry - 7


Stiliyan Petrov - 6


Steve Sidwell - 6


Ashley Young - 7


Gabby Agbonlahor - 6


Craig Gardner

Craig - on for Sidwell late on, not on long enough to evaluate.

The Journalist

Writer: Glensider Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Wednesday December 31 2008

Time: 10:07AM

Your Comments (oldest first)

Change to most recent first
Great report Mr Sider of the Glen. Sounded like it was freezing there, I know Deanovilla text'd me saying he'd never been so cold in his life ! Thought that was the worst game I've ever seen Gareth Barry play - and I love Gareth Barry (in a manly football way obvioulsy cough cough!!!!!!!!) but hey, another three points, fantastic way to enter the New Year. Long may the luck continue in the games we don't play particularly well in!
The Fear
Report Abuse
31/12/2008 10:12:00

I agree, Gareth needs someone to give him a kick for these games against so called weaker opposition. He very rarely plays like he can when not against the top sides which is a shame. If he gave it a proper go at it every game I'm sure we'd see him boss most midfield's about and make it look easy. The crowd sounded great, I guess because its a small stadium (and we've got amazing away fans of course) and the fans are so close to the pitch they were caught by the microphones. Sounded great. How many villans were there last night?
Report Abuse
31/12/2008 10:20:00

I don't often disagree with you GS, but having the benefit of seeing the game from a TV point of view I couldn't possibly agree with the rating of 6 for Steve Sidwell. He spent the entire game chasing shadows, lost out on alot of balls he could have done more with, and won about two and a half headers the entire game-all only my opinion, of course. I'd love to see him dropped and for Craig to get a run out, even if only for a few games.
Report Abuse
31/12/2008 10:50:00

Steve Sidwell. was the worst player in a Villa shirt, I just dont think hes that good.
Report Abuse
31/12/2008 11:55:00

I thought Zat Knight had a solid game at the back. Put in some really good challenges and blocks. He is prone to the odd mistake (a couple of slices) but other than that - I was pleased with him. Apart from his cross for the goal - Ashley was really poor and lots of his free kicks and corners didn't get past the first defender.
Report Abuse
31/12/2008 12:30:00

Funny how things look different on TV , GB was awefull worst game I've ever seen ( and I'm a GB fan )! I thought the much maligned Zico Knight was MOTM again if it's possible to pick one . Petrov tried hard but was left with no movement. A truly woeful performance but we'll take 3 points ! Team needs some fresh legs Mr O'Neill before we start to slide
Report Abuse
31/12/2008 12:33:00

I'd have to agree with the comments on Sidwell - very poor in the first half and completely anonymous in the second. Personally I thought that Zat Knight was outstanding and probably my man of the match - defended well without switching off at any point and made Cousin look like a fool when he tried to barge Knight away from the ball, but he stepped back and Cousin threw himself to the ground! :-)
Report Abuse
31/12/2008 12:34:00

Hey Glensider, get this... I would've given Petrov at least a 7 yesterday, I though he played really well. Finally showing what he can do. Great report Kev!
Report Abuse
31/12/2008 14:08:00

Gareth Barry is doing a Captains job very well by getting stuck in and getting the ref to speak to the lino etc. He also calmly took the penalty last week so he deserves some credit even if he doesn't look as though he is on top form.
Report Abuse
31/12/2008 14:24:00

I have to agree that even though Gareth did not play that well his Captains actions got us all 3 points so ive voted him man of the match
Report Abuse
31/12/2008 15:17:00

I can see why people are saying we were poor, but let us not forget that Hull played a 4-5-1 at home and basically refused to pressure the ball outside their own half. It is very difficult to play against a team that plays that way AWAY from home, let alone at home. Our midfield three were up against five and had no space to operate. Hull set out to draw this game 0-0 and salvage some confidence - can't blame them for that. The only players that ever had time on the ball were Zat and Curtis - says it all really. This was a match crying out for a big strong target man like John Carew who could get on the end of those long hopeful balls from the back and draw some attention away from Ashley and Gabby.
Report Abuse
31/12/2008 15:20:00

I though Barry and Sidwell were awful and I'm a big fan of both. Zat Knight was by far MOTM for me.
Report Abuse
31/12/2008 15:57:00

Not sure what NRC did wrong to be given the worst rating. I thought others were far more disinterested.
Report Abuse
31/12/2008 16:40:00

For the record, this is not the General, but his son, who unknowingly used a PC that he had signed in on at my house. I have no idea how my father would rate the players.
Report Abuse
31/12/2008 16:42:00

Great report as ever Glensider. I got up early (7AM in Aussie) to watch the game and was to be frank disappointed with the first half, I thought we kept possession well enough but just couldn't get enough space behind them to exploit Gabby's fast n furious running. The slow-mo replay we had showed Ashley clearly didn't get a hand to the ball, but as I've heard someone else say already, the ref is supposed to consult his linesman *before* awarding a penalty and didn't - so I'm sure the Hull fans were aggrieved in seeing the decision reversed once he did so. All said and done though, another 3 points nicked, another result for the mighty Villa, back above Arsenal and with some games coming up we most definitely should win. UTV :)
Report Abuse
31/12/2008 16:43:00

Very reassuring to see that my views on the players performances - exactly match the collective summation of all the above. Glensider always great reports - but very different views on the individual performances. I thought Barry was awful, only interested in falling over and putting 75% effort in rather than 110%. Sidwell was very poor too. Man of the Match for me was Petrov who was busy busy busy, always trying to be constructive, and generally keeping possession - the only one of the midfield that you ould say this about. Friedl was surprisingly off form in his handling - even if they were both infringements there was insufficient contact to cause him to drop the ball. FA cup this weekend, and it will be interesting to see if we field a strong team or not. I hope we do and go all out to win it - it remains a huge missing part of the trophy cupboard for nearly all Villa fans and always a competition worth going for. Some changes would be understandable - but keep it strong and just change 2 or 3 to give others who desrve a game a look-in (and rest those who deserve resting). Thus Sidwell and Barry replaced by Gardner and Rio Coker, with Young switched to the right and a rare game for Shorey. Alternatively give the Fonz a game and have Gabby, Young and Fonz with a massive show of pace and skill, with one less in the middle. Guzan could be given a game too. FA Cup (with the luck of the draw) and 4th place would do nicely please.
Report Abuse
31/12/2008 17:26:00

Villa were poor, the decisions favoured you when we had a goal disallowed for no reason and with that penalty. A poor game all round but one you were very lucky to have won.
Nottingham Tiger
Report Abuse
01/01/2009 12:17:00

Excuse me Nottingham Tiger. What penalty? I didn't see an incident that warranted a penalty, must have missed that. Get over it Nottingham Tiger, I'd start concerning yourself with the relegation fight ahead if I were you. We were way, way below par, no denying that, but your lot, with a much improved performance according to even your own manager, didn't for one minute look capable of beating us.
Report Abuse
01/01/2009 16:34:00

i was at the game, sitting with the home fans, and took alot of restraint not to celebrate when we scored as i was right next to our fans. the game, was well pretty poor! It was quite noticable I thought that Hull set out to be solid, and not get beaten badly again which my mate who is a season ticket holder at Hull agreed with. They let curtis and zat have the ball at the back, and sat deep which worked very well. I thought some of the passing looked good, but didnt come to alot, however you do see man u, liverpool, chelsea playing similarly against opposition that set out to defend. I think we missed big john, or a physical striker but thats nothing we dont know already in these kind of tight games. I have to say we did look pretty solid though, as they were a threat from set pieces, and I think Turner is a quality player who will get brought by a bigger club at the end of the season I have to agree about Sidwell, was pretty anonymous as I only noticed he was playing about half an hour into the game. However, I think that was dictated by the game as he strikes me as more of a Lampard, Cahill ect. type of midfielder, who really shows his worth getting into the box from midfield to support with some crutial goals, as apposed to your barry/petrov style midfielder.
Report Abuse
01/01/2009 19:03:00

Ckrulak or son, I've explained on the forum a few times exactly how I reach my ratings. There's four of us travel, and we all vote when journeying home, marks out of ten for each players performance. I then divide by four to give me the actual rating score that I post. Its all of course a matter of opinion, and although all long term Villans of forty years standing, we all still regularly see games, individual performances, tactics, team selections, etc etc., very differently. My ratings aren't 'expert' comment, merely the views of four Villans who although having watched the same game, often see it very differently. Obviously everyone is free to disagree with my observations, thats what its all about, and if the four of us disagree so regularly, then rest assured, there will be a lot of disagreement amongst fellow VV members.
Report Abuse
02/01/2009 16:00:00


Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Pride of Lions 608
2. The Fear 327
3. ClivetheVillan 295
4. Fulford 255
5. sirdennis 202
6. JuanPabloAngel 187
7. revdpete 184
8. DeanoVilla 149
9. Wurzel 119
10. Silhillvilla 104

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
14. WBA 25 7 8 10 -9 29
15. AFC Bournemouth 25 7 7 11 -12 28
16. Swansea 25 6 9 10 -9 27
17. Newcastle 25 6 6 13 -18 24
18. Norwich 25 6 5 14 -20 23
19. Sunderland 25 5 5 15 -19 20
20. Aston Villa 25 3 7 15 -20 16

Aston Villa Fixtures (view all)

Breaking League News

Spurs In Town
Man City : 13/02/2016 08:02:00
The West Ham Preview
Norwich : 13/02/2016 07:00:01
Set Piece Analysis 2/2 - Defending Corners vs WBA & Palace
Swansea : 12/02/2016 22:31:01
Oviedo given new contract
Everton : 12/02/2016 20:24:00
Liverpool: Stats Preview 15/16 - Aston Villa (Away)
Liverpool : 12/02/2016 17:53:01

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Aston Villa v Liverpool will:
Suggested By:  Mystic Mug
Win 23%
Lose 55%
Draw 22%