UK time is: 06:33:48
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Aston Villa 1 - Manchester Citeh 1

Villa Park

22/12/2007

Attendance: 41 455

Villa v Citeh Match Report

Its been a good weekend for me, we had the Vital Villa meet up at the Holte Pub on Friday night, steak, beer and good company, then some more beer. What more can you ask for?

Then to the game on Saturday, no matter how bad the times have been at Villa, as soon as you see the stadium you can't help but get the buzz and remember WHY you bother. Now the times are a changing the excitement is higher and the atmosphere is ten times better, that all makes for a much better match day experience and is long over due.

You see, with too much beer in the system, I just ramble... Sod it, its Christmas and lets face it, most of you have lives and won't be reading this anyway!

Pie in stomach, I sat down with a mixture of optimism and trepidation, after-all, despite most of us thinking we'd win the game (or at least most around by me + the majority in our poll Win (64%), Lose (31%), Draw (5%)) we were playing a team who hadn't been out of the top five all season.

The start was a major worry, we were second to every ball and every time we got the ball we hoofed it back up to Man City to build another attack. These tactics have got to change, this is not what Champions League sides are built on, so hopefully with a few new arrivals we can see the ball played far more often where it is meant to be played, on the floor. Wasn't it Brian Clough who said if football had been made to be played in the air, God wouldn't have created grass? Probably not, it is probably a figment in my ever bemusing imagination.

The Citeh, who have fans much like us who back their team through good and bad, home and away - just that they don't talk proper like what we do (!) - ooh, Fairytale of New York has just come on.... took the lead and rightly so. At that point I thought they were going to annihilate us as they looked more like the home team with wave after wave of attacks and our boys chasing shadows.

Strangely though, as soon as their goal went in, Villa woke up and up popped the mighty John Carew to score a fantastic equaliser. He so very nearly had a second (albeit after seeing the replays having started the move by the use of his arm) which was superbly saved by Citeh's impressive young goalkeeper Joe Hart (son of Hollywood detectives Hart to Hart I believe!)

The rest of the game was Villa's for the taking if not for the fact we couldn't finish. It does appear that we still want to walk the ball into the net but the best chances and most attacking play certainly seemed to come from the mighty claret and blue. We even had a goal line clearance, or goal depending on who you listen to. Alan Hansen did a bit of tinkering on a computer and showed that it was a goal, but to be fair to the linesman, or assistant ref or whatever the heck they are called now, it would have been a tough one to give. Goal line technology anyone? Must be so easy to do and yet football remains oblivious to technology.

All in all the game wasn't a classic but it was a well contested game, although Citeh did shock me at how dirty they were at times. Is it dirty or is it just competitive? Maybe we need to start crunching in more as well?

The main person involved in the game was the referee. He was truly appalling and missed four or five fouls on John Carew, who was at one point decked near by where I sit, when he saw he hadn't been given a free kick he just looked totally bemused, laughed and got back up again. Martin O'Neill on the other hand went barmy and threw his bottle of lucazade with a rude word or two for good measure. The fourth official certainly had a busy game, bet he was dying to say to the Villa bench, 'look, it isn't my fault the ref is crap'! As Murph, who came in with me said, the ref was actually quite impressive due to the fact he was reffing the game AND inventing new rules for us at the same time.

Some have said in the forum that a draw v Citeh wasn't good enough. Said about Sunderland and I'd agree, but not Citeh, they have a canny manager who has spent the money available very well and has guided them to the top five whilst we still talk of being in transition. We missed our chance to be where they are in the summer, now all eyes are on Martin O'Neill in January, the pressure is on to bring in the quality we so desperately need - as he admitted yesterday (Villa Boss Left Cursing Luck) A right-back, a top class striker and a playmaker and we might just push in the second half of the season, especially as we have some easier home games coming up (if there is any such thing as an easy game in the Premiership)

Star Player

John Carew, starting to live up to his reputation.

Player Ratings


Scott Carson 6

Didn't really have a great deal to do, don't think he was to blame for the goal, but does need to start coming out for crosses and corners more.

Olof Mellberg 7

Please don't go Melly. Get a right-back and return Mellberg to where he is best, alongside Laursen in defence.

Martin Laursen 7

3-4 top headers to clear away threats, also got into scoring positions and more goals are bound to come for him. Quality player doing the job for two at times but was in the wrong position for the goal.

Zat Knight 6

Gets caught out too much, first time leading to Citeh goal and I just can't see why he was brought in and how he has kept his place ahead of a 9m (?) defender. Then again, what do I know?

Wilfred Bouma 6

Shreks brother did ok defensively but his distribution still leaves a lot to be desired and that is a shame after he works so hard to get the ball back.

Ashley Young 6

Effectively played out of the game for much of the game.

Gareth Barry 6

Not a vintage performance but still contributed and the one through ball he did lobbing the defenders was worth the admission fee alone.

Shaun Maloney 5.5

Not really up to speed, few nice touches, needs a run in the team to get up to speed. Would still love to see him played in a free role where he could roam around a bit.

Nigel Hokey-Cokey 6

Seems to be splitting the fans but it isn't his fault if he is told to play the holding role. Does the scruffy stuff that goes unnoticed. Should have either shot or got his pass to Gabby right in the second half though, that two on two situation should have provided Villa the winner. That said, he again got back when the defenders weren't near the ball to stop a good chance for City.

Gabby Agbonlahor 6

Was involved in the game throughout, should have buried the ball that was cleared off the line, that is the sort of chance you HAVE to take.

John Carew 8

Immense. Fouled over and over throughout the game but gave his all and was unlucky not to have had a second. Looks like he is nearing full fitness and is now showing why he came to Villa with such a big reputation. I'd have loved to have seen him play alongside Milan Baros, not be his replacement.

Stiliyan Petrov (on for Maloney on 75)

Looked ok, few good runs, hopefully he'll get back on track because before he got injured, he had started to look better.

Manager Rating

Martin O'Neill. Eyes on Martin in January, got to shore up this squad otherwise we'll finish 7-9th. The man is amazing, he looks like he is kicking every ball, living every moment, he never stands still, he just lives it. Got well fed up with the ref and (sorry Martin) that was quite entertaining to watch - in between shouting at the ref ourselves obviously!

Must admit I thought he would have brought on Harewood with 15 minutes to go to see if he could offer anything fresh. Not sure why he was bought as he hasn't had a look in since arriving.

Opponent Rating

Sven Goran-Eriksson. Deserves a round of applause for looking like a bank manager and yet pulling Ulrika! Bought well, got the team playing a tough game but a passing game. That is how football should be.




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!

The Journalist

Writer: J P Fear Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Sunday December 23 2007

Time: 12:32PM

Your Comments

"the ref was actually quite impressive due to the fact he was reffing the game AND inventing new rules for us at the same time" this ref was odd and crap in equal measure. Made some appalling decisions. He seemed to let crunching 'fouls' go, which was beneficial to Reo-Coco, especially first half, but would buy any kind of dive. Elano only had to topple over and he'd get a foul, but Carew would battle through several hearty fouls only to get nothing or worse to have the foul go against him. Similar with other players too. I was surprised at how dirtty Vassell was! Never been a good tackler but he was never this dirty when playing for us, was he! I enjoyed the game and am surprised we didn't win. Gabby should've buried the header and NRC should've passed to him ealrier than he attempted. But we'll give Chelsea a game and with Terry and toehrs out we have a decent sniff!
Jongekki
nice report summed it up perfectly except I would only change one thing. I thought Zat Knight played much better than a 6? every time they had a corner in the second half it was Zat Knight who was clearing the ball away and with some distance on the headers. And he made many crucial interventions, especially one in the second half that had me on my feet clapping where he cleared the ball the length of the field and crippled the poor man city player who got in the way. I would have given him a 7 for that tackle alone!!! :D Good result against a good side in my opinion :)
industrial_musical
Agree industrial, good result v a good team and to come out disappinted at not winning shows we had the better of much of the encounter. 6) isn't that bad a rating by the way, it is above average! Must admit the ratings are so subjective. Listened to Tom Ross on the way home, some fans were ringing in saying NRC was amazing and man of the match, others that he was awful ! Funny old game!
The Fear
first game in a while NRC never got caught in possession, so he had a good game!! I think the main reason Knight is always in the team is purely down to the fact when he's in the team set pieces are never too much of a problem because of his height. I love the match ratings defined: 1) - should be taken out and shot haha :) !!!
industrial_musical
Have to say I though Barry produced one of his best displays for a long time.
DeanoVilla
I thought Barry and Reo-Coker were excellent. Carew was outstanding. I also thought Ashley was disappointing and Gabby ineffectual. Overall I think we shaded it without having that killer instinct. Not a bad result, but I spot a worrying pattern developing. We need to turn periods of dominance into goals. That just isn't happening at the moment. Against Arsenal, Pompey, Sunderland and Citeh we had sustained periods of pressure without being able to punish the opposition properly. We're NEARLY there, but not quite.
VillaYamYam
Two points very definitely lost. We had enough of the game to have wrapped up the three points by half-time. Another somewhat sluggish start, and that is now becoming worrying. We seem to be always on the back foot from the get-go, and thats a trend that has to stop.
glensider
Must admit though that Sven has put a decent team together. They've definitely improved, and look a better team than when we played them up in Manchester.
glensider
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Pride of Lions 644
2. The Fear 608
3. ClivetheVillan 569
4. kefkat 239
5. Freeman14 196
6. sirdennis 175
7. Villan57 141
8. Sussex Villan 123
9. DeanoVilla 122
10. mike_field 97

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
10. Everton 16 5 6 5 3 21
11. Liverpool 16 6 3 7 -3 21
12. Stoke 16 5 4 7 -3 19
13. Aston Villa 16 5 4 7 -10 19
14. WBA 16 4 5 7 -5 17
15. Sunderland 16 2 10 4 -10 16
16. Crystal Palace 16 3 6 7 -5 15

Breaking League News

Southampton V Everton Match Preview
Everton : 20/12/2014 03:14:00
Team News: City v Crystal Palace
Man City : 19/12/2014 19:57:00
Pellegrini Confident Milner Will Stay
Man City : 19/12/2014 19:54:00
Team News: Hull v Swansea
Hull City : 19/12/2014 19:37:00
Dawson Out For Five-Weeks
Hull City : 19/12/2014 19:36:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Villa v Man Utd will:
Suggested By:  Mystic Mug
Win 49%
Lose 47%
Draw 4%