Vital Football

Latest Aston Villa News

Villa Back Down To Earth

Manchester City
1 - 0
Aston Villa

City of Manchester Doo Dah


Attendance: 38 363


Martin O'Neill said after the 1-0 loss to Manchester City: 'We've got a week in training now where we can work on a few things. As much as anything else, we need to work on the final ball.'

Trouble is, with the lack of an out-and-out goal scorer, we can work as hard as we want, but where will the goals come from? Some have asked, with the lack of form John Carew is showing, where was Marlon Harewood. Are things really that bad at Villa that we have to start looking to a striker who got 3 goals last season?! Anyway, the big former West Ham man was out injured on Sunday so wasn't an option anyway.

I didn't get too carried away after the great win against Chelsea so I have no intention of getting carried away after this loss, however I did think the loss illustrated exactly why we should have been spending in the close season, we don't have the firepower, we didn't have it last season and we don't have it now. Given the choice with the speed and the decent service now being created, I'd take Juan Pablo Angel and Milan Baros over what we have now any day of the week. Luke Moore is getting closer to the finished article maybe, he looks the most likely to score for us and Gabby Agbonlahor certainly has the speed, but they are still young, unproven at this level and still learning. One chain of thought says let the kids learn, wait a season or two and we'll be fine, the other says go out and buy the strikers needed. For me I'd have grabbed Jermain Defoe and sulky Nicolas Anelka, he might be a plonker but he is a plonker who knows where the goal is!

I didn't think Villa did much wrong yesterday, there weren't - Gareth Barry aside - any stand out performances but there also weren't any woeful performances. The same could be said for Manchester City, at times it was difficult to believe that they were the home team with Villa enjoying the lions share of possession and forward play. Trouble is, whilst looking at the table today, the possession stat doesn't count for anything, only goals scored and conceded do and although we were unlucky that a moment of brilliance from Johnson proved our downfall, this could well be the story of our season if we can't start to test the opponent keeper.

2 shots on target in 90 minutes is not great and that ratio will rarely bring about a win. We will no doubt be tough to beat and give plenty of teams a challenge, but I have to say I can't see where we'll get enough goals to blast us into Europe unless Big John Carew can somehow 'click' and fulfil the potential he must have - I know little about him, just that at the moment he looks average and not totally up to speed, but with a reputation like his if he can get into the scoring vibe, we may just be ok!

So yesterday against Manchester City we can in some ways come away feeling aggrieved not to get anything out of the game, but if you don't shoot you don't score (or in my case if you do shoot you don't score!) it really is that simple, especially when playing against a keeper who was flapping more than Mr Flappy of Flapsville. Darn it that the backward header by Laursen didn't go in mind you, I'd got a fiver on him at 33/1 to be the first scorer!

Up next, Everton, another tough game and another that the fans will expect something out of, especially at home.

Match Stats - Click Here

Star Player

The Villa fans.

Player Ratings

Scott Carson 6

not to blame for the goal

Olof Mellberg 6

not bad, still prefer him in the middle though!

Martin Laursen 6

missed the tackle that would have prevented the goal and had an argument with Shrek (Bouma)

Zat Knight 6.5

looks a useful addition to the team making a few important tackles.

Wilfred Bouma 6

nothing bad, nothing great.

Ashley Young 6

none of the real attacking, penetrating form we've seen so far this season.

Gabby Agbonlahor 5.5

pace but his final ball is way off.

Gareth Barry 7

a real captains performance, deserved a few more around him to put in the same.

Nigel Hokey-Cokey 5.5

surprisingly anonymous.

Luke Moore 6

most likely to score for us but not likely without a shot.

John Carew 5

got more involved but when he got his chances, he fluffed his lines, with chances at a premium, top strikers don't do that.

Maloney (on for Carew 66)

Didn't really get much of the ball.

Gardner (on for Hokey-Cokey on 82)

Made one important block otherwise Johnson might have scored a second.

Petrov (on for Bouma on 82)

Not enough time to make an impact but looks nervous on the ball.

Writer:J P Fear
Date:Monday September 17 2007
Time: 12:40PM

Best of Vital Network


I don think MoN could really go out and buy a big name first choice striker in the transfer window because Carew and Luke and Gabby needed more time to prove themselvs when he signed Harewood it was made clear that he would have to force his way into the team.Listening to what MoN said yesterday he is running out of patience now and come the next window Carew and Luke would have had their chance.
17/09/2007 12:47:00
I couldn't understand why the substitutions were made so late. At 82 minutes they were never going to have any impact on the game.
Hoss The Villain
17/09/2007 12:48:00
I cannot understand why on earth you sold Baros !!!
17/09/2007 12:53:00
We could have been 2/3 up within the first 30 minutes....but just not clinical enough in front of goal yesterday. I think all will be fine lets wait and see the performance in the next game. Why is JC scoring at will for Norway?
17/09/2007 12:53:00
Agreed Hoss........65 mins is time to do it in my opinion......but so many managers do it, don't understand why. We were missfiring all over the pitch, but still looked better than they did....they are riding high on luck at the moment, why keep playing Gabby on the wing tho ?? surely Maloney and Young on the wings is a better proposition. We needed Berger yesterday, someone to take hold and produce a killer's he doing, is he still injured ??
17/09/2007 12:58:00
Whats the story with Salifou has anyone even seen him in Birmingham yet?
17/09/2007 13:17:00
Did you notice Coker going off with the hump. He will cause loads of probs if MON keeps taking him off. Whats happened to Hommer Harewood he could have got your team out of trouble yesterday.
17/09/2007 14:12:00
We missed the clinical finish, I do think JPA would do better with the crosses coming this season. The delivery was great all day, Barry and Young were excellent. No striker its that simple, I am in 2 minds you have to let Gabby, Luke and Ash grow but we need goals and big John simply is not doing enough. I also dont like all the moaning that Luke was doing, play the game.
NY Villa
17/09/2007 14:17:00
O'Neill in deflection mode. Anyone see Carews shot that hit the corner flag, the header that went wide, the dribble that left him tamely flicking the ball right footed into the keepers arms when a left foot shot might have done it. Did you see Laursens 3 headers all go well wide, Moore's hand ball that ended in the net, Gabby's two lame shots that went wide, Reo Coker being caught and tackled when through, Carew's run on goal between 2 defenders when he was caught and the ball taken easily from him, the numerous flaps by Schmeichel from crosses. No, join the O'Neill club he didn't either.
17/09/2007 14:23:00
So what you are saying avfc48 is we created a lot but didn't have a killer instinct to put the ball in the net... a lot simpler to say :-)
Hoss The Villain
17/09/2007 14:35:00
Page 1/4
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4

Login to post a comment

Site Journalists

J P Fear
Editor email
Mike Field
Editor email
Steve Wade
no email
JuanPablo Angel
no email
no email

Current Poll (see more polls)

Villa v PNE will:
Suggested By: Mystic Mug
Win - a nice bounce back76%
Lose - gulp12%
Draw - meh!0%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites
Write for Vital Football
Latest F1 News
McLaren struggling to hide enthusiasm for 2018
Latest Vital Boxing News
Groves Place in WBSS Final in Doubt
The Vital Football Members League

Recent Aston Villa Results (view all)

Aston Villa Fixtures (view all)

Vital Members League Table

1.Pride of Lions363
2.The Fear358
6.Melon Donkey145
Vital Football Comment