UK time is: 10:54:35
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Everton 4 - Aston Villa 1

Goodison Park

18/03/2006

Attendance: 36,507

Illness or Malaise? 4-1

So how do you judge that one?

We have injuries - Angel, Berger, Baros and obviously Laursen.

And we have viruses - Phillips, Milner, Hughes (off after 28 mins), Hendrie and maybe more that we don't know about.

So to judge that performance on the players on the field all being fit is one thing, but if some of them are carrying knocks/virus and were willing to play for the cause, well, it makes it just that bit more difficult.

O'Leary said after the game that he knows what he wants to do, but he'll have to wait and see. The suggestion is a lack of money and the 'takeover' situation being the main cause of our problems.

We have a Denmark international keeper. Holland and Sweden international defenders, two other defenders who have played for the England U21's and one who plays for Ireland. Not that bad a defence is it? Well yes, today it was. In fact it was more than bad, it was dire. Now is Ellis to blame for that? Not really. He is to blame for the lack of cover, but lets not let the manager continually hide behind the situation that we all know about.

Everton will not get four easier goals than they got today, the only surprise is that they didn't get more.

The game started slowly and was fairly tame for ten minutes, then a free kick from Everton's own half was floated forward, Beattie beat Ridgewell to the ball, no other defender put in a challenge and he headed to McFadden, lovely finish, 1-0 thank you very much. Bouma was just left standing and no defender closed down or marked McFadden.

Villa then rallied, a Steven Davis shot was cleared off the line by Naysmith. Villa floated a corner over for debut boy Gabriel Agbonlahor to neatly head, only to be cleared off the line again, then Davis took another shot to be, yup, you've guessed it, cleared off the line, this time by Cahill.

Everton nearly caught us on the break with a decent shot by Osman which Sorenson parried away instead of holding. It could have gone anywhere, lucky for Villa this time it didn't go straight to an opponent.

A few minutes later and our defence once again fell apart, in fact they were left standing. A throw in reached Beattie. It reached Beattie because he was keen, eager and determined. None of those words would apply to any of our defenders today. So Beattie won the first ball and flicked it on, Ridgewell completely missed the ball which went to Cahill to slot in. Bouma was once again left standing and no other Villa player was challenging. Dire man marking, dire cover and a total lack of understanding. They basically missed the first, second and third ball. 2-0 and to all intents and purposes, game over. Bouma picked up a nasty cut in a collision (after the ball had gone in!) and had to go off for stitches. Hughes then had to go off as he was struggling with a virus. On came Jlloyd Samuel.

Ooops, 3-0. Jlloyd was beaten for pace and failed to put a tackle in, the Everton player (missed who it was) crossed it in, Ridgewell once more missed it and Bouma was again miles away. Bang, Osman, goal number 3.

And that was only the first half!

The second half Villa came out and tried to make a game of it. Our man of the match was Gabriel Agbonlahor, although it has to be said, the competition wasn't stiff. He scored an excellent goal from a wide angle following a pass from Hendrie, who I have to say looked fairly lively. The goal was class and this young lad (19) has a bright future. Villa did then huff and puff and try to break Everton down, with more luck we could have made the end interesting, but unfortunately we ended up getting caught on the break for Cahill to get a brace and the humiliation was complete.

Plenty of O'Leary out chants were heard, Ellis was watching on thoughtfully. Would be nice if the Chairman sacked himself and took the manager with him. In a straight choice I'd still prefer Ellis gone, he has brought the club to its knees, or 14th anyway, but if a new lot ever do come in, I just hope they clear the decks and start again, either that or give O'Leary shed loads of cash, as he has proved he isn't a tactician or a motivator of players, he is what he said he wasn't - a cheque book manager.

I won't rate the players, on today's performance I don't rate them! But it is impossible with a virus doing the rounds to know who was truly paying at their 'peak' and who was trying for the cause but failing due to illness. The game next week against Fulham could prove crucial, lets just hope we get a few players back to fitness, either that or hope that other results go our way, we are nearly safe, but nearly isn't safe enough.




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!

The Journalist

Writer: J P Fear Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Saturday March 18 2006

Time: 3:58PM

Your Comments

you say we had a full International defence out. Sorensen was woeful and has been for 3 matches, the alternative is, Taylor who has yet to start more than once Hughes was ill as anyone who saw him live would have seen. Ridgewell is a kid whose lack of experience was exposed. He looked punch drunk when he came off at half time. Mellberg has been ill and it was rumoured at the ground only playing because there wasn't anyone else fit enough. Hendrie had been ill and only just apporved to play, McCann was sick just off the pitch and played on Where can O'leary get any more players from Gabi should never have been out there, I was overjoyed he was,what a prospect, neither should Gardener, he runs and runs but what's the point of a player who gets booked in 10 mins every game. I'm sure given a decent squad O'leary would have changed his side completely, but he hasn't. Why hasn't he. Perhaps if the fans got behind O'leary like Everton did when Moyes looked to be on the way out the issue of Ellis could be forced. Bleating incessantly on and on about another managerial failure does no more than allow Ellis off the hook. Smell the coffee and wake up
avfc48
you say we had a full International defence out. Sorensen was woeful and has been for 3 matches, the alternative is, Taylor who has yet to start more than once Hughes was ill as anyone who saw him live would have seen. Ridgewell is a kid whose lack of experience was exposed. He looked punch drunk when he came off at half time. Mellberg has been ill and it was rumoured at the ground only playing because there wasn't anyone else fit enough. Hendrie had been ill and only just apporved to play, McCann was sick just off the pitch and played on Where can O'leary get any more players from Gabi should never have been out there, I was overjoyed he was,what a prospect, neither should Gardener, he runs and runs but what's the point of a player who gets booked in 10 mins every game. I'm sure given a decent squad O'leary would have changed his side completely, but he hasn't. Why hasn't he. Perhaps if the fans got behind O'leary like Everton did when Moyes looked to be on the way out the issue of Ellis could be forced. Bleating incessantly on and on about another managerial failure does no more than allow Ellis off the hook. Smell the coffee and wake up
avfc48
That is why I said you can't judge the match without knowing who is ill??? Exactly the reason for those comments. My argument was with O'Leary saying he knows what should happen, he should have said about the illness, be clear and everyone would know what the situation was. IF we knew those players were bad then as I say in the report, you'd have to be happy that they were willing to fight for the cause. So why go on about the takeover when he could go on about Ellis not funding him, Ellis not ensuring enough cover etc? Just for once play it straight O'Leary, don't hint at things SAY EXACTLY. He isn't afraid to do that when it is about the fans, so why not about the players? It is surely simple enough to come on at the end of the game and say 'the players did well judging by the fact half of them have illnesses, Mellberg was ill, McCann was sick etc'? What is so difficult? What has their illness got to do with the takeover? I also don't think I can be accused at any time of letting Doug off the hook? Even above I say Doug is ultimately to blame and he is. Does DOL's bleating about the fans not also let Doug off the hook?
The Fear
That is why I said you can't judge the match without knowing who is ill??? Exactly the reason for those comments. My argument was with O'Leary saying he knows what should happen, he should have said about the illness, be clear and everyone would know what the situation was. IF we knew those players were bad then as I say in the report, you'd have to be happy that they were willing to fight for the cause. So why go on about the takeover when he could go on about Ellis not funding him, Ellis not ensuring enough cover etc? Just for once play it straight O'Leary, don't hint at things SAY EXACTLY. He isn't afraid to do that when it is about the fans, so why not about the players? It is surely simple enough to come on at the end of the game and say 'the players did well judging by the fact half of them have illnesses, Mellberg was ill, McCann was sick etc'? What is so difficult? What has their illness got to do with the takeover? I also don't think I can be accused at any time of letting Doug off the hook? Even above I say Doug is ultimately to blame and he is. Does DOL's bleating about the fans not also let Doug off the hook?
The Fear
Oh and yes, Sorenson was woeful, as have a few of the other defenders. My point is why are they being woeful? Samuel for instance has gone backwards season on season since DOL has come here. The shape and understanding of the defence has been poor. I agree Ridge is a kid and has plenty to learn, but if they aren't coaching them at that level how to man mark and not stand there guessing, then all really is lost. I also hate the smell of coffee, so will a peppermint tea suit the purpose!? ;-)
The Fear
Oh and yes, Sorenson was woeful, as have a few of the other defenders. My point is why are they being woeful? Samuel for instance has gone backwards season on season since DOL has come here. The shape and understanding of the defence has been poor. I agree Ridge is a kid and has plenty to learn, but if they aren't coaching them at that level how to man mark and not stand there guessing, then all really is lost. I also hate the smell of coffee, so will a peppermint tea suit the purpose!? ;-)
The Fear
Illness was obviously a factor but we had enough experience out there to not concede 3 goals in one half
dannydeeavfc
Illness was obviously a factor but we had enough experience out there to not concede 3 goals in one half
dannydeeavfc
Bad bad result , what's going wrong .
JACK_THE_LAD
Bad bad result , what's going wrong .
JACK_THE_LAD
Our defence is a shambles our midfield is so lightweight a stiff breeze could knock em' over and our finishing is pretty suspect to no wonder we are absolutly *****
Vince_AstonVilla
Our defence is a shambles our midfield is so lightweight a stiff breeze could knock em' over and our finishing is pretty suspect to no wonder we are absolutly *****
Vince_AstonVilla
Injury and illness decimating an already paper thin squad whatever, the fact is we are seriously underachieving, and that has been a season long problem. No heart, passion, commitment, desire. Tactically struggling, lack of ideas and leadership. Roll on seasons end. Its like a never ending nightmare.
glensider
Injury and illness decimating an already paper thin squad whatever, the fact is we are seriously underachieving, and that has been a season long problem. No heart, passion, commitment, desire. Tactically struggling, lack of ideas and leadership. Roll on seasons end. Its like a never ending nightmare.
glensider
If they have no desire etc or aren't motivated, how come when behind with so many out injured and so many out half fit, they still managed to fight back and put Everton and Man City and Blackburn under so much pressure in the second half of their matches?? You have to stop believing the sound bites and use that matter between your ears.
avfc48
If they have no desire etc or aren't motivated, how come when behind with so many out injured and so many out half fit, they still managed to fight back and put Everton and Man City and Blackburn under so much pressure in the second half of their matches?? You have to stop believing the sound bites and use that matter between your ears.
avfc48
Arteta beat Samuel for pace to cross ! Now that is amazing considering Arteta doesnt have any pace at all
crosswesleyanchapel
Arteta beat Samuel for pace to cross ! Now that is amazing considering Arteta doesnt have any pace at all
crosswesleyanchapel
"If they have no desire etc or aren't motivated, how come when behind with so many out injured and so many out half fit, they still managed to fight back and put Everton and Man City and Blackburn under so much pressure in the second half of their matches?? You have to stop believing the sound bites and use that matter between your ears." avfc48 We showed commitment for 10 mins against Man City and about 25 mins against Everton...if this is acceptable for you then fair enough. But for me playing badly for 80 mins and trying to cover it up with "well we really tried for the last 10 mins" just doesnt cut it, sorry.
Aronno7
"If they have no desire etc or aren't motivated, how come when behind with so many out injured and so many out half fit, they still managed to fight back and put Everton and Man City and Blackburn under so much pressure in the second half of their matches?? You have to stop believing the sound bites and use that matter between your ears." avfc48 We showed commitment for 10 mins against Man City and about 25 mins against Everton...if this is acceptable for you then fair enough. But for me playing badly for 80 mins and trying to cover it up with "well we really tried for the last 10 mins" just doesnt cut it, sorry.
Aronno7
na, we're just *****.
leelindsay
Looks like yet again another manager at villa park!
leelindsay
na, we're just *****.
leelindsay
Looks like yet again another manager at villa park!
leelindsay
Well that was just awful! As was said.... "We only went to read the programmes!"
DeanoVilla
Well that was just awful! As was said.... "We only went to read the programmes!"
DeanoVilla
avfc48, putting to good use that matter between my ears, I come to the conclusion that lifting your game for a brief spell, when the game is already lost and your opponents are cruising and going through the motions, is not what I consider passion, motivation, and desire, being shown by my team. Far from it. I stand behind my earlier comments.
glensider
avfc48, putting to good use that matter between my ears, I come to the conclusion that lifting your game for a brief spell, when the game is already lost and your opponents are cruising and going through the motions, is not what I consider passion, motivation, and desire, being shown by my team. Far from it. I stand behind my earlier comments.
glensider
avfc48, putting to good use that matter between my ears, as suggested by your goodself, I have decided that I shall stick by my earlier comments. Watching my team press forward for 10, maybe 15 minutes, against opponents that already have the game totally wrapped up, are cruising and going through the motions just to see out the 90, is not my idea of my lot showing passion, desire, and commitment. Far from it.
glensider
avfc48, putting to good use that matter between my ears, as suggested by your goodself, I have decided that I shall stick by my earlier comments. Watching my team press forward for 10, maybe 15 minutes, against opponents that already have the game totally wrapped up, are cruising and going through the motions just to see out the 90, is not my idea of my lot showing passion, desire, and commitment. Far from it.
glensider
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Pride of Lions 754
2. ClivetheVillan 725
3. The Fear 539
4. kefkat 251
5. Freeman14 207
6. sirdennis 166
7. DeanoVilla 143
8. Villan57 132
9. HeathfieldRoad1874 88
10. gator 86

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
13. WBA 12 3 4 5 -4 13
14. Sunderland 12 2 7 3 -7 13
15. Hull City 11 2 5 4 -2 11
16. Aston Villa 11 3 2 6 -11 11
17. Leicester City 12 2 4 6 -7 10
18. Burnley 12 2 4 6 -12 10
19. Crystal Palace 11 2 3 6 -6 9

Breaking League News

Liverpool: The Winds Of Change
Liverpool : 23/11/2014 10:49:00
Rooney`s Views on Arsenal Win
Man Utd : 23/11/2014 10:11:00
Shaw Added to Lengthy Injury List
Man Utd : 23/11/2014 10:06:00
Van Gaal Delighted at Arsenal Win
Man Utd : 23/11/2014 10:01:00
Not quite cutting the mustard?
Chelsea : 23/11/2014 09:55:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Villa v Southampton (home) will:
Suggested By:  Mystic Mug
Win 17%
Lose 73%
Draw 8%