Vital Football

Latest Aston Villa News

An Interview With A Sunderland Fan 1/11/12

An Interview With A Sunderland Fan 1/11/12

Who'll take their Cup form into this weekend's game at the Stadium of Light? An interview with our friends from Sunderland!

With thanks to safc123 of Vital Sunderland.


1) What are you expecting from the season and how are you finding life under Martin O'Neill?

I was expecting, perhaps hoping is realistic, that we'd improve on last season's finish of 13th place. However, after the start we've had - one win and five of our six league goals coming from Steven Fletcher (the other Demba Ba's O.G) - I'm slightly less optimistic. There's always one side that looks to have too much quality on paper everybody expects to get their act together sooner rather than later before eventually succumbing to relegation. I'm not saying it will be us, but I see few reasons why it shouldn't be us.

Martin O'Neill. Hmmm. Last season, quite clearly the messiah. A terrific start to life on Wearside, but the present run of form - one win in 16 league games is relegation from, however you dress it up. Whilst most fans won't want to admit it/allow themselves to think it, there are certainly some drawbacks to O'Neill, and a lot of things that (at the time, bitter!) Villa supporters said about O'Neill seem to be ringing true.

One of the great criticisms was his business in the transfer market. On the basis he's only paid a fee for Adam Johnson and Fletcher, there's no complaints in that department. However, he does have his favourites and when Stephane Sessegnon was dropped on Saturday at Stoke it was the first time this season. Talisman? Yes. Undroppable? No. O'Neill's willingness to change the system, style of play or any of the personnel is zero, and that's frustrating when most right-minded supporters can see the issues a mile off.

2) Were there any highlights or lowlights from your pre season?

Pre-season was, in a word, abysmal. You can't read too much into results and performances but at the same time, you want to be able to have something to build on. Defeats by Hartlepool United (now bottom of League One), Helsingborgs, Leicester City and Seongnam Chunma were far from inspiring, nor was the 1-1 draw at Derby County. If anything, pre-season highlighted our biggest weakness before the real business began - a lack of goals.

3) How do you feel your club did in the transfer window?

Very well, but. I can't say anything more about Fletcher that hasn't been said. The boy is a goalscorer and darn good one too, so no complaints. Johnson should come good, but he needs to be played on the left rather than the right (see question one!) if we are to see the best of him. Playing on the right exacerbates the fact he is so left-footed.

Carlos Cuellar and Louis Saha seem decent enough for free transfer pick-ups. I saw Saha for a substantial period for the first time this season against Newcastle and he made a big difference. We were desperately missing someone who could link the midfield and forward and he filled that role well.

4) Has anybody left who you think has seriously weakened the team?


5) Who is going to be your main dangerman when we play?

Fletcher. It's boring to say but with five of our six goals coming from him, who else was it going to be?

Seb Larsson, James McClean and the aforementioned Sessegnon and Johnson will provide a stupendous supplementary attacking quartet, once they remember where they left their form!

6) What are your weaknesses, any clues for the game will be appreciated :-)

An over reliance on Fletcher basically. With Larsson, McClean, Sessegnon & Johnson all struggling, it heaps all the pressure on the big man. Whilst he's got the ability to cope for now, he can't do it all season and God forbid he gets injured or suspended for any great length of time.

In midfield Jack Colback and Lee Cattermole are tidy ball-players but little else. Neither will play that defence-splitting pass, and although that's the difference between a lot of mid-table and top-seven teams, we are really crying out for the kind of deep-lying playmaker who can open up a game in one pass.

7) Will you have anyone out who would otherwise play?

Phil Bardsley is fit enough to resume & could make his first start since ankle surgery. That shrinking violet Cattermole is back in the side following suspension and having signed a new contract this week, I fully expect him to celebrate that in his customary fashion, picking up a straight red for a diabolical 'challenge'.

Now with a slightly more Claret and Blue angle...

8) Are you surprised to see how Villa struggled last season and do you think we will again this time round?

I wasn't surprised. You hired Alex McLeish - enough said.

Will you struggle this season? Clearly.

Darren Bent is a good striker, but like Fletcher (and any forward) he needs service. The fact that he's not getting any service means he isn't scoring & has seen him dropped. On the basis he is by far & away the best forward at the football club, that's an aberration as decisions go - that said Christian Benteke looks like he knows how to find the back of the net.

Paul Lambert has signed bang-average footballers and players for the future. That's more to do with Randy Lerner reigning in the horns than anything else, but you can't as an average side bung a load of kids in at a higher level than they're used to and expect to succeed.

A relegation scrap awaits.

9) Do you have any thoughts on Paul Lambert?

Aside from being the most dour man on the face of the planet?!

Did a fantastic job with Norwich City and clearly has something. I hope he gets time and the backing of Lerner because there's no point in hiring a fairly youthful manager and looking to change the DNA of a club if you're not going to give that person time.

10) What have you made of our youth promotions last/this season, anybody caught the eye for you?

Chris Herd looks like someone who's robbing a living & indicative of the lack of depth & genuine ability within the squad.

11) Who has stood out most from our recent acquisitions for you?

The aforementioned Benteke looks decent. I have to admit to knowing very little of him, but he's looked lively so far and scored a decent goal against Norwich City on Saturday.

12) If you could take one of our players, who would it be and why?

Bent - then we could have two good strikers entirely dependent on non-existent service!

13) Who do you see as our main threat in the game?

Benteke could be a handful, but I reckon big John O'Shea and Cuellar should be able to handle him.

14) Where would you say our current weaknesses are in terms of how you will approach the match?

Your midfield is there to be got at. Stephen Ireland is a million miles away from being the player he was a few seasons ago, whilst Fabian Delph has never really kicked on from the prodigy he was at Leeds. Brett Holman and Karim El-Ahmadi - who?!

15) Finally, a prediction please kind person...

2-0 Sunderland. We have to win.


Sunderland Forum Thread.

Vital Villa on: facebook

Vital Villa on: twitter

Join Vital Villa

It's easy to REGISTER, simply click the link and enjoy getting involved!

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:Mike Field
Date:Thursday November 1 2012
Time: 4:03PM


Cheers SAFC. I can't wish you well for Saturday though. Yes I totally get that that Sunderland fans thought it was our bitterness about MON going to Sunderland. We were like it too. Celtic and Leicester fans warned us and we just said sour grapes. We had to concede humble pie too. Thanks for your write up too. I don't agree with the score line though obviously LOL
01/11/2012 16:19:00
Good interview and he was spot on about Herd offer's us nothing except miss timed tackling !!
01/11/2012 16:20:00
Good interview. Disagree on Herd...poor bugger is a midfielder and he's been chucked into centre of defence. Think we'll win 1-0 on Saturday. To MON: "You're just a ***** Paul Lambert!"
01/11/2012 16:31:00
Q8 - Absolutely spot on safc123, couldn't of put it better myself.
Pride of Lions
01/11/2012 17:11:00
Yes another clubs fans duped by the enigma that is Martin NoDeal. Not sure how a Sunderland Fan could pick out Herd ? Is he a secret Villan ? ie studies us every week?
01/11/2012 17:28:00
Good honest interview, ouch to question 8, even the oppo can see it!
The fear
01/11/2012 18:29:00
Very very fair interview one of the best because it clearly reinforces how overrated MON is... So many similarities between the Villa of old and Sunderland at some point at Villa MON lost the plot n started taking the *****... He built a great side then he went off the rails... I firmly believe Sunderland wont beat us we are going to win 1 of the next 4 games I think this will be it... we will have no pressure on us playing away and Lambert will demand more so I think it will be enough to see us through... either that or a 0-0
01/11/2012 21:13:00
Good interview from as you would expect a realistic and down to earth Sunderland fan. He is spot on about the bitterness towards MON but the way he left produced most of that. Interesting to see him pick Gardner who he sold when at Villa Park.Have always rated Fletcher good player this should be a tight game if we can find two fit centre halfs!
02/11/2012 11:26:00
VERY harsh on Chris Herd who was one of our better performers last seasonl, has been fine filling in at CB and should be starting ahead of Delph in midfield.
02/11/2012 14:27:00
Have a lot of time for Sunderland (but not this weekend, obviously!). Remember on the old 606 some Scum fan was trying to tart around all the message boards drumming up support for a 'we hate Villa' campaign. The Sunderland lads basically told him to Foxtrot Ocar, lots along the lines of "Villa are a proper, big club with a real history, while you lot are vicious backstabbing losers". Fair play to them, other than against us. On the MON point though, he is a great galvanising force and inspires his players, but beyond that, the cupboard's empty. Thinks tactics are nice minty sweets. Will never forgive him for the way he left, but I'm sure we're exactly the team you'd want to play when you're on a good run. Wish we could play us!
02/11/2012 19:50:00
Page 1/2
  1. 1
  2. 2

Login to post a comment

Recent Aston Villa Articles

Preston Relief For Bruce

Aston Villa manager Steve Bruce has said that he has to be 'fairly pleased' that we came out of Tuesday night's encounter with Preston North End...

Video - Wolves U23s To The Slaughter At Villa's Hands

With Monday evenings heavy six one victory for Aston Villa over Wolverhampton Wanderers at Under 23 level - here are some highlights.

Villa Fan Fights Back Over Hogan Scapegoating

The Yank - rightly I think (not that anyone asked me!) - defends Scott Hogan.

The Fans Ask - The Club Answers. FCG 20/02/2018

The minutes of the meeting for the Fan Consultation Group with board members/staff members of Aston Villa.

Aston Villa Archived Articles

Vital Villa articles from

Site Journalists

J P Fear
Editor email
Mike Field
Editor email
Steve Wade
no email
JuanPablo Angel
no email
no email

Current Poll (see more polls)

Preston MotM
Suggested By: MF
Sub - Davis2%
Sub - Grabban27%
Sub - Elmohamady1%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites
Vital Football Comment
Latest F1 News
Verstappen dreading Halo introduction
Latest Vital Boxing News
Smith Gets Change of Opponent in WBSS Semi-Final
Write for Vital Football

Aston Villa Fixtures

Vital Members League Table

1.Pride of Lions448
2.The Fear418
6.Melon Donkey167
The Vital Football Members League