UK time is: 10:40:56
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Half Term School Report For New Villa Players!

A decent thread started by Deanovilla here. Early days but what are your early impressions of our new players?

See: The new signings - Half Term school report

So come on then, how have the new boys done so far? Grade them from A-F based on what you've seen so far.

Lowton - A definite improvement on Hutton, but still a little bit inconsistent. Can be a bit sloppy in possession, but likes to get forward and also in the main defends solidly. C+

Bennett - Similar to Lowton in many respects, but not seen as much of him. May well need a bit more time to settle but i think he has all the attributes to be a top player. C-

Vlaar - Committed, powerful, a leader, talks a good game.... but I've got to say I've not be overly impressed. The defence has been weak, we've let in some fairly sloppy goals, and Vlaar as the only constant has to take his fair share of the responsibilty. An improvement on Dunne and Collins? Sure. The attitude alone ensures that. The next Martin Laursen? I just can't see it myself. C-

El Ahmadi - Started the season well and you could see what he was brought for. Sit, protect the back 4 and allow the guys in front of you to play. Recently though he's gone massively off the boil in my opinion. I can recall 2 games where he has been a complete passenger, just not getting involved at all. I didn't know he was playing in one game until 60 minutes in, he was so anonymous. Needs to step it up a gear and start to stamp his authority on games. Certainly a step down from Petrov. D

Holman - Tonnes and tonnes of endeavour. You can't but help like a guy who gives 110% every game. Question marks about the quality, but if he keeps giving his all he'll be a real fan favourite. When you put him next to N'Zogbia, there's just no choice to be made. B+

Benteke - Big like Heskey, Black like Heskey, misses sitter after sitter like Heskey. The biggest disappointment of the bunch for me so far. Not writing him off, it could be a phase and suddenly they might all start flying in, but on what I've seen so far I have no choice but to give him a very disappointing D-

Join The Vital Debate




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer: Deanovilla Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Thursday October 25 2012

Time: 1:50PM

Your Comments

hope by the end of the season they are all on at least B- I might accept a few C+ 'could do better' reports as well!!!
The Fear
Good accessment there Deano. Agree re KEA he has put in a few disappointing dsplays recently. Surely Heard could do a better job. Is he fit/unfit or doesn't his face fit?
Pride of Lions
I don't think Lambert is a Herd fan. Even in pre-season it was obvious he preferred Delph, Herd hardly got a look in and since the season started has had even less of a look in.
DeanoVilla
I keep having to say to myself that although Benteke looks 30 he's only 21 . So I think D- is harsh . He's a work in progress & should be assessed as such
AstonBilla
I think those are fair assessments. I have sympathy for Benteke though. He is young, in a new country with a completely new set of surroundings and style of football. He hasn't hidden and has been in the position to miss his chances. The problem that both Lambert and Benteke have, is that we have one of the best goalscorers in the country in the squad and if Benteke plays and misses chances whilst Bent is on the bench, questions will be asked. Ultimately his all round game is more suited to Lamberts phillosophy, but goals win games and he has to deliver, young or not.
voiceoftheholte
A fair assessment but I am not sure what Benteke's skin-colour has to do with anything.
OnMeHeadFred
I think everyone deserves more time... Lambert will get it right. Benteke will hopefully settle, and then unlike Heskey, will actually be in the position to score goals rather than sloping near the half way line!!
thorpyuk
Would say Lowton will turn out to be a gem has all the makings needs the experiance. My problem with the Bentke - Bent argument is I know the lad has missed a few, but the chances do fall to him where Bent does not seem to get the chances is that down to good play by Bentke in getting the positions or is Bent a capable goal scorer just marked tighter. anyway would go with most of your assesments Deano.
Merlin128777
Agreed thorpy. He gets in the right positions despite the meagre amount of chances we create. Heskey was ten years older than benteke when we bought him and had never scored much! He needs time but looks promising I think. The fact that he gets into the excellent Belgium team speaks for his quality.
NorthcliffeBandit
I am getting very tired of the "He's just like Heskey, because he's missed s few chances and he's black. I find the black references very distasteful. Benteke is a young lad, who is adjusting to a new club, and country. He puts himself about and he is getting chances. He precious record for club and country suggests that he will start putting the chances away. The amount of times I have read, Benteke missed, Bent would have scored that. Bent wouldn't have scored because he would probably been standing around sulking with his hands in his pockets. I would much prefer Benteke to be compared with Savo than Heskey. He is the same age as when we signed Savo, he is new to the country, like Savo, he's powerful like Savo, and he's missed a few chances like Savo. The crowd got on his back too, he left us for 3m, and two years later was sold on for 18m, and he went on to have a great career. Let's support the lad, not get on his back. I would play him today, and leave the waste of space Bent on the bench. No more Heskey references please.
2big4seatswannastand
read previous not precious. sorry fat fingers, small laptop keyboard
2big4seatswannastand
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Aston Villa Articles

Lambert Speaks Following Contract Extension (Wednesday September 17 2014)

Paul Lambert Extends Villa Stay (Wednesday September 17 2014)

Robinson Loaned To Preston (Tuesday September 16 2014)

Hutton - I Want To Take This Opportunity (Tuesday September 16 2014)

Bombshell - Hutton Signs Three Year Deal (Tuesday September 16 2014)

Senderos In Team Of The Week Nod (Monday September 15 2014)

Benteke Returns To Full Training (Sunday September 14 2014)

Stats: Liverpool v Aston Villa (Saturday September 13 2014)

Archived Aston Villa Articles

List All Vital Villa Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. ClivetheVillan 472
2. Pride of Lions 468
3. The Fear 437
4. Villan Of The North 206
5. mike_field 199
6. DeanoVilla 196
7. kefkat 185
8. sirdennis 163
9. lewis1980 135
10. Juan Mourep 110

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
1. Chelsea 4 4 0 0 +9 12
2. Aston Villa 4 3 1 0 +3 10
3. Swansea 4 3 0 1 +3 9
4. Southampton 4 2 1 1 +5 7
5. Man City 4 2 1 1 +3 7
6. Spurs 4 2 1 1 +2 7
7. Arsenal 4 1 3 0 +1 6

Breaking League News

Good Luck Jonas
Newcastle : 18/09/2014 10:02:00
Martinez hoping to learn from Wolfsburg experience
Everton : 18/09/2014 10:00:00
Jags wants to skipper cup winners
Everton : 18/09/2014 09:25:00
Partizan Belgrade vs. Tottenham Hotspur.
Spurs : 18/09/2014 09:00:00
Rusty or Finished?
Chelsea : 18/09/2014 07:48:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Liverpool MotM
Suggested By:  A very happy MF
Guzan 5%
Senderos 34%
Cissokho 3%
Baker 39%
Hutton 3%
Delph 1%
Cleverley 1%
Westwood 4%
Agbonlahor 9%
Weimann 1%
Richardson 0%
Sub - N'Zogbia 0%
Sub - Sanchez 0%
Sub - Bent 0%