Vital Football

Latest Aston Villa News

Bad Transfer Window All Round? Not Just Villa?

Bad Transfer Window All Round? Not Just Villa?

Ok, so people are getting worried about the lack of transfers for Villa.

I thought I`d look how many other clubs have done good / more business. Not many really, or not any?

There is the list of moves as below. There are some who frankly, as much as I love Villa, we couldn`t get. But who have we REALLY missed out on? I`m not bothered about Sunderland paying twice as much (?) as he is worth for Fletcher for instance, are you?

I`m worried our squad isn`t strong enough, so don`t get me wrong, I`d love to see a striker, two defenders and a midfielder added, I`d love each to be bums on seats players (well, ok, not the defenders) but I can`t see it myself and think there is a new dawn coming, players fees will slowly come down as even the biggest clubs (apart from maybe Man City, although even they aren`t spending like they have) realise they can`t afford this to continue.

Fair enough our poll shows that Villa fans are worried. Seems 'right manager, not a strong enough squad` is now the call and some are still looking for a marquee signing. We might get one, but I doubt this summer. If we are struggling come January there might be movement, next summer even more, we are - AGAIN - in transition and patience (which is wearing thin for most of us I know) is going to be needed as Paul Lambert settles in, settles us down and gets us playing as he wants to.

The poll showed the worries:

Is Our Squad Strong Enough For The Season?
Poll Date: 14 Aug 2012
Suggested By: JP Fear

Still light 66%
Nowhere near strong enough 28%

Just about with luck on injuries 5%

Yes 1%

Unsure 0%

Just 1% think the squad is good enough. Strong results!

The transfers of note, I might have missed one or two, I`ve included the unrealistic but not done many of the lower league. Not sure much good business has been done anywhere, we`ve spent £8million ish? If we could get a couple more at least and maybe offload a few of the ones like Warnock, Dunne and Hutton, maybe it won`t have been too bad a window. But obviously, it has been a while since a really exciting entrance was done and surely the bums on seat player/s is where we now hang our hopes?

So far (23/08/2012)

Emmanuel Adebayor [Man City - Tottenham] £5m

Sebastien Bassong [Tottenham - Norwich] Undisclosed

Harry Bunn [Manchester City - Crewe] Loan

Alexander Buttner [Vitesse Arnhem - Manchester United] Undisclosed

Josh McEachran [Chelsea - Middlesbrough] Loan

Rodri [Barcelona B - Sheffield Wednesday] Loan

Conor Sammon [Wigan - Derby] Undisclosed

Alex Song [Arsenal - Barcelona] Undiscloses

Stuart Taylor [Manchester City - Reading] Free

Kevin Mirallas [Olympiakos - Everton] £6m

Jose Bosingwa [Unattached - QPR]

Robin van Persie [Arsenal - Manchester United] Undisclosed

Vurnon Anita [Ajax - Newcastle] Undisclosed

Louis Saha [Unattached - Sunderland]

Arouna Kone [Levante - Wigan] Undisclosed

Simon Cox [West Brom - Nottingham Forest] Undisclosed

Ryo Miyaichi [Arsenal - Wigan] Loan

Jack Rodwell [Everton - Manchester City] £12m

Joe Allen [Swansea - Liverpool] Undisclosed

Craig Bellamy [Liverpool - Cardiff] Free

Colin Kazim-Richards [Galatasaray - Blackburn] Loan

Michael Kightly [Wolves - Stoke] Undisclosed

Santi Cazorla [Malaga - Arsenal] Undisclosed

Joseph Yobo [Everton - Fenerbahce] Undisclosed

Benik Afobe [Arsenal - Bolton] Loan

Alberto Aquilani [Liverpool - Fiorentina] Undisclosed

Dickson Etuhu [Fulham - Blackburn] Undisclosed

Heidar Helguson [QPR - Cardiff] Undisclosed

Ivan Ramis [Real Mallorca - Wigan] Undisclosed

Curtis Good [Melbourne Heart - Newcastle United] Undisclosed

Steven Pienaar [Tottenham - Everton] £4.5m

Manuel Almunia [Arsenal - Watford] Free

Junior Hoilett [Blackburn - QPR] To be determined

Michael Turner [Sunderland - Norwich] Undisclosed

Tim Cahill [Everton - New York Red Bulls] Undisclosed

Oscar [Internacional - Chelsea] Undisclosed

Massimo Luongo [Tottenham Hotspur - Ipswich Town] Loan

Omar Elabdellaoui [Manchester City - Feyenoord] Loan

Hugo Rodallega [Wigan - Fulham] Free

Jan Vertonghen [Ajax - Tottenham] Undisclosed

Jose Manuel Flores [Genoa - Swansea] £2m

Park Ji-sung [Manchester United - QPR] £2m

Denilson [Arsenal - Sao Paulo] Loan

Salomon Kalou [Chelsea - Lille] Free

Jonathan Woodgate [Stoke - Middlesbrough] Free

Pavel Pogrebnyak [Unattached - Reading]

Steven Naismith [Rangers - Everton] Free

Gylfi Sigurdsson [Hoffenheim - Tottenham] Undisclosed

Paul Pogba [Manchester United - Juventus] Free

Leon Best [Newcastle - Blackburn] £3m

Danny Blanchett [Burton - York] Free

Fabio Da Silva [Manchester United - QPR] Loan

The full list so far...

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:J P Fear
Date:Thursday August 23 2012
Time: 1:19PM


Is it to do with the Fair play rules or has the Prem league teams realised they cant sustain what they are doing ?????? Except for the big money clubs that is.
23/08/2012 13:33:00
It is to do with FFP and financial market conditions and players holding out for wages clubs can no longer afford to offer.
23/08/2012 13:45:00
You must be joking I wont bother with the bigger team but Fulham, Newcastle, Everton, Swansea, Liverpool have all strengthened well... Petric is 31 but he will net 15+, Anita can play LB and CM he is excellent on the ball, Michu was the top goalscoring CM in Spain last year andthe Swans got him for 2m because Vallecano are in debt, Kevin Mirallas signed for Everton (£6) he will prob become a fine striker and was the top scorer in Greece last year I think... Liverpool might struggle again but they have they still strengthened further Assaidi is the type of player we could have got... QPR still look poor but they signed Hoillet another player we should be looking at, West Ham got Diame and Alou Diarra to solid CM's, Southampton almost had Gaston Ramirez 15m would have been a huge outlay but he's 21 and recognised as winger with massive potential... I do trust PL and Villa but the lack of activity does worry me when I see some of the players teams have brought in... I was hoping for a top 10 this year but with that squad I cant see it happening... As a Villa fan we will always talk up our own but there are some there I dont particularly rate due to the last two seasons for me its make or break for Bannan, Albie, Fonz, Delph.. if they cant perform for PL with his system which undoubtedly suits them then they will never be good enough for where we want Villa to be... If we get a LB and a CF we should be in good shape till January then may be Henke will have spotted one or two bargains which will help us push on after Xmas... Ideally thats how things will go...
23/08/2012 13:46:00
Agree with you CDX, just goes to show how poor our European network is, which is a little surprising since Houllier would have surely been onto that? (Although who knows what damage was done last season!). As for who we've missed, I'm still convinced Michael Dawson would be a great signing, even if we don't get anyone else. And Julio Cesar is looking to get out of Inter....a stronger challenge to the injury-prone Shay (who's form is also a little questionable in the last 6 months or so - poor Euros as well). I would think it will take Lambert all his powers of persuasion to sell the Villa to potential signings though - outsiders looking in for the past 3 years can't be convinced of our ambitions on the evidence...
23/08/2012 14:25:00
Still hoping PL will bring in one or two more before the window closes.
23/08/2012 15:21:00
The only deals that are worth anything in that list are: Adebayor Van Persi Anita Kone Rodwell Cazorla Ramis Vertonghen The others aren't that much to get excited over, other than those that have no link to the premiership, and really Villa have had the best transfers this transfer window, so far.
Avfc94 we do
23/08/2012 15:48:00
Oh and Podolski to Arsenal.
Avfc94 we do
23/08/2012 15:49:00
Our network will get better with Lamberts new structure in place - early days tho and we still have a lot of people to convince that we are a good place to be after the last three seasons of dross.
23/08/2012 16:04:00
This new scout should surely have some available targets already on hs books? 3 players is a minimum before the 31st Aug (LB, Winger, Striker)
23/08/2012 16:56:00
Personlly I ain't bothered what other EPL clubs are doing, I have enough to worry about with US!
Pride of Lions
23/08/2012 17:08:00
Page 1/2
  1. 1
  2. 2

Login to post a comment

Recent Aston Villa Articles

Another Massive Game. A Candle In The Wind For Villa?

Here we go again, another acid test. Which team will turn up v Bolton?

The Match Day Villa Times - Ready To Bounce Back?

The latest Aston Villa news, views and social media reviews via the uno fish ial one...

Fans React To 2nd Starlet Signing Villa Contract Extension

Hot on the heels of Andre Green signing a new Villa deal, Aston Villa have announced the extension for another U23 regular.

The Grass Isn't Always Greener. Starlet Extends Villa Stay

Well this is glorious news in my ever so humble opinion. Despite being linked to Premiership clubs, one player doesn't think the grass is always greener.

Aston Villa Archived Articles

Vital Villa articles from

Site Journalists

J P Fear
Editor email
Mike Field
Editor email
Steve Wade
no email
JuanPablo Angel
no email
no email

Current Poll (see more polls)

Villa v Bolton (away) will:
Suggested By: Mystic Mug
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites
Write for Vital Football
Latest F1 News
What do we now know about Mercedes in 2018?
Latest Vital Boxing News
Joshua Yearns for Wilder Showdown
The Vital Football Members League

Aston Villa Fixtures

Vital Members League Table

1.Pride of Lions331
3.The Fear271
6.Melon Donkey132
Vital Football Comment