Aston Villa - Should Shay Given Stay? Poll Results
UK time is: 01:32:58
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Should Shay Given Stay? Poll Results

Following a bit of transfer talk with regards to Shay Given Vital Villa asked:

Would you replace Shay Given

Poll Date: 21 Jun 2012

Suggested By: JP Fear


No 57%

Yes 35%

Unsure 8%

For me, with any player, the key is only to replace if you are replacing with better. If not, why bother? He`s a mighty fine keeper and I personally think he kept us up last season, so happy for him to remain IF he wants to.

Given kicking

Shay Given Profile.

Shay Given forum thread: Click Here

Related: Villa After Another Ruddy Keeper?!?

Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer: J P Fear Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Monday June 25 2012

Time: 4:21PM

Your Comments (oldest first)

Change to most recent first
He had a stinker at Euro 2012, then again with the exception of Keith Andrews all the Irish inc the manager had shockers. I still think Shay will give us (the Villa) a good season so no I would not sell him. COTVABU
irish villa
Report Abuse
25/06/2012 16:40:00

He has had his day, injury prone, unfit and can't command his area ..... get rid. UTV
Report Abuse
25/06/2012 16:57:00

Wouldn't take any notice of the Euros, he's still a great keeper, a couple of decent defenders in front of him and we'll be impenetrable.
Stephen Jay Hawkings
Report Abuse
25/06/2012 17:12:00

Shay has a history of making more mistakes for his country than he does for his club
Villa b
Report Abuse
25/06/2012 17:52:00

He had a stinker at the Euros? No wonder Irish Villa, no offence mate but he had so much to do due to Ireland being so shocking...He still to date has pulled off the save of the tournament against how people just say 'get rid' like he has done something wrong, give players some respect ffs. He was by far player of the season last year.
Report Abuse
25/06/2012 17:54:00

Agreed P.Avfc, some of the saves he made contributed to some of those bore draws we managed. These draws could have been defeats and we could be in the fizzy pop league by now!
Report Abuse
25/06/2012 21:28:00

I don't think he kept us up last season. On the contrary, I think he almost relegated us. We conceived the most goals from corners last season and that's primarily because he was not stepping off his line to collect the balls and was not commanding his defence. The isolated instintive save here and there would happen to cover up for his mistakes. I have no idea why we released Brad Guzan.
Report Abuse
26/06/2012 07:00:00

Report Abuse
26/06/2012 07:03:00

Sorry, Villalfred. I wholeheartedly disagree! Season before last we were hardly any good at defending set pieces and crosses. Most of the blame stops at Dunne and Collins' door.
Report Abuse
26/06/2012 07:38:00

100% keep for me. If he had a stinker at the euro's then fine but he only played in three games. If he had a bad three games in the EPL nobody would say much, just that he's lost a bit of form and will pick it back up because he's class. All great players have dips and Shay is no different. He kept us up for sure and he'll be a massive asset for us again this coming season. There's plenty of other Villa players I'd rather see the back of. UTV!
Report Abuse
26/06/2012 09:02:00

I think Shay has his faults but he also has strengths as well. He is still a top keeper and my question to those saying get rid would be and bring in who? realistically.
Report Abuse
26/06/2012 09:13:00

Have to agree with villalfred. Those who understand the goalkeeping art will know the difference between a keeper who makes a few saves for the camera and one who prevents the need for the saves in the first place. Given makes some great saves, but they are often due to a lack of command of his box. Simple stats show that we concede to many goals from within our six yard box (more than any other team). It is absolutely pointless making a save for the cameras that most other keepers would routinely make if you undo your good work by conceeding a goal every time the ball hits the 6 yard box. Get Foster immediately.
Report Abuse
26/06/2012 09:59:00

I personally think we should be replacing the back four before the keeper, but hey what do I know lol
Report Abuse
26/06/2012 10:16:00

astonmilan - how many games did Shay miss last season, y'know, being as unfit as you say he is? Was it 5, 6 games?? Pretty sure younger keepers in the league were more injury-prone than he was! Totally agree with Fear; why sell if we can't replace with better? Who exactly is there that is better than Shay whom we could realistically afford on our transfer and salary budgets?? All very well saying get rid, but in favour of who?? Ruddy?! Gilks?? Give(n) me Shay for another year over either of those two any day.
Report Abuse
26/06/2012 13:41:00

So the defence isn't too blame from the goals conceded from Corners? No?
Report Abuse
26/06/2012 17:28:00

pavfc. The defence is to blame as well? But the command of that defence (or lack of command)comes from the keeper. BristolVillan. Foster???
Report Abuse
27/06/2012 08:19:00


Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Aston Villa Articles

Something For The Weekend (500) (Sunday August 30 2015)

Sherwood Gives Sunderland Thoughts (Saturday August 29 2015)

Audio - Sherwood On Sunderland Draw (Saturday August 29 2015)

Stats: Aston Villa v Sunderland (Saturday August 29 2015)

Aston Villa v Sunderland - Team Sheets (Saturday August 29 2015)

Pre Sunderland Injury Update (Friday August 28 2015)

The Aston Villa Injury Table Updated (Friday August 28 2015)

Archived Aston Villa Articles

List All Vital Villa Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Pride of Lions 1246
2. ClivetheVillan 675
3. The Fear 542
4. Bonker 329
5. kefkat 326
6. Fulford 309
7. DeanoVilla 260
8. Villan57 225
9. sirdennis 223
10. thefacehead 223

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
9. Everton 4 1 2 1 1 5
10. Southampton 4 1 2 1 0 5
11. AFC Bournemouth 4 1 1 2 -1 4
12. Aston Villa 4 1 1 2 -1 4
13. Chelsea 4 1 1 2 -3 4
14. Norwich 4 1 1 2 -3 4
15. WBA 4 1 1 2 -3 4

Aston Villa Fixtures (view all)

Breaking League News

Good News - Montero Injury Nothing Serious
Swansea : 30/08/2015 23:42:00
The KDB conundrum
Chelsea : 30/08/2015 23:25:01
Rate The Players: Swansea City 2-1 Manchester United
Swansea : 30/08/2015 22:11:00
Swansea : 30/08/2015 21:25:00
Monk's Tactical Masterstroke Helps Swans Beat United
Swansea : 30/08/2015 21:11:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Sunderland MotM
Suggested By:  Site Staff
Guzan 3%
Hutton 1%
Richards 1%
Clark 0%
Amavi 1%
Westwood 1%
Sanchez 26%
Gueye 28%
Bacuna 0%
Gestede 0%
Sinclair 38%
Sub - Gil 1%