Aston Villa - The Vital Villa Manager Short-List
UK time is: 15:10:35
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

The Vital Villa Manager Short-List

Firstly, a big thank you to Randy for quickly resolving a situation that was driving a wedge between the club and fans. Rapid and decisive action was needed and that's what we got. The relief amongst the fan base is tangible and we all feel like a weight has been lifted from our shoulders.

Now down to business.

The Vital Villa members have taken part in the new manager poll in their droves and the results are in. At the time of writing there have been over 1,500 votes cast and in first place on the Vital Villa manager short list is.....*drum roll*......brace yourself for a huge surprise...

It's Paul Lambert!

Paul Lambert had a very successful career as a player, starting his medal collection at the tender age of 17 after winning the Scottish Cup with St Mirren in 1987. He stayed there for 8 years before signing for Motherwell. A year later a bright young manager by the name of Alex McLeish took over the Motherwell job and they finished second in the table, their highest position since 1934, and qualified for the UEFA cup.

The UEFA cup run ended in the second round after the 'Well were knocked out by Borussia Dortmund after pushing them all the way. Ottmar Hitzfeld saw something he liked in the defensive midfielder and signed him for the German club.

Lambert spent just over a year at Dortmund, but what a year it was. He was instrumental in Dortmund's Champions League win in 1997, helping to see off Manchester United in the semi-final and Zidane's Juventus in the final.

At that time Rangers had won 9 league titles in a row and Wim Jansen bought Lambert in for Celtic to help halt that run and launch a successful period for Celtic. He won 4 league titles, 2 of each domestic cup and a UEFA cup runner-up medal.

He also won 40 international caps and was inducted into the Scottish Hall Of Fame in 2009.

Paul qualified as a coach in 2005 and took his first managerial job at Livingstone in June of that year. It didn't go well and he resigned the following February after winning just 5 out of 32 league games in that time.

He then enjoyed a more successful stint as Wycombe Wanderers manager between 2006 and 2008, leading them to the league cup semi-final, where they were eventually beaten by Chelsea. He quit after missing out on promotion in the League Two play-offs in 2008.

He joined Colchester in October 2008 and steered them to a mid-table position in League One. His career took a dramatic twist on the opening day of the following season when his Colchester team beat Norwich 7-1. This resulted in Bryan Gunn being sacked and Lambert taking over...and it couldn't have gone much better. He led Norwich to the League One title in his first season and then to automatic promotion to the Premier League in the next season. The successive promotions have been followed with a comfortable 12th place finish with 47 points in his debut season in the Premier League.

That's 9 points ahead of Villa!


A strong second place goes to Andre Villas Boas. This will be a very short summary of his career, as he never played professional football and was originally employed by Bobby Robson at Porto because he spoke fluent English, thanks to his Grandmother, who was from Stockport. He worked for most of his career as assistant coach to Jose Mourinho (apart from a year-long stint as international coach of the Birtish Virgin Islands when he was 21) before taking his first club management role at Académica de Coimbra in 2009.

When he took the job, Académica were at the bottom of the league and hadn't won a single game, but he had an immediate impact, introducing stylish attacking football and leading them to an 11th place finish, 10 points clear of the relegation zone. The eye-catching football made AVB hot property and he was snapped up by Porto in June 2010.

He had one very successful year for Porto winning the Portuguese Super Cup, Portuguese Cup, Primera Liga and the UEFA Europa League, all at the age of 33!

He then quit in the very high profile and extremely costly move to Chelsea. He started well, winning the Premier League Asia Trophy in the off season, but the new style that he was trying to implement seemed to cause a split with some of the senior players and he was sacked in March 2012. The feeling is that he would be a great appointment for a club prepared to give him the time and authority to impose his style.


Roberto Martinez is in third place, as his stock is still high following a very impressive end to the season to save Wigan from the drop with ease. At the end of January Wigan were bottom of the table with just 15 points from 23 games. They looked relegation certainties, especially when you looked at the difficulty of their remaining fixtures. At that time they were 12 points behind Villa having played a game more (so potentially 13 if we could 'win' another draw!).

Then Martinez worked his magic and sent Wigan on a great run full of enterprising and attacking football. They beat Bolton, Liverpool, Stoke, Man Utd, Arsenal, Newcastle, Blackburn and Wolves - earning more wins in that run than Villa had all season. They ended the season above Villa by 5 clear points.

Going against Martinez is the fact that he turned the job down a year ago and the fact that the great final third of the season was desperately needed following the dismal first two thirds.

He has a lot of advocates, but there are a few reservations about him now.


The final manager standing out from the pack is Brendan Rodgers, another successful manager that didn't have a playing career after he was forced to retire due to injury at the age of 20 while on the books at Reading. He then became youth team manager for Reading in 1995 where he worked until Jose Mourinho took him to Chelsea in 2004. After managing the Chelsea youth team he was promoted to reserve team boss in 2006.

He took his first managerial role in 2008 when he got the Watford job, and steered them to a 13th place finish in the Championship after a slow start. Then Steve Coppell resigned his post at Reading and Rodgers was made favourite for the job. There followed some controversy as Rodgers initially distanced himself from the job and made a commitment to Watford, only to later leave Watford for Reading for £500k in compensation.

It never worked out at Reading and he left barely 6 months later after winning 6 of 23 games.

Seven months later Rodgers was appointed manager of Swansea where he has instilled a style of confident possession football that has proved very successful. He won promotion to the Premier League in his first season at Swansea after beating (of all teams) Reading 4-2 in the final.

He has received great acclaim for the way his Swansea team have performed in their first season back in the top flight. They finished in 11th place with 47 points, pipping Lambert's Norwich team on goal difference.

Rodgers popularity among Villa fans could be influenced by their commanding 2-0 win at Villa Park in January.

A stumbling block will be his contract at Swansea, which runs until July 2015.


The chasing pack are made up of Roberto Di Matteo, Gus Poyet, Ole Gunnar Solskjær, Slavan Bilic and Martin Laursen.

Di Matteo is splitting opinion after his sacking at West Brom he has steered Chelsea to the Champions League final after stepping up from his coaching role following the dismissal of AVB. His league record in that time is inferior to that of AVB this season and many fans feel that all he needed to do to improve Chelsea's season was to unite the dressing room, bringing the senior players back on board. Of course, many fans also think that he has done brilliantly to get Chelsea to the Champions League final and that his league results have suffered as a result of their great efforts in Europe.

Gus Poyet had wide popularity during his playing career as most football fans warmed to his wit and forthright interviews. He started off his coaching career working as assistant to Dennis Wise at Swindon and Leeds before becoming part of Juande Ramos' coaching team at Tottenham in October 2007. A year later he was looking for work again, as Spurs cleared out Ramos and his team.

Poyet was given the Brighton job in November 2009 and has been very successful. He steered the team to safety in his first season. In his first full season, he won the League One title after hitting the top after 8 games and staying there, winning the LMA League One Manager of the Year. Brighton finished the season in a very respectable 10th position in the Championship, but some see this as a failure after they started the season with 5 wins and a draw. It was enough to earn him won the Outstanding Managerial Achievement Award at the Football League Awards in March. Again, his contract could be an issue, as he signed a new and five-year deal to remain at the club until 2016.

Ole Gunnar Solskjær is a very well known name for his playing exploits for Manchester United, but has quietly been making a name for himself as a manager in Norwegian football. He is currently managing Molde FK and has impressed with a 60% winning record, good football and Molde's first ever league title in 2011.

Slaven Bilic has accepted the Lokomotiv Moscow job and will start after the Euros, so enough said!

Which brings us to Martin Laursen. A Villa hero after 5 injury troubled years at Villa Park he was a big hit with the fans for his commanding displays and 100% commitment when he was fit. He was fit quite often, making 84 appearances before he was forced to retire in 2009. He is now in his first managerial role in the Danish Second Division East with BK Søllerød-Vedbæk. I have looked at his record there, with is fairly even with 6 wins, 6 losses and 4 draws (as far as I can tell), but I don't know if he has improved the performances and results...because I don't follow Danish Second Division East as closely as I should!

The huge popularity for Laursen is clearly from his playing days, but he would get huge support from the fans and Villa Park would be buzzing again!

Chris Hughton and Rafa Benitez are the only other managers in touching distance of the leading pack.

So, there you have the Vital Villa short-list. We've shown you ours, now show us yours Randy ;)

With thanks to Nimmo!

Vital Villa on: facebook

Vital Villa on: twitter

Join Vital Villa

It's easy to REGISTER, simply click the link and enjoy getting involved!

Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer: Mike Field Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Tuesday May 15 2012

Time: 6:15PM

Your Comments (oldest first)

Change to most recent first
AVB or Lambert for me! AVB would be first choice, Lambert would be first choice out of the more realistic options, he could do a good job here I think. But who knows, maybe the board will surprise us and think big!
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 18:26:00

Mick McCarthy is the name everyone is talking about. Guess my article 'The Blame Game' might need to be copy and pasted for this team next year.
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 18:26:00

Thanks for that summary Mike, good read. Yep, Lambert for me.
Pride of Lions
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 18:29:00

May I add, Rudi Garcia has worked miracles at Lille and still finishing third with a wealthy PSG taking command again as well as slowly losing his best players and Eden Hazard being lined up next. He plays attractive football so why not add him to the bunch? Maybe even Capello if Lerner is willing to provide the cash.
Avfc94 we do
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 18:31:00

AVB or Lambert. PLEASE!!!
Adam Deuce
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 18:43:00

I am pretty sure we are being paid attention too by the board at the moment and they will know that Mcarthey is totally unacceptable.
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 18:50:00

faulkner still aiming for euros - so if he wants that then there is no possible chance in hell mccarthy will be manager
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 18:51:00

Having seen the interview with Paul Faulkner, I am really concerned that he Is again saying ( as they did last time) that they have plenty of people to consult with and consider their opinions on our future manager. I tell you what Paul and Randy it's time you made some decisions, if you feel incapable of appointing a suitable manager you need to employ ( even on a temp basis) someone to do this for you. Can I therefore suggest you pick up the phone to David Dein and get some quality guidance. Get him on the payroll and Let him get on with guiding our club back to the place it's deserves to be. With a quality manager and a broad vision of what is required to make us a classy proposal for players, business consultants, sponsors and raise our global awareness. What he did for the gunners was superb and seeing him on TV last Night he was still impressive to listen too as well. Last time out our board listened to advice from SAF who recommended Eck to us, well he would do wouldn't he, it's 6 points he could guarantee united, so Paul and randy if this managerial decision can't be made in house by you , then please employ someone who has all round ability to do so and put a bit of gloss on our club
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 19:09:00

Got to be AVB, if not for anything else the fact of his middle name! :-) Well, Arsene works at Arsenal, so why not?! In all seriousness, it seems to me that AVB would provide the vision for Villa as they get ready to again challenge in Europe. He could be at Villa for many years.
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 19:12:00

All thanks to Nimmo for this article lads and lasses, forgot to change my name when I put it up. Sterling work and research!
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 19:27:00

I'm in the AVB (very little chance, I know!) or Lambert camp.
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 19:39:00

No messing about they need to get their first choice and quickly before Liverpoo come looking !!! Mick Dennis (Norwich fan) from Daily Express says that the problem with the Lambert/Villa partnership is Lamberts adulation of MON and that he doesnt feel Villa want to be anywhere near any connection with MON
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 19:50:00

Congrats to you for staying up. I'd like to put a name to you- claudio ranieri. He bought jose's players for him. As a Chelsea fan I am grateful to the tinker man for what he done for us. He is also a man with a lot of experience, something I think you could do with and I consider him a big name. He would be great for you. Best of luck for next season but obviously not against us!
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 20:29:00

Well said jj. Wonder who'll send Randy a letter of recommendation ( condemnation ) this time??? Speak to Sid, taylor and KMac FFS. Speak to any group of real Villa fans!!! It's not rocket science if you know the game which they clearly don't sadly!!!
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 20:30:00

Mick McCarthy, favourite with the bookies, if this happens then Lerner must leave and take Faulkner with him, someone please tell me this is a ***** take.
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 20:32:00

thanx blue1989
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 20:34:00

Rodgers or Lambert please. Both play football and shrewd in the market. Amazing what theyve achieved this season. Not convinced with Martinez. Wigan no better than when Bruce left.
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 20:37:00

McCarthy is 9-1 3rd fav on Betfair eltoro. That's usually the best guide for a betting guide. Lambert 9-4 fav.
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 20:40:00

I'd be interested to see how lambert does in his second season in the PL first. You guys would be a big step up from Norwich, surely maybe see how he does in the second season with Norwich, second season syndrome may hit them and then people will think he's rubbish. I'd also suggest Owen coyle to you.
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 20:45:00

Best wishes to Stylian as well.
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 20:51:00

i'm putting £50 on McCarthy
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 21:02:00

you need to look again tebor 1978, he's the FAV with 6 of the big bookies! very bad news, if this comes true then it's the end for our once great club' because to go from mcliesh to mad mick says it all really!!
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 21:33:00

I totally agree eltoro. It would be a disaster. I'm just saying I wouldn't get panicking too much yet. The bookies know about as much as you and me on these matters. It only takes a small amount of money on these markets & the bookies $h!t themselves and shorten up the price so they don't get filled in. Trust me, if Big Mick goes evens on Betfair, that's the time to worry.
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 21:43:00

After the mess the board made with the signing of the last bloke, they wouldn't do something as daft as Big Mick.
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 21:49:00

I know what you're saying Blue 1989 - Lambo definitely a gamble, but if he stays at Norwich and does well again, he will be in another stratosphere in terms of cost next time round. Ranieri was probably a good shout last time we were recruiting, but now we're talking about energetic managers (which implies young), don't think that's the direction we're likely to take. And tebor, if it's McCarthy or Bruce, think they'll have a bigger insurrection on their hands than anything we've seen with Eck.
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 21:54:00

Thanks for letting me come on and discuss with you, nice to have spoken to you, I'm off back to vital Chels to discuss our managerial problems yet again.
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 22:00:00

Agree with jj184, shame we don't have somebody on the board who knows what they are doing. Signing David Dein would be a great first step, don't trust Faulkner to make a decision, bring back Steve Stride. Would love to see AVB clear out the squad and start a dynasty but can't see it happening myself. Failing that go get Lambert.
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 22:34:00

Well Blue 1989 - you have invited this - there is a ginger scottish ***** that would do wonders with the backing of the owner, just waiting to be appointed given he has no job at the mo. Apparently Sir Alex rates him so there you go - obvious choice for you guys.
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 22:52:00

Maybe AVB has a point to prove....? No way will Big Mick or Bruce get a look much history of mediocraty/underachievement so surely we can be more optimistic? Martinez, Rodgers, Lambert - all their teams play attractive football, score goals and provide entertainment, something sorely absent from B6 over the last couple of years. I would favour Martinez as he has an advantage in terms of Prem Lge experience (Rodgers & Lambert one-season wonders?) and has had to rebuild Wigan on a shoestring almost on a yearly basis. Although not massive, budget at Villa would surely allow him the chance to really show what he's got in his locker?
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 23:03:00

Just to put things in perspective. Mcarthy is 2/1 on skybet to take over Villa and Mourinho is 2/1 to take over at manure...... not gonna happen ...Is it? -_-
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 23:04:00

And what I mean re: AVB, maybe he would not be such a fanciful candidate? His nose surely bloodied by his Chelsea experience, maybe he would want another crack at the Prem slightly more distant from the glare of publicity surrounding the top few teams? Come to think of it, why not Ranieri, or even Capello? Both keen on the Prem (unless for one last fat payday...)
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 23:08:00

Mick McCarthy is on the nightmare parallel universe short-list, along with Steve Bruce and Alan Curbishley. There again, I thought that about McLeish one year ago.
Report Abuse
15/05/2012 23:37:00

going on what Faulkner has said, it ain't going to be McCarthy, Bruce or Curbishley.
Report Abuse
16/05/2012 01:18:00

Hum, AVB would be cool - make some nice banner - "AV Welcomes AVB" etc
Report Abuse
16/05/2012 07:38:00

Rogers, Lambers, AVB, Martinez please
Report Abuse
16/05/2012 11:02:00

If you had offered me Mick McCarthy last year instead of Mcleish I would have snapped your hand off. But this year expectations are should be a lot higher. We arent paying peanuts so why do we keep getting offered monkeys ?
Report Abuse
16/05/2012 12:43:00

nicely done Nimmo, cheers for that mate.
The Fear
Report Abuse
16/05/2012 16:50:00


Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Aston Villa Articles

Lescott Shortly? (Tuesday September 1 2015)

Anderlecht Keeper Joins On (Tuesday September 1 2015)

Calder To Dundee Confirmed (Monday August 31 2015)

Quick Transfer Roundup (Monday August 31 2015)

Sherwood Talks Injuries & Gabby (Monday August 31 2015)

Sinclair Gets BBC Nod (Monday August 31 2015)

Deadline Day Tomorrow (Monday August 31 2015)

Something For The Weekend (500) (Sunday August 30 2015)

Archived Aston Villa Articles

List All Vital Villa Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites

Vital Members League (view all)

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
9. Everton 4 1 2 1 1 5
10. Southampton 4 1 2 1 0 5
11. AFC Bournemouth 4 1 1 2 -1 4
12. Aston Villa 4 1 1 2 -1 4
13. Chelsea 4 1 1 2 -3 4
14. Norwich 4 1 1 2 -3 4
15. WBA 4 1 1 2 -3 4

Aston Villa Fixtures (view all)

Breaking League News

Van Dijk Finally Signs On
» Southampton : 01/09/2015 15:04:00
Koeman amp; Fonte Talk Norwich Win
» Southampton : 01/09/2015 14:59:01
Ferguson Stays At Millwall
» Newcastle : 01/09/2015 14:52:01
Dyer amp; Walters In?
» Leicester City : 01/09/2015 14:47:00
Moore Completes Bristol City Loan
» Leicester City : 01/09/2015 14:41:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Sunderland MotM
Suggested By:  Site Staff
Guzan 7%
Hutton 1%
Richards 1%
Clark 0%
Amavi 3%
Westwood 0%
Sanchez 20%
Gueye 24%
Bacuna 0%
Gestede 0%
Sinclair 44%
Sub - Gil 0%