Aston Villa - The Blame Game
UK time is: 05:29:41
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

The Blame Game

For the record I am of the opinion that the marriage between Aston Villa and McLeish is not going to work. A lack of tactical nuance and the burden of history have undone whatever possibility their might have been of the relationship working out; a relationship most of us did not want to see. Most Villa fans begrudgingly resigned themselves to his appointment but were prepared to see how things panned out. Alex McLeish would be the first to tell us that things have not panned out well. Circumstances have not helped, whether it be our top striker doing his ankle or our heroic captain developing Leukaemia and, of course, hindsight is always a wonderful thing. Providence or an ability to plan accordingly would perhaps have been better.

However, as much as I disagree with his appointment and the football direction in which we are heading, I have nothing but personal respect for the manner in which Alex McLeish has dealt with with his situation, one in which he has been met with personal abuse and hate. Although accountability should be part of the concept of management I respect and recognise the integrity he has shown in taking it all on the chin nonetheless. He has undoubtedly being the focal point for all of the fans anger in a season when difficult decisions needed to be made. No wonder then he is receiving supportive texts from the board and the chairman when it is he who is taking the bullets. They must be relieved it isn't them but then perhaps that was the whole point of the appointment in the first place.

It is quite obvious from yesterday's post match comments that the manager is aware of the situation and will not proceed with the same hardiness and protection that he has shown to the players, in taking all of the ire on to himself. They must "pull their finger out," he said. I could not agree more. This is undoubtedly aimed at many of the senior players (Stan excluded) who have let the club down with some of their performances this season. Yes, it his job to motivate them but they have, at times, failed to motivate themselves or respond to what is being said. That is until it began to dawn on them that contracts might not get renewed and that they might get relegated. Whether it was key players disappearing in games, defensive lapses, lack of focus in front of goal, or collective apathy, the famous Claret and Blue shirt has taken an utter battering this season at the hands of some of those who wear it.

The players would have known, that with both barrels aimed at the manager, they would go largely unscathed and so have avoided overt and direct criticism which seems ludicrous when you consider how badly some of them have played. Week in week out players are put under the microscope across the media yet not our players? They have obviously been well protected, ducking for cover as their beleaguered manager took the brunt of it all. Yes he deserved a large slice of whatever was going to come their way though not the entire cake. To be a gentleman about it, it seems darn right unfair.

As stated earlier he has made some baffling, woeful decisions at times though I couldn't knock the man's mental fortitude, belief and fight; his professionalism and integrity. Most mortals would have walked away. He didn't, which is ironic to applaud when many of us wish he would have gone before the situation became practically untenable.

Interestingly, when our academy graduates came in they took their chances by the scruff of the proverbial neck. They showed a lot of the above values under McLeish. Indeed, it seemed as though he had no problem motivating them but then they had no problem motivating themselves either. They are a credit to the club. Whether it was Herd's goal against Liverpool, Baker's coolness at the back or Weimann's killer goal against Stoke, they have done their bit for both gaffer and shirt. Do we not offer him some credit for that or was that simply down to a combination of Kevin MacDonald and magic?

However, those young starlets have unfortunately witnessed the bile that has come the managers way. I still wonder as to the psychological effect of this and their perceptions of what it is to be part of this club given all that has happened. For example, many of us (myself included) were up in arms over the recent "Gatecrasher" incident yet seem to think abuse is acceptable as long as it comes from the fans. Is it? I'm not sure it is. Alex McLeish is certainly not responsible for what comes out of my mouth or what I write no more than he is yours. If that is the case why do some give themselves permission to be abusive?

I love this club as much as the next fan and driven by tribal feelings I often spring out of my seat, offering verbal jousts to the players and managers though there is a line because none of the above gives me the right to offer foul mouth discriminatory abuse to anyone. I try (though sometimes slip) to speak and express myself as if Eck was listening. I would like to think I would have hard questions and some things to say though I would want to put this over in a way that was reasonable and appropriate. Sadly, some of the things I have heard shouted and seen written are not appropriate in anyone`s language. To see grown men with young children spitting the most vile foul mouthed hate as though that were a normal thing to do bothers me; keyboard warriors tapping out anti-Scottish obscene bile as though it was acceptable makes me feel the same. Unfortunately, anonymity breeds contempt and in some cases obscenity.

The fact is we're ALL representing our club and should do so in a way that honours the badge and shirt. Let us remind ourselves that Alex McLeish is a father, a husband, someone's son and a friend and work colleague to many. He is a decent human being. I may not want him to manage my club but I have nothing but respect for the way he has personally conducted himself; the qualities he has shown in that regard even if I am angered by some of the footballing decisions he has made. So "McLeish out" but let us show the man the door with dignity.

As we do lets us all remember where the doors are. They get you in as much as they let you out. The report I heard this morning suggested we have currently sold somewhere in the region of 13,000 season tickets for next season. With the club required to set back 5% of our 42000 seats for match day tickets (Premier League Rules: Ticketing 4.9) with 7% allocated to away fans (Premier League Rules: Ticketing 7) and taken in to account complimentary and corporate tickets I'm sure the club would like to see season ticket sales double at least. Though to suggest that the decline in sales is solely down to McLeish is just plain wrong.

There are times when I haven't gone through the Villa door owing to health, personal circumstance and finance and if that is your situation or you live many miles away then fair enough. It can be an expensive business and this is a financially austere age, the worse economic period since the 1930's which has left us in a double dip recession. Without doubt this partly accounts for the decline in our average gate, a fact repeated across the country not just at Villa Park. However, we have also lost some of the 'hangers on' who only want to associate themselves with an Aston Villa Football Club that is successful and wins; for whom a match day experience is a product they are buying into. Of course, I want to see Villa win and I would practically levitate in celebration if we won silverware though I'll be there regardless because Alex McLeish doesn't determine whether I support the club or not. I determine that.

Surely the best place to protest and effect change is from within and for that to happen we must be the heart and soul of the club. It is difficult to do that from an armchair or a computer, regardless of how strongly you feel. Just ask the 36,000 crowd who turned up yesterday to watch our rag bag outfit battle for a point. They sang, cheered and proclaimed their loyalty and commitment to the team through 90 gruelling, nerve jangling minutes. The game was as much a credit to the supporters as it was to the team and I have no doubt that when ire cools over the summer that passion will turn into "acceptable" sales because when all is said and done we love this club don't we? A club involved in the greatest soap opera on earth: football.

As to yesterdays "McLeish Out day": It seemed less of a tub thumping coup d`etat and more of a damp squib, with people opting to support the team rather than campaigning in their thousands. In electoral terms it just doesn't seem to carry so I am unsure why it keeps getting plugged other than it being a juicy story. I respect the passion behind it though maybe the mass majority realises that it is more than the fault of one individual? Even if he, as manager, is accountable problems will still persist whoever is in charge. If only the world was simple.

In the back of my footballing brain, creating a vilified scape goat and throwing him from the city walls will not solve our financial and resource problems. We will not be top eight next year or be challenging for anything other than stability and improvement, as our new financial philosophy chugs forward. Yes, we can improve and do better than McLeish. That much is obvious. Though anyone who thinks Paul Lambert or Roberto Martinez is going to take us to a top eight finish is setting themselves up for a season of unrealistic expectations in what is the worlds most unforgiving and competitive league.


Previous from: Villa_Grizzly:

An End To Villa Boom And Bust?
Far From The Madding Crowd
A Dirty No Good Villan
Going Through The Change
When The Fat Lady Sings
Listen Carefully, I Shall Say This Only Once....
Fight Club

Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer: Villa_Grizzly Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Monday May 7 2012

Time: 6:37PM

Your Comments (oldest first)

Change to most recent first
wise words sir but don't think that Eck has taken the flack for the players in this case to be honest (see one of my articles from monday on his quotes) in fact I think he has deflected blame all over the place and only one he hasn't pointed the finger at is himself, although I guess he's had a lot of fans pointing their fingers to him!!!!!!!!!
Not a nice situation, he should remove himself from this firing line but looks like he wont, he'll wait for the pay off instead.
The Fear
Report Abuse
07/05/2012 18:44:00

Report Abuse
07/05/2012 18:44:00

makes for depressing reading that you don't think the other, younger managers can take us forward. I'd bet they can get us playing nicer football at least, I'd settle for just a bit of fight these days!
The Fear
Report Abuse
07/05/2012 18:45:00

disagree the current squad with the right manager should be 8th ish not bottom 6
Report Abuse
07/05/2012 18:46:00

Not sure where you 'heard' about 13,000 Season Card sales fella. I have been informed that it is currently just under 3000. Maybe someone thought that was a misprint and added a '1' in front. Not to worry though. We are safe and 2500 travelling Villans will undoubtedly let McMuppet have both barrels at Norwich. The man is a blameless (according to himself). Thank God , that despite his bluster, next weekend is his last as our Manager. He was already gone before yesterdays game, but fortunately the final nail was put in his managerial coffin with another pathetic showing on the pitch. One shot, that fortunately for us, deflected in, was all we had to show in a game that was played for almost half of it against 10 men. I kept counting the players because even after the sending off Spuds still looked like they had 2 extra men. It was embarrasing. Then to top it all off McMuppet says he has had to take the blame this season to protect the players. Can you believe the man and his absolute cheek? All he has done is blame, the players, the weather, God, injuries, the kids, the fans . . . . . . everybody except himself. And then he says next season he isn't protecting the players any more . . . hahahahahaha. The reason for that Alex, is that you will not be here . . . . . . no matter what you say or think. UTV. The fight goea on until you are gone. Oh, I agree with some sentiments of the article. I think he actually is a nice man, who is kind and caring and a lovely family type of bloke. But he is never a Villa Man and never will be.
Report Abuse
07/05/2012 19:08:00

Nice article, Grizzly. I suppose then there is the angle where if the manager's blaming himself every other week, the players will pick up on it and lose respect for him. After all, who wants to play for a manager who freely admits he's screwing up? Either way, next season I want to see more attacking, more confidence and less injuries. If those wishes get granted, I'll pass the lamp on so someone else can have a rub.
Report Abuse
07/05/2012 19:25:00

I blame global warming, all that heat must be getting to Randy's head.
Green Villan
Report Abuse
07/05/2012 19:25:00

nice stuff, but we can go around the houses all we like, mcleish isn`t good enough for and doesn`t fit this club.
Report Abuse
07/05/2012 19:55:00

Best seven teams in the country- Man City, Man Utd, Arsenal Chelsea, Spurs, Newcastle, Liverpool. We are a mile of those sides for consistency and quality. Next on the list are Fulham , Everton and Sunderland vying for that eighth spot. We could scrape this, depending on who we bring in.
Report Abuse
07/05/2012 19:56:00

Are we suggesting that the magaer come out and heap balme on himself throughout the season? That would be psychological and motivational suicide wouldn't it? Yes he isn't good enough but how about some articles about some of these abysmal players?
Report Abuse
07/05/2012 19:58:00

Great post, I have been saying this for a while and getting stick for it at the same time. Hit the nail on the head for me, not right one man should be given such stick on his own for the actions of 11 other men who actually play the game and the board who viewed his cv, his previous achievements and expected anything other than dross football, lack of goals and poor entertainment. As I have said many a time, the man is doing exactly what his cv said he would. Should he therefore be totally blamed for how things have turned out? I dont think he should but I respect others who think differently but without the vile insults and personal abuse that has seen me slightly embarrassed by the actions of fans who I thought were far better than those of other clubs.
Report Abuse
07/05/2012 20:06:00

Integrity? Is the person who wrote the above a complete idiot or just fails to see the facts. Integrity? Would a man with integgrity resign from his job while on holiday and join their nearestrivals? Would a man with integrity sign a convicted woman beater for his then team? ( marlon King ). Integrity is not something he can claim to have
Report Abuse
07/05/2012 20:33:00

Not a complete idiot. I have idiotic moments though. If you read what I said, he has conducted himself in regard to THIS situation with personal integrity. I do not account for the entirety of his moral choices, his views on Domestic Violence or post-sentence rehabilitation, or his value system since birth, though we are all entitled to draw inference or be speculative.
Report Abuse
07/05/2012 20:44:00

Nice try at a different angle rather than just saying the manager is ***** BUT, it's nothing more than waffle. How can you say that you respect Eck for the way that he deals with things and lol @ "difficult decisions". The bloke won't drop Hutton and normally gives Bannan a pointless run out. WHY??? He's had bugger all difficult decisions and he's messed up the easy ones like playing players in the correct position.
Report Abuse
07/05/2012 20:55:00

What, its all waffle? Not a single valid point or considered perspective Villan444? I didn't refer to his football decision making other than to state that he has made woeful decisions in that context, so you have obviously not read it right.
Report Abuse
07/05/2012 21:01:00

Grizzly, I agree with much of what you say and applaud you for saying it better than I could! I think there may be one thing that we are missing: I suspect that the outburst by AM is actually his way of trying to hold onto his job by setting out his stall. I suspect he knows that the directors will be considering their position and he is simply fighting from the front.
Report Abuse
07/05/2012 21:55:00

Some valid points sure, but the main points that started off, as in having respect for Eck because of the way he has handled anything is incorrect in 90% of people's minds.
Report Abuse
07/05/2012 22:37:00

At last!!!! I agree with Gordonsleftboot. I too think he's talking up as a form of defence against the (hopefully) boot!
Pride of Lions
Report Abuse
08/05/2012 01:12:00

This has been the the worst 12 months since the Villa wrere relegated into the old 3rd Division What worries me is if you step back almost 12 months the Club stuggled to attract a half decent applicant to manage what we believe is the best Club in the world, so whats changed ? In fact we are in a worse position finacially and team morale wise now than then. So apart from the usual suspects of ex Managers who no Club wants who do we turn to when the likes of Moyes etc. were not interested last year.
Report Abuse
08/05/2012 01:13:00

i'm with Gordonsleftboot and Pride of Lions.... Mcleish has his back to the wall and is defending! badly...
Report Abuse
08/05/2012 07:56:00

The bluster is McMuppets way of saying 'I am not resigning, you will have to sack me'. The man has no moral compass and is simply saying 'I want your money for my failures'. Well sack him and let him go to tribunal. There is more than enough evidence for grounds of failure, competence. However the process should have been in place several months ago. He should by now already have received a verbal and two written warnings and the coup de grais should be delivered immediately after our defeat to Norwich next week.
Report Abuse
08/05/2012 08:05:00

I see the point of your article, I too blame the players A LOT. How have so many once amazing players gone so rubbish? If it was just this season I would only blame McLeish but Dunne, Warnock, Collins, Gabby have all under performed for 2 seasons now for various reasons. Clearly Heskey is excluded as its not like we expected any more from him! However I disagree with you in the sense that I am a stay away Villa fan this season, only made 1st match Away vs Fulham. I think McLeish has messed up team selection, messed up tactics, formation and is far too defensive. The reason I wont come and watch is cos its utter rubbish, if we played half decent football I would come tomorrow but I can not accept going to a game thinking we are going to defend badly for 90 mins and try to nick a goal, waste of my time as much as my money. Thats not entertainment. Also when on limited funds did he sign Hutton, let alone play him!! We had 3 potential right backs so money could have been better spent - even by just keeping Luke Young!! I believe he came in to see through the break up of MON's bad sigings and has done a great job letting all their contracts run down and keeping us up just. However now I can see us selling Bent, I hope we sell Gabby and that will give us money to rebuild. I dont want the man who bought Hutton and N Zogbia to be spending it. Also I think he is the wrong man for our kids, all of them have looked better when they 1st came in and have gone backwards under him, for me he destroys their confidence and makes them believe they cant do it. As you say we dont need to give him 4 letter abuse but we should open the door and he should agree to walk through it and not just look for a pay off from us!!
Chelt Villan
Report Abuse
08/05/2012 10:08:00

Yes Grizzly would agree we dont need the bile etc he is at the end of the day probably a decent family man. The players should shoulder their fair share of the blame, Also let us not hide behind the rose tinted glasses for the boards part in this. With all that being said I judge the man purely on his tactical ability, entertainment value and results . My opinion on this is tactically poor (set pieces, some substitutions) entertainment in general has been very poor , results - The worst home record ever seen at Villa Park and surviving relegation by the skin of our teeth . Not interested where he came from if we had finished in the same position but shown a reasonable amount of flair backbone and attacking ability would probably have said hes done as well as can be expected given the squad available as I forecast us to finish 17th before he arrived,also I might add before we signed anyone. No I feel many fairminded Villa fans have given him a chance and he has failed. My fear now is that Mr Lerner will stick his chin out and keep this going when it is causing nothing but a split in the fanbase and will probably lead to a huge drop in attendance when the club need every penny.
Report Abuse
08/05/2012 11:33:00

I completely fail to see the point of this article. If the players are not out there busting a gut, week in and week out, how are we meant to change this if everything else stays the same? Football is a results business. The results have been terrible. Solution? Change. The only person we can realistically change is the manager

Where do you get this, 'Mcleish has taken all the blame' from? He has spent the whole season pointing the finger at anyone but himself. How is that 'taking the blame? Yes, he has been blamed but that is not the same as 'taking the blame'.

What McLeish needs to take is responsibility. Responsibility for team selection. Responsibility for tactics. Responsibility for team formation. Never once has he done that.

No sensible Villa fan expects us to be top eight in the present circumstances. Setting up straw men and then knocking them over may be great fun but adds nothing to your argument. Where Villa fans did not expect us to be after 37 games was 16th.

You say that our poor form this season is not McLeish's fault. The fault lies elsewhere. If that is true then how do you suggest we change things for next season?

Throwing in the old, 'We are all Villa fans so we must continue paying our money' canard is surely beneath you. There is only one way to protest that directly affects the club. Don't give them your money. I have been a Villa fan for longer than I care to remember. Followed them in the first division, second division and third division. Seen them play at Chesterfield, Mansfield, Chester, Millwall etc. But enough is enough. The deal is I give the club my money and they try to entertain me on Saturday afternoons (or whenever) They are not keeping their side of the bargain. Why should I keep mine?

chocolate teapot
Report Abuse
08/05/2012 11:54:00

Nice article Grizzly. The only thing I take issue with is the fact that you seem to have missed out a very important party when you are handing out the blame - Faulkner and Lerner. Ultimately, the fact that Villa is now seen as a joke is not because McLeish isn't as good as he might be, or that the players have disappointed, its because Faulkner and Lerner took decisions which led directly to present situation. If I were to defend McLeish I would say that he has done Lerner's and Faulkner's dirty work to the best of his ability, what ever that may be. But it wasn't Mcleish who have hid in the shadows and let someone else take the blame. It was not McLeish who hoodwinked the fans and obfuscated their real plans for the club. McLeish may have been guilty of repeating the lies but he is not the originator of those lies. Of much he is guilty. But if he is guilty, then there are guiltier men behind him, who for some reason the fans are desperate to exonerate. No one can talk of integrity or moral-compasses, without including Faulkner and Lerner. These are the guilty men and McLeish is just their stooge.
Steve Wade
Report Abuse
08/05/2012 16:40:00

I make inference to that point in the article Steve. The idea of it being a Machiavellian appointment, which underlines the idea of McLeish being the fall guy and taking the bullets and the flak.
Report Abuse
08/05/2012 17:25:00

Grizzly, You definitely suggest that. But I would prefer the accusations aimed at Faulkner and Lerner to be as direct, explicit and unequivocal, as those being directed at McLeish. I don't think you can deny that the criticisms of Villa's owner tend to be a lot more mealy-mouthed than those you have heard or read, aimed at McLeish.
Steve Wade
Report Abuse
08/05/2012 17:46:00

I would agree Steve that commentators tend to be more 'mealy mouthed' as you put it, when it comes to the chairman and the board. Unfortunately, folk often want a black and white scape goat and McLeish is it at the moment. Of course, when the team is winning or on the up they assume that it implies that everything is okay because they just want to see us win. Things are much more grey and mercurial than that as we know.
Report Abuse
08/05/2012 21:47:00

I'm nice but doesn't mean I think I can manage Villa!! Screw nice, I want good football
Report Abuse
08/05/2012 23:10:00

Grizzly, you're still inferring that Eck isn't so bad by saying that it's grey. There's no in between area here Eck is a 1 or 2 out of ten and very bad. The rest RE: the board etc. is a different matter and shouldn't be included in the same argument!!
Report Abuse
09/05/2012 11:35:00

What has the ownership of Randy as Villa chairman really achieved in 6 years? He spent money 3 years ago, since then we have been selling our best evry year to ambitous clubs, we have become a laughing stock of the midlands and are now being branded as odds on for relegation next season, oh what a pity Sheikh Mansour didn't buy us or Tony Fernandes of QPR or even the Liverpool owners, nah we get a bloke who appoiints the worst manager we have ever had and an owner who hides away in america whilst his manager who was never good enough to be manager recoups Randy's money back for him and the poor fans left seeing this downgrading of a once great club into the mould of Wolves and Blackburn how sad, just wish i could spend 5 mins in a room with our owner and board members then i would be taken to a police cell happy knowing i did what i had to do!
Report Abuse
09/05/2012 12:42:00

clive please read the 'prophets (sic) and Losses' article from 18th April I think it was. Randolph has spent more than we have recouped in all but the last two transfer windows I believe. We are in debt to him to the tune of about 120m. Most of us do not support the Villa hoping for a Sheik Mansour. We support the Villa first and foremost as a great community and traditional football club. Most of us are not bothered about Sugar Daddy. Randolph has been excellent for our club bar a terrible decision on McMuppet and his overspend during M'ON's years. Everything can be corrected with one correct managerial decision.
Report Abuse
09/05/2012 17:13:00


Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Aston Villa Articles

Ilori Makes Move On Loan (Tuesday September 1 2015)

Bennett Gets Cherries Loan (Tuesday September 1 2015)

Lescott On Joining Boyhood Club (Tuesday September 1 2015)

Lescott, Bennett & Ilori (Tuesday September 1 2015)

Lescott Seals Villa Move (Tuesday September 1 2015)

Lescott Shortly? (Tuesday September 1 2015)

Anderlecht Keeper Joins On (Tuesday September 1 2015)

Archived Aston Villa Articles

List All Vital Villa Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites

Vital Members League (view all)

1. ClivetheVillan 125
2. Pride of Lions 125
3. kefkat 49
4. Bonker 47
5. The Fear 42
6. 1958Villan 37
7. BarosBarryBouma 22
8. goode9 21
9. littleburtonvilla 21
10. hanboroughvilla 20

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
9. Everton 4 1 2 1 1 5
10. Southampton 4 1 2 1 0 5
11. AFC Bournemouth 4 1 1 2 -1 4
12. Aston Villa 4 1 1 2 -1 4
13. Chelsea 4 1 1 2 -3 4
14. Norwich 4 1 1 2 -3 4
15. WBA 4 1 1 2 -3 4

Aston Villa Fixtures (view all)

Breaking League News

Match Analysis - Swansea City 2-1 Manchester United
Swansea : 02/09/2015 21:14:00
Afellay suspension shortened to two games
Stoke : 02/09/2015 20:25:01
The Yellow Bird Podcast
Norwich : 02/09/2015 20:04:01
Jarvis Joins Norwich
West Ham : 02/09/2015 17:50:00
Adebayor Didn`t Come
West Ham : 02/09/2015 17:35:01

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Aston Villa Player Of August?
Suggested By:  JP Fear
Guzan 2%
Clark 0%
Richards 1%
Amavi 16%
Westwood 2%
Gueye 26%
Sinclair 40%
Gabby 1%
Sanchez 12%
Other 0%