UK time is: 21:35:02
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Polls Do More Harm Than Good?!

Polls do more harm than good?

It is now clear that McLeish will be gone at the end of the season, maybe earlier. Even if he is still manager for the Spuds game I wouldn't be surprised if he has a nasty cold and the club announce that he will be watching the game from home.

We do know that the club have been going to ridiculous lengths to prevent supporters airing their views and taking him out of the firing line will possibly be seen as way of dampening the venom he is about to face. However all talk is now going to be based on who the new manager is going to be. On this forum several weeks ago I informed people that the word within VP is that Poyet and Zola were being viewed as a new management team. I think that all the editors of sites such as this should agree not to have open forums asking fans for their choice and avoid having any polls at all.

Obviously we will air our views, but we have got to avoid the ridiculous shenanigans of the last couple of seasons where managers were refused interviews because of fans reactions (Wolly with the brolly!!!!). There are several good candidates who would potentially be good for us. None guarantee success and there is no guarantee they will do better than our soon to be ex manager. But there are managers who will raise hope and expectations and crucially, will have the support of all Villa Fans. Poyet/Zola, Houghton (if Small Heath don't get promoted)Martinez, Lambert (strangely if we win our last 2 games hahahaha these are all managers likely to finish the season below McMuppets Villa!!!!).

You can add the likes of Benitez, Hoddle, Villas Boas, Di Matteo (if Chelsea don't give him the gig full time) and probably more that do not immediately spring to mind. And this selection is why all editors of sites should refrain from any polls. From the possible choice of new managers I have mentioned none of them would probably get more than 20% of the votes in any poll, but all of them would be welcome if they got the job. Unfortunately the press (and the Birmingham Mail are experts at this) would headline the story as 80% of Villa fans do not want xxxxxxx as the new manager according to the recent polls. When the truth is that 100% actually are happy with the new man, but simply had a preference to someone else.

Yes we should let our voices be heard if Randolph is about to make another horrendous error in his choice of manager, but we should let him choose without applying pressure.

Randolph has been good for this club other than his appointment of managers. Lets forget the polls and just support who ever is awarded one of the finest accolades in world football - the job of Aston Villa Manager.

voiceoftheholte




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer: voiceoftheholte  Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Monday April 30 2012

Time: 9:57AM

Your Comments

Houghton or Hughton?
mmlozza
After a season putting up with Eck, any new manager bar the obvious like Avram, Strachan, Souness, Lennon etc. would surely be greeted with great welcome by everyone except the 3 blind mice.
Villan444
Srroy lzzoa. I ma udner grate sterss adn mi spillng and englnad is getin worser and wosrer
voiceoftheholte
I suppose they could of put him on "gardening leave" but probably the garden is under water...........
Pride of Lions
Interesting article. You're probably right. We probably shouldn't have polls because as much as we'd like to keep the media and the fan sites separate, it's fairly obvious that the media come trawling these sites looking for stories. It's a pity because we'd all 'like' a poll :-) FWIW I'd take any of your initial suggestions with the exception of Hughton (surely Lerner isn't so stupid as to enter that minefield again. I'd add Rodgers to it now that it we know Harry is staying at Spurts.
BOF
I guess it's better for us that Harry is staying at Spurs. Spurs is clearly a better job than Villa. Villa vs WBA however...? Surely the Villa job edges that one!? I would e happy with any of your suggestions. Even Hughton. In fact I'd positively welcome Hughton just to show the world we don't care where you've come from.
Adam Deuce
lol VOTH . Yes just to put paid to these media stories about not liking a manager because he worked for Small Heath I would gladly have Hughton he was my choice last season. Lets forget the big bucks managers unless they have open cheque books they wont come anyway. Lambert has been floated recently and yes any reasonable appoitment would be welcome all though I am under no illusions with the current restrictions on spending/wages it will be a tough job to take on. BUT please please Villa tell the press you are drawing up a short list of candidates to be interviewed NOT we want this guy and then get turned down PR DEPT . take note of last years shambles.
Merlin128777
Disagree, voth. The fans are entitled to air their opinion. Randy Lerner doesn't have to listen or be influenced one way or another. He clearly wasn't when appointing Mcleish. If Randy Lerner was better informed about modern football -- I personally don't believe he is very knowledgeble -- then he could make these big decisions with confidence. I, also, wouldn't have an issue with Hughton as Villa boss although he wouldn't be my first choice. Slightly, off topic there is a good article in the FT today about the Manchester derby. It says -- and I agree -- that 'Chewalot' is the only factor keeping 'Manure' from decline. The same is arguably true of Wenger at Arsenal, Redknapp @ Spurs and di Matteo at Chelsea. Citeh are really the only club in England who are virtually guaranteed success in the long term. The UEFA fair play rules could yet scupper that, too. Point is one good manager can make a big difference and that nothing is set in stone in the EPL. RedScouse, arguably, are now closer to Villa than they are to Citeh etc.
VillaWillRiseAgain
Commentary team for sky on Sunday, hoddle and Wilkins. Be great to have that duo in the dugout. Still not convinced that mcleish will be gone any time soon though.
AVbornandbred
Surely not proposing stewards or support prevention officers to be introduced on fan sites! By the way, for 2million per year, I vote for me.
RiF
The speculation is all part of the fun. As long as no one thinks the tail wags the dog, it is just fun. Lets face it, they don't pay attention to the polls (and nor should they) if they had then the 90% or more against the last appointment would have stopped it!
The Fear
The fact it didnt stop it and the advise sought by RL was so poor is the biggest case you could make for a Director of Football with proper knowledge of the game.
Merlin128777
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Aston Villa Articles

Lambert Thrilled With US Tour (Sunday July 27 2014)

Houston 0-1 Aston Villa (Sunday July 27 2014)

Lambert - We Were Excellent (Thursday July 24 2014)

FC Dallas 0-2 Aston Villa (Thursday July 24 2014)

Gardner To Make 2014-15 His Year (Wednesday July 23 2014)

Roncrete's Sett(led) At Villa (Wednesday July 23 2014)

Vlaar Bar (Wednesday July 23 2014)

Archived Aston Villa Articles

List All Vital Villa Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. The Fear 914
2. ClivetheVillan 607
3. Pride of Lions 462
4. kefkat 342
5. HeathfieldRoad1874 253
6. sirdennis 219
7. Green Tea 205
8. Villan Of The North 198
9. Juan Mourep 191
10. Clubpaver 186

League Results (view all)

Latest Results

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
1. Arsenal 0 0 0 0 +0 0
2. Aston Villa 0 0 0 0 +0 0
3. Burnley 0 0 0 0 +0 0
4. Chelsea 0 0 0 0 +0 0
5. Crystal Palace 0 0 0 0 +0 0
6. Everton 0 0 0 0 +0 0
7. Hull City 0 0 0 0 +0 0

Breaking League News

And Slowly They Arrive Back
Chelsea : 28/07/2014 17:32:00
Granero Joins Real Sociedad
Q.P.R. : 28/07/2014 17:20:00
Moyes Linked with Hammers Job!
West Ham : 28/07/2014 17:10:00
Could Hooper be the Man?
West Ham : 28/07/2014 17:04:00
Hammers Show Campbell Interest!
West Ham : 28/07/2014 16:55:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Darren Bent?
Suggested By:  JP Fear
Still needs to be sold 13%
Should be a starter 32%
Good for squad/off bench 53%
No idea! 2%