Vital Football

Latest Aston Villa News

Going Through The Change

Going Through The Change

Imagine the following:

A client complains that I have acted unprofessionally. I am duly pulled before an ethics and standards committee to respond to these allegations. In my defence I offer the following explanation as to why I have gone wrong: I am going through a transitional year. I am not an expert on these matters though I am pretty sure that this defence would not fly.

There are contexts in which the notion of a 'transition' does very much apply. The Arctic Woolly-Bear caterpillar in its 14 year cycle from egg to Moth, Jesus of Nazareth lying three days in the earth prior to his resurrection and the ability of Autobot leader Optimus Prime to turn from alien robot to hot rod truck. I am not sure, however, if this can be applied to Aston Villa Football Club because I'm not sure if any transition is actually taking place. Do managers turn to readily to the notion of a 'transitional period' when things go awry? What does this actually mean?

In football there are transitional periods that we all accept. When Juan Pablo Angel arrived from River Plate for the sum of £9.5Million he and his family went through a difficult period. Moving from South America to England involved huge social, cultural and personal adjustment. No amount of money is going to make that any easier for those initially undertaking such huge moves. Yet starlets like Angel, with club support, do adapt and settle. It applies to managers as well. When Gerard Houllier left due to health concerns it was accepted that the new manager would need time to ingratiate himself and impose his philosophies upon the club. However, in the recent blurb that has come out of Villa Park we are no longer talking in terms of transitional periods but in term of a transitional season. A transitional what?

I don't remember the August announcement that advised supporters that it was a transitional season; that we should financially prepare ourselves for the paint drying, plate scraping, shin rolling ineptitude to come? However, I am prepared to accept change and embrace new ideas after all, "one does not simply walk into Mordor." I joke but should we have to be more understanding given the cost and investment we make, when we don't perceive comparable investment being made either on the pitch or in terms of transfer dealings.

Another example: Let us say I am appointed as an operations manager at a large firm and over the course of my first financial year at the helm there is a downward trend in the overall performance of the business. At the annual review I am questioned by the board as to why profits are low. My reply: I have not being able to bring in my own staff. Not sure that would go down too well either.

When managers make such statements about not being able to bring in their own players what are they actually telling us? With the wage bill we have and the good youngsters at our disposal surely the manager, whoever he is, must be able to motivate the players, ensuring that the eleven he turns out are focused, committed and hungry for success in claret and blue. If he cannot do this or the players fail to respond, playing at half sail, what is he demonstrating? That he does not have the psychological nuance to engage and inspire the players or perhaps that the players will not respond for him and that it is their fault? Either way, the manager is responsible for what happens on the pitch whether he likes it or not because the concept of management is inseparable from the notion of accountability. Let us also remind ourselves that this is not the manager of an ice cream parlour but the manager of a top flight historic club playing in the richest, most competitive, coveted and demanding league in the world: The Barclays Premier League. The standards and qualities demanded of those managing at this level should be exemplary if footballing status as one of the top clubs is to be maintained. Obviously, this is not a job for the feint of heart or for those lacking pedigree, experience or talent and with the vast sums involved it is neither a job for those who don't hit the ground running because points, my friends, mean prizes; prizes that come with zeros on the end and big fat pound signs upfront.

Further, the idea of a transition implies that we are transforming into something better. If that were the case one would see the transition starting to take places in footballing terms, whether that be a development away from the counter attacking 4-3-3/ 4-2-3-1 ethos of yesteryear or the introduction of a short, one touch possession game and a 3-5-2 system. Currently, no such things are being seen. Thus, the idea of a transitional season seems to simply imply a commitment to something different without things actually changing now. That is not, in reality, a transitional season but a commitment to change next year. It is as though we needed the best part of 9 months to really unify everyone to the importance of progression by demonstrating, over the course of a whole season, just how desperately bad it actually all is. (A very Machiavellian move indeed.)

Another phrase often used by the new, struggling manager is this priceless entry: I haven't really had chance to stamp my authority on the club yet. Really? Are the players Ronin Samurai? Do you need to call in artillery? Seriously, does this mean that a manager cannot command the players or direct the players under his charge or that the players are non-responsive towards their manager? Maybe it means he doesn't want the players currently contracted to carry his stamp. Either, way if either scenario were the case it would not bode well for the players involved as it would point to a deficit in their sporting and working relationship with the manager. This would be bad at any club. Is it happening at our club? I guess that's down to opinion.

And, thus far, who are the inspiring names who are linked with leading the riot on our battleship Potempkin or storming our claret and blue Bastille? 32 year old Croatian target man, Olic, who has spent the last two years struggling with injuries in the Fatherland and Rangers fullback, Lee Wallace. I think a keeper has also been mentioned as well and with the prospect of a Rangers fire sale we're already crying into our seats and it isn't even May. Is this the change we are expecting? Bosman players, ageing players and youth players thrown into a claret and blue melting pot without a clear footballing philosophy?

It is often said, if you do not change your direction you will end up where you are heading. Let's hope that isn't the Championship then and a parachute payment but a move to sustainability and footballing development. Though unless we see and understand the change how can we embrace it? The only people who then change are us- altering how we see things in the hope that our claret and blue future looks different when in fact it may very well be the same. Give is something to cheer then, something to believe in, something to inspire us.

All change please.


Vital Villa on: facebook

Vital Villa on: twitter

Join Vital Villa

It's easy to REGISTER, simply click the link and enjoy getting involved!

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Date:Saturday March 10 2012
Time: 8:00AM


What is AVB doing at the moment? Looking to prove to himself he CAN manage in the Premier league?
10/03/2012 08:34:00
Hear hear! I think these sentiments are shared by most and an indication of where we're heading and why would go along way to stemming the speculation and inevitable frustration that being in the dark brings. A little more time in the opposition half wouldn't go a miss either ;-)
10/03/2012 08:36:00
Well said. I bet you are glad to get that off your chest eh.
10/03/2012 08:50:00
I made it all the way through that one Grizzly. Nice read. You still stopped short of a downright conclusion and indeed a confirmation of condemnation but well put squire. If only Randy and co. read these…
10/03/2012 08:57:00
hey magic!, they haven't really got a clue what direction we're heading in...... well they have, and we know which direction that is, but they ain't going to come out and say "We are heading down the water closet" are they......
Pride of Lions
10/03/2012 08:59:00
I can breathe now, thanks Surpsy. I do find some of the stuff managers say quite baffling. I could spend ages just thinking about some of the phrases.
10/03/2012 09:04:00
Great article, and spot on! Just one thing to add here in that another of the excuses thrown in for this difficult transitional period is where the manager came from and that he would need to win the fans over. Now we all live amongst bluenoses, they may be family members (not mine!) or mates, or work colleagues, and for the previous few seasons to this we have heard them complain about how negative their team are and unattractive their football and we almost felt sorry for them, and then he came to villa, but apart from the few that wouldn't accept where he came from he was cautiously welcomed after promising attractive certainly hasn't panned out that way, and we are now playing some of the worst football i have seen down VP The hatred for the man stems, not from where he came from - i'm sure most villa fans would accept chris houghton without complaint, but brought on by a season of dire, negative and tacticless football that is totally clueless in its planning and application, and has put us in with a very real chance of going out of the premier league for the first time since its inception!
10/03/2012 10:48:00
An extremely well written and well argued article. Its possible to argue that the investment yo question has already been made - and wasted, hence the need now to re-establish the club financially. Like our children carrying the national debt in future, its no fun paying for the errors of those who went before. However I think you best point is that about transition. You are right, it does mean movingo something to something else and at the moment the target does not seem as well defined as it might be. A statement from the board regrding a revised 3 year plan for the club would be most welcome. In the past I have defended Randy for his investment. However it seems that at this time we are being asked for a firm commitment in terms of season tickets for next year with no corresponding indication of what the cub is aiming to achieve. It all seems to be in the ether: namely 'the best we can'. And that is not much of a plan.
10/03/2012 11:14:00
Why does this comment box not have an end we can see? Apologies for the errors in the above that I could not seebefore posting.
10/03/2012 11:16:00
The transition began last season after O’Neill and Milner left; with the hammering at Newcastle and feeble defeat to Vienna. A new manager came in with new ideas and he had to work with what he’d got. He instilled new discipline and demanded certain standards in lifestyle diet etc... He brought several youngsters into the first team, he made the Villa players work harder in terms of training and playing style. Certain seniors/automatic choices were unhappy; not because of any thought of AVFC but because he made more demands on them as individuals. The difficult first few months were a bi-product of TRANSITION. A transition also means light at the end of the tunnel, and progress. The signing of Bent, Makoun and Walker. The ball being passed on the deck to feet. The fact that despite the worst efforts of certain senior players (on and off the pitch) we lost only 4 of the final 17 Premier League games. The impending departure of the troublemakers/deadwood. The stated targets of more quality. That WAS a transition. This word transition cannot apply to our current situation. This season has been a step backwards; players who should and would have gone under Houllier are still here. And what we have is not a transition but a game to game slog with the long-term plan stretching as far as the next match.
Dudley Villan
10/03/2012 11:29:00
Page 1/2
  1. 1
  2. 2

Login to post a comment

Best of International Football News


Recent Aston Villa Articles

A Closer Look At The Soccerex Report For Villa

Last Wednesday we briefly covered the Soccerex Football Finance 100 report with Aston Villa figuring in their overall table.

Three Things We Learned About Aston Villa v Barnsley

Three things we learned in our 3-1 win over Barnsley...

The Villa Times - 22/01/2018 (Aston Villa News Round Up)

The latest Aston Villa news and views via the uno fish ial one..

Bruce Post Match Video & Villa v Barnsley Match Highlights

Steve Bruce post match video interview and extended match highlights - Villa v Barnsley

Aston Villa Archived Articles

Vital Villa articles from

Site Journalists

J P Fear
Editor email
Mike Field
Editor email
Steve Wade
no email
JuanPablo Angel
no email
no email

Current Poll (see more polls)

Barnsley MotM
Suggested By: Site Staff
Sub - Onomah0%
Sub - Whelan0%
Sub - Davis0%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites
The Vital Football Members League
Latest F1 News
Could Red Bull be favourites for 2018?
Latest Vital Boxing News
Flanagan Bidding to make History
Vital Football Comment

Aston Villa Fixtures

Vital Members League Table

1.The Fear381
2.Pride of Lions372
10.Melon Donkey119
Write for Vital Football