Vital Football

Latest Aston Villa News

A General U-Turn Or A Simple Contradiction?

A General U-Turn Or A Simple Contradiction?

I was going to ignore the report by the Daily Star when I read it the other night, as to be honest it was that daft I thought the best response would be to forget it.

But sadly yesterday those in the sports media world proved the phrase "football journalist" really is an oxymoron as everyone and their dog have jumped on the story, rearranged the words a bit and come up with new catchy headlines without actually checking the substance of the claims made, like Sky who go with "Houllier U-turn For Krulak" but back to Sky later.

The Star 'story' (and you'll see it is a story in the truest sense) leads with the headline:

"Aston Villa Director General's Changed His Tune On Gerard Houllier."

The hook is imaginatively:

"Randy Lerner's right hand man has performed a U-turn by hailing Gerard Houllier - less than a week after infuriating the Aston Villa boss."

Sounds good doesn't it, very juicy. So what's it based on:

"Director General Charles Kruluk posted on a web forum that he could not defend Houllier's Liverpool love in on his return to Anfield last Monday."

Well the General only posts on three websites, and Vital Villa is one of them. To the best of my knowledge his forum post dealing with the Anfield nonsense are identical on each site.

"But Krulak changed his tune yesterday singing the Frenchman's praises."

The Star justifies this angle seemingly by the point that the General "could not defend Houllier's Liverpool love in" and offers the following for his U-turn:

"I can promise you that our expectations and desire to move forward are as strong, if not stronger, than ever...But we have a superb manager who is working hard to get us where we all want to be."

Now on the face of it maybe it's an understandable position although at no point do we find out how or why Houllier was apparently infuriated by the General's comments. I hazard my uneducated guess was the Press Conference with the BBC where GH commented that he was aware that the General had spoken to fans, but his words and the fact he also commented he would be shaking the General's hand next time they met, and that it wasn't a problem hardly strikes you as the behaviour of somebody who is infuriated.

But moving on, unfortunately, you have to question the research undertaken to verify the story and the proposed angle. Which really shouldn't be the case given the Star have obviously also read the General's full forum post because they quote sections from it here way back on December 9th.

I say this simply because if the angle is correct and the General said he could not defend Houllier, and then made such a major u-turn by calling Houllier superb, then why did he actually say:

"I am not going to try to minimize what he said...make excuses...or anything else. There is no denying what he is there for all to see.

"What I don't know, as I indicated, is what was going thru his mind at the time...and neither does anyone else. What I DO KNOW is that what he put forth in his statement that was put out yesterday is far closer to the reality of how he feels.

"What I am saying is simply that I think I know how he feels about our Club and it is exactly what you would want him to feel. Again, I am just not in a position to talk about what GH was feeling when he walked into the Liverpool stadium. I only know what I have seen and heard as he has worked hard for our Club.

"Those who are seeking GH's head...who are asking that he be fired...have the right to feel that way...they pay for their tickets and can say what they want.

"At the same time, Randy and the Board need to keep focused on the overall goal...and we believe that GH is key to achieving that goal. His statement made it very clear that "building lasting success at Aston Villa" is his goal...and it is our goal too!"

So unless I've missed a major revisement of the word 'u-turn' and the implications it carries, I fail to see how the General saying on December 8th that the club believe GH is key to achieving the Board's goals, and then saying on December 14th that Houllier is a superb manager would in anyway under the English language constitute a 'u-turn'.

Add to that the fact the General did not say "he could not defend Houllier" given he actually said that fans "can say what they want" which is a bit different. I can only believe the tabloid press are again simply ignoring accuracy and ethics as they pertain to conveying a fair, accurate and balanced report of an event in order to simply tick the 'sensationalise and sod it' box.

Not like they really care is it, we are only Aston Villa.

If the General's comments had been read in context and in full (as opposed to cherry picking which parts of a sentance you think would make a more controversial story) I genuinely fail to see how anybody with a grasp of our fine language could conjugate the belief of a 'u-turn' from the two statements given.

But then, at least the Star (despite ignoring/contradicting their own reports) had the sense to look at the live web chat the General conducted a few days ago - Please Click Here to view the full webchat - unlike the previously referenced Sky report which seems to think the General gave an exclusive interview to the Star, although again given Sky's coverage of the General's comments on the forum you have to worry why the 'u-turn' element didn't click even if it was a deliberate invention by the Star - especially as in the Sky report they actually link to their coverage of the forum quotes so they saw them in context and in full to begin with so knew the General could not have possibly have made any kind of u-turn here.

I don't know, maybe the Christmas cheer has started early or maybe I should know better by now when it comes to the media?

Vital Villa on: facebook

Vital Villa on: twitter

Join The Vital Debate

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:Mike Field
Date:Friday December 17 2010
Time: 5:52PM


What happened to all the initial letters in each paragraph?
chocolate teapot
17/12/2010 19:04:00
Damn it, hadn't got round to checking yet DOH.
17/12/2010 19:14:00
All better now lol
17/12/2010 19:21:00
I haven't posted anything in a VERY long time - still a daily visitor, though - but I had to congratulate Mike on this timely piece of common sense. I myself felt obliged to submit a comment on the Daily Mail's page when that shameless hack Moxley first posted his own version of the General's words: it was a lesson in how to take the words of an honourable man out of context. It's now almost amusing how the journos (including those at the Mail) are trying to back-peddle by labelling the Generals entirely consistent views - as expressed in both forum post and web chat - as a "u-turn". It's all such barefaced bull but, as you point out, Mike, should we really be surprised..? Fabulously written article, mate! You put the media to shame.
Athens Villa
18/12/2010 06:37:00
Would never put Neil M as a hack to be fair Athens, also now you have complimented Fieldy he'll want a rise in pay (albeit from £0 at the moment so there might be a 5% increase possible!)
The Fear
18/12/2010 14:51:00
agree though, this sort of thing is Fieldy at his very best.
The Fear
18/12/2010 14:52:00
As expected from you Mike, keep it real.
18/12/2010 15:14:00
Being a Villa fan for as long as I have, I've learned not to read anything in the press with the words Aston Villa in them, nothing good ever comes of it, this has been going on for just over 12 years now, remember all the press talk when all the prem teams were full of foreign players one team stood out at that time, us, our only foreign player was Bosnich, he got injured and Oakes stepped in making that Villa team 11 English men, did we get a mention did we *****, and ever since I don't read a thing in the papers, the BBC are included in that too, including that jug eared ***** lineker, good post though mike, will I ever stop ranting! NO
19/12/2010 10:29:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Recent Aston Villa Articles

Neilson Not A Willing Souttar

Heart of Midlothian boss Robbie Neilson has issued a hands off warning to Aston Villa following speculation that we are preparing an offer for defender John Souttar.

Fans Held Back This Sunday

West Midlands Police have released a statement ahead of this Sunday's derby clash against Birmingham City and confirmed that travelling Villans will be held in...

Gardner Relishing Blues Clash

Midfielder Gary Gardner has also been wheeled out ahead of this weekend's derby against Birmingham City given his long association with the club.

Bruce - You Live For Games Like This

Manager Steve Bruce has continued his preview of this weekend's derby against Birmingham City and admitted people are in football for matches of this magnitude.

Archived Vital Villa Articles

Vital Villa articles from

Site Journalists

J P Fear
Editor email
Mike Field
Editor email
Steve Wade
no email
no email
Turkish Penguin
no email
no email
Chris Heath
no email
M Calucar
no email
JuanPablo Angel
no email

Current Poll (see more polls)

Will Villa get promoted?
Suggested By: J P Fear
Yes, automatically25%
Yes, through play offs41%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
1 Newcastle 14 10 1 3 31 19
2 Brighton 14 8 4 2 28 9
3 Huddersfield 14 9 1 4 28 4
4 Norwich 14 8 3 3 27 7
5 Sheff Wed 14 7 3 4 24 1
6 Bristol City 14 7 2 5 23 6
7 Birmingham 14 6 5 3 23 3
8 Reading 14 6 4 4 22 -3
9 Preston 14 6 2 6 20 1
10 Leeds Utd 14 6 2 6 20 -1
11 Brentford 14 5 4 5 19 5
12 Barnsley 14 6 1 7 19 3
13 Q.P.R. 14 5 4 5 19 -3
14 Fulham 14 4 6 4 18 -2
15 Burton 14 4 5 5 17 0
16 Aston Villa 14 3 8 3 17 0
17 Ipswich 14 4 5 5 17 -2
18 Wolves 14 4 4 6 16 -1
19 Forest 14 4 3 7 15 -3
20 Cardiff 14 4 3 7 15 -9
21 Derby County 14 3 5 6 14 -4
22 Blackburn 14 3 3 8 12 -8
23 Wigan 14 2 5 7 11 -3
24 Rotherham 14 1 3 10 6 -19
Write for Vital Football
Latest F1 News
F1 introduces the Verstappen rule
Latest Vital Boxing News
Eggington Stops Gavin in Eight Rounds
The Vital Football Members League

Recent Aston Villa Results (view all)

Aston Villa Fixtures (view all)

Oct 30 2016 12:00PM : Birmingham City (a)
Sky Bet Championship
Nov 5 2016 3:00PM : Blackburn Rovers (H)
Sky Bet Championship
Nov 18 2016 7:45PM : Brighton & Hove Albion (a)
Sky Bet Championship
Nov 26 2016 3:00PM : Cardiff City (H)
Sky Bet Championship
Dec 3 2016 5:30PM : Leeds United (a)
Sky Bet Championship
Dec 10 2016 3:00PM : Wigan Athletic (H)
Sky Bet Championship

Vital Members League Table

1.The Fear567
9.Stephen Jay Hawkings152
Vital Football Comment