Sidwell Baggies Move Imminent?

Nige is a good solid player, he always gives 100%, we wouldn't of beaten Liverpool at Anfield if he hadn't been playing. How can you make a judgement on a player who has been out injured for a long time? [Edited by Mike Field]

RCIC - 'numerous long range top corner goals'!? Sidwell's only scored three times since he's been here. NRC looks a quality player whenever he gets a run of games and always gives his all. [Edited by Mike Field]

Sidwell deal unlikely as the wages are far too high for the Baggies also Tiote's price is probably too for West Brom also. Looks like Sidwell will be stuck with you until he is a free agent.

villan57 - What are thy talking about? SchoolBoyError - who said for Villa? Not me i'm talking Reading, Chelsea & Villa (Everton & pre season). As for this run in the team when was that then? He's been that ***** a run in the team never happened. [Edited by Mike Field]

barry'sboots - He does not look for the ball he points his finger at another player a silent was of saying don't give it me give it him. That is a FACT.

Why are you editing at all we are not in North Korea...You are acting like a school teacher telling us all off for having different opinions. Is there a party line we should be following? Please send me the rules?

I rate sidders just as highly as i rate Nig. I think their lack of first team football has dropped their confidence and it can be seen in their play. it appears very conservative which doesn't do much for creative play. That being said both have their ups and downs. Sidders isn't afraid to have a crack at goal whilst i find Nig more reliable in possession of the ball.

He's a nose on the wind up Mike - you should ban him - he adds nothing.

FFS gents, why are we bitching like girls??? Reo-Coker is worse than crap but I'm sure that the username wouldn't have been allowed. If anyone thinks that he has won us any games then they haven't got a clue. I can see how some will argue that he does a job for the team IF ( only IF ) we play in a certain manner, which basically means adjusting everyone else to accomodate him. There is no skill there and IF he just did the Makelele role then everyone would be happy. Problem is with these stupid runs. They don't ever produce anything as he can't pass full stop. I'm not saying that he isn't very good at passing. He can't pass (or shoot for that matter) atall. 1 out of 7 goes where he wants it to but that's just odds of probability. Energy and speed and tenacity are all there in abundance but he just needs to take it easy some times and NOT go tearing off at top speed with the ball at his feet with no options available other than take everyone on and score a wonder goal which he clearly isn't capable of. I manage a pub team and the young kids coming through these days are just like Nige. Head down and run as if they're in the playground. MON should have instilled the simplicity of win the ball and give it short whilst retaining your position/player to mark. Only good thing that I will admit is that he did mark Ronaldo out of that game a couple of years ago buty I was at Old Trafford 2 years ago when we were 2-1 up, he was introduced and they scored 2 goals eminating from his position.

Fear this Coker is crap fella is making me feel sick can you do something about it please? I know people are allowed their own opinions and everything, however detrimental it is to general health and safety but anybody who honestly thinks Sidwell is a good player, and for a club like Aston Villa especially, must've been brain washed.

Just having a laugh Mike would be nice if you could take it the way it is meant as a bit of fun!! Anyway wouldn't you like the Vital England Job?