Vital Football

Latest Aston Villa News

Man City Fan Opinion On The Milner / Ireland Deal

Man City Fan Opinion On The Milner / Ireland Deal


1) So, Man City are taking another of our top midfielders, what do you make of the transfer?

Milner is undoubtedly a quality player, his exploits over the last few seasons culminating in a world cup call-up, as well as the PFA Young Player of the Year and 2010 PFA Premier League Team of the Year awards.

His attributes have been sorely missed in the City squad, with fans crying out for a decent box-to-box midfielder ever since Michael Johnson was injured during Sven`s era.

I expect he will make a great acquisition, although the £30m price tag that was stuck on him was ridiculous.

Most City fans would have preferred to go for Ozil, Gourcuff or Hamsik, who represent far better value for money at £15m-£20m, and have arguably the same level of ability.

Obviously we will all welcome Milner with open arms, but City fans are certainly not happy about the price, a player worth £16m at best.

2) The rumoured amount is around £18million and of course Stephen Ireland. I'd argue we have the better part of the deal. Opinion?

Stephen Ireland is rated £12m, so we are still paying the £30m than MON demanded. If the deal was £18m without Ireland, then I would say it was fair, but his inclusion means that you are undoubtedly getting the better part of the deal.

We certainly need a player like Milner to link our overly defensive midfield with our forwards, so getting Milner in is an important step. Unfortunately, we caved in to Villa`s excessive demands instead of taking a gamble on one of the aforementioned players, and now we are lining your pockets and giving you an equally good player in return.

3) So what sort of player are we getting in Stephen Ireland?

While Ireland may not have had the best of seasons, his talent is undeniable. His quick passing and vision make him an excellent attacking midfielder. If he is sitting in the hole behind a striker like Agbonlahor then he could cause mayhem for opposition defences, including our own!

His biggest weakness is his mentality; he is a player who does not like stepping out of his comfort zone. While he could regain the impressive form that saw him come a close second behind Ashley Young in the PFA Young Player of the Year award a few seasons ago, he could equally find it hard to settle at a new club and bomb.

Richard Dunne should help him settle, and if the Villa fans give him time to adapt to his new surroundings, he could flourish. We don`t call him 'Superman` just for his underpants.

4) A lot is said about his off field stuff - most ignore his charity work - any opinions, just a young lad spending big or....?

The Grannygate incident with the Ireland squad and his subsequent retirement from international football is perhaps the lowest point in his career. He has also become known for an obscene taste in cars and spending approximately £174m per week on tropical fish.

Like I said, his biggest weakness is his mentality!

However, as you stated in the question, most ignore his charity work. Stephen dedicates a lot of his time to 'The Stephen Ireland Foundation` a personal charity that helps to raise money for Francis House Children's Hospice.

He is still relatively young and although he has made some mistakes with his off field antics, he shouldn`t be judged too harshly. City`s rise has thrust him into the spotlight and the sudden attention could have an effect on any young star.

5) You surprised that you have done this swap and just how many midfielders do you need?

I think most City fans are disappointed to see Ireland go in a swap deal, although we almost sold him to Sunderland for £2m a couple of seasons ago!

Ireland could have found his form again playing with the likes of Silva and YaYa Toure, but we only have room for 25 players and so sacrifices must be made.

In a box-to-box role it certainly raises questions as to who will play along side Milner. We have Nigel de Jong, YaYa Toure, Patrick Viera, and of course, Gareth Barry to choose from. Vincent Kompany and Pablo Zabaleta can also slot into midfield.

Fortunately, as well as being able to play in a box-to-box role, Milner has the versatility to play on the wings. This is an important element to bringing him in as he will provide much needed cover for Shaun Wright-Phillips. It also means that when he is not selected to play in the middle, he has the ability to play elsewhere.

It will be hard to keep everyone happy, but we are in Europe this season and Mancini has made every cup competition a priority - we are aiming for silverwear. This should allow for everyone to get some quality match time, although inevitably, some will be on the bench more than others.

6) How has Gareth Barry been for you and how do you think he feels with another midfielder incoming?

I think Barry has done well since coming into the side. He started exceptionally well, although an injury saw him lose form at the end of the season.

He lacks pace but that has never been a part of his game. He is one of those players that could be playing at the top level until he is 35-years-old.

He will be under intense pressure to perform consistently with Milner coming in, although I think he will play an important part for us this season and after having time to gel with his new team-mates, we should see the best of him.

Barry will be difficult for Milner to oust, although as mentioned before, he can be used on the wings so he will not be short of playing time.

With thanks to eighthsin from Vital Man City



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:J P Fear
Date:Tuesday August 17 2010
Time: 1:39PM

Best of Vital Network

Vital Boxing - Tyson Fury Will Be Back!

Comments

0
You've got to assume the wing haven't you? Cit£h will surely line up with 2 strikers given the massive selection to choose from? Then that leaves 4 in midfield (unless you opt for a back 3!) Toure & Barry must surely be in the center with Silva one side and Milner the other? I can't see him playing central in the current squad without putting Toure or Barry out of place.
Bizarre_Blue
17/08/2010 15:02:00
0
Reo-Coker is crap .. i'm getting the slightest hint that your not a great fan of Coker ..
Doug4ever
17/08/2010 16:12:00
0
Really hope its true about the wage cut for Ireland and sure it is. If we can get Ireland back to the form he showed a few seasons ago he could be the type of player we were missing last season, pitty Milly won't be alongside him, but would be really sweet if finish above Citeh.
AVbornandbred
17/08/2010 20:29:00
0
I agree, Milner is a class act i wish him all the best, he has everything but pace but still class, Ireland will be great when back to full fitness for us, he;s been out a while, im recovering from losing barry, milner manager whats next i wonder? hopw we invest a TOP CLASS 20/25 goal season striker WE NEED 1
ClivetheVillan
18/08/2010 00:47:00
0
So this guy reckons Milner is £18million despite the fact he was by far our best player last season and all the awards and england performance on top of that and we bought him for £12million. When will man city fans get it through their thick skulls that if you come in and take another clubs biggest asset that you will pay the price for such an act.......
sonicdeathmonkey
18/08/2010 08:52:00
0
Oh I never knew how Young Ireland was!! I thought he was about 28/29...Bonus!!!
jolf
18/08/2010 09:28:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Recent Aston Villa Articles

Match Day Officials v Preston (1/10/16)

The Football League have now announced the Match Day officials that will take charge of the game against Preston North End this Saturday.

Which Manager Has Spent The Most?

The modern game tells us that the club who spends the most money wins. So does the manager who spends the most money win the most also?

Barnsley Frustration For RDM

Roberto Di Matteo was again left ruing a late conceded goal in our trip to Oakwell and Barnsley last night.

A Fan Convinced RDM Cannot Arrest This Form

A worrying post from hightrinity on Roberto Di Matteo and his inabilities at all the manager jobs he's had.

Archived Vital Villa Articles

Vital Villa articles from

Site Journalists

J P Fear
Editor email
Profile
Mike Field
Editor email
Profile
Steve Wade
no email
Profile
Villa_Grizzly
no email
Profile
Turkish Penguin
no email
Profile
Glensider
no email
Profile
Chris Heath
no email
Profile
M Calucar
no email
Profile
JuanPablo Angel
no email
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

Barnsley MotM
Suggested By: Site Staff
Gollini8%
Bacuna4%
Elphick0%
Chester2%
Cissokho0%
Adomah2%
Tshibola4%
Jedinak0%
Grealish4%
Kodjia27%
Ayew43%
Sub - Westwood2%
Sub - Gestede4%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
1 Huddersfield 10 7 1 2 22 5
2 Norwich 10 6 2 2 20 5
3 Newcastle 10 6 1 3 19 11
4 Brighton 10 5 3 2 18 6
5 Brentford 10 5 2 3 17 9
6 Bristol City 10 5 2 3 17 6
7 Birmingham 10 4 5 1 17 4
8 Sheff Wed 10 5 2 3 17 0
9 Reading 10 5 2 3 17 -3
10 Barnsley 10 5 1 4 16 6
11 Wolves 10 4 3 3 15 2
12 Fulham 10 3 5 2 14 -2
13 Ipswich 10 3 4 3 13 0
14 Leeds Utd 10 4 1 5 13 -2
15 Forest 10 3 3 4 12 -2
16 Q.P.R. 10 3 3 4 12 -4
17 Aston Villa 10 1 7 2 10 0
18 Burton 10 2 4 4 10 -2
19 Preston 10 3 1 6 10 -4
20 Derby County 10 2 3 5 9 -4
21 Wigan 10 2 2 6 8 -2
22 Blackburn 10 2 2 6 8 -7
23 Cardiff 10 2 2 6 8 -9
24 Rotherham 10 1 3 6 6 -13
The Vital Football Members League
Latest F1 News
2016 the season of the swingers
Latest Vital Boxing News
Tyson Fury Will Be Back!
Vital Football Comment

Recent Aston Villa Results (view all)

Aston Villa Fixtures (view all)

Oct 1 2016 3:00PM : Preston North End (a)
Sky Bet Championship
Oct 15 2016 5:30PM : Wolverhampton Wanderers (H)
Sky Bet Championship
Oct 18 2016 8:00PM : Reading (a)
Sky Bet Championship
Oct 22 2016 3:00PM : Fulham (H)
Sky Bet Championship
Oct 30 2016 12:00PM : Birmingham City (a)
Sky Bet Championship
Nov 5 2016 3:00PM : Blackburn Rovers (H)
Sky Bet Championship

Vital Members League Table

RankNamePoints
1.The Fear651
2.sirdennis381
3.glensider364
4.Fulford334
5.Melon Donkey244
6.Silhillvilla238
7.villasince67199
8.kefkat183
9.holtelower160
10.DeanoVilla156
Write for Vital Football