UK time is: 17:10:03
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Barrett Backs O'Neill's Cuellar Controversy

Former Villan Earl Barrett has backed Martin O'Neill's decision to play Carlos Cuellar at right back instead of Luke Young or Habib Beye.

Speaking to the Sunday Mercury Barrett said fans were wrong to criticise Cuellar being played out of position because although he does fail to offer much going forward, he is steady and solid at the back and his defensive strengths far outweigh any attacking weaknesses.

Barrett points to our defensive record last season as both proof of this fact, and a vindication for the manager.

'If Martin O'Neill's philosophy is to make sure Villa are strong defensively and then build from there, obviously that's why he's playing Cuellar because he's a strong defender.'

Pointing to the obviously attacking trade off, Barrett doesn't believe that it is such a problem for Villa because of the talent of the wingers we have at the club. He thinks it allows our full backs the chance to stay back instead of bombing forward in support.

'The game has changed and most managers are asking their full backs to be like wingers, O'Neill does things a bit differently with his full backs and first and foremost wants them to be able to defend. Villa have got proper wingers in Young and Downing so there is less need for the full backs to over lap all the time.'

Barrett makes a valid point in reality despite how unpopular Cuellar is at right back. Our defensive record does show he has done a very capable job there and he hasn't permanently been the weak link in the back four If somebody looked at it closely I doubt Cuellar was caught out much more often than Warnock was during the whole season but whilst he has a point, like many, Luke Young especially is a very solid full back.

We've seen that through out his career and we saw how strong he was when playing out of position on the left.

I don't agree that our defence would've been weaker had Luke played the same games but our attack would've been stronger.

Some will point to the Chelsea match as proof Cuellar obviously does a better job than Luke but that misses the point completely as it doesn't factor in Luke not having played for months, not turned out for the reserves so in no way was properly match fit or sharp - especially against a team like Chelsea.

Many of us I suspect heard O'Neill's justification for Cuellar in games like Stoke where the forwards are more physical and where a big man can deal with the aerial threat better and agreed Cuellar's height was an advantage in such games....but it's a no brainer to think against tricky wingers and teams who play more on the floor or look to cross from the byline and not the halfway line, Luke is far better suited for that kind of battle.

Again it comes back to rotation and competition for places.

Vital Villa on: facebook

Vital Villa on: twitter

Join The Vital Debate






Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer: Mike Field Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Sunday July 25 2010

Time: 4:06PM

Your Comments

Get Richards in from Man Citeh for 6m and he will probably be able to produce the balance of solid defending and over lapping with hes pace.
Villa 4 Ever
Ridiculous! A fullback should be able defend as well as Cuellar can, but also have the ability to attack! L.Young is not as strong defensively at right back compared to Cuellar, but, anyone who plays right back needs the ability to get forward and overlap giving us the extra option we need. It's boring now because every team will have sussed that we play down the left hand side more often than not because Warnock gets forward with Ash/Downing. We need a new right back and be able to get Cuellar back in the middle!!
astvil123
What does Earl Barrett know about being a good right back?
young_jonah
Having watched Earl play at right back for us I am far from surprised by his comments...... cultured he was not.
fatloser
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Articles

Something For The Weekend (459) (Friday April 18 2014)

Deeney In, Helenius Out? (Thursday April 17 2014)

Lambert Upbeat Ahead Of Saints Clash (Thursday April 17 2014)

Randy In Praise Of Lambert (Wednesday April 16 2014)

Villa Confirm Suspensions (Tuesday April 15 2014)

Archived Articles

List All Vital Villa Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Pride of Lions 851
2. The Fear 762
3. ClivetheVillan 298
4. Barney2004 245
5. Villan57 220
6. Villan Of The North 196
7. tarzan 193
8. sirdennis 187
9. Sussex Villan 177
10. BlackCountry Villa 173

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
11. Crystal Palace 34 12 4 18 -14 40
12. West Ham 34 10 7 17 -9 37
13. Hull City 33 10 6 17 -6 36
14. Aston Villa 33 9 7 17 -14 34
15. Swansea 34 8 9 17 -5 33
16. WBA 33 6 15 12 -11 33
17. Norwich 34 8 8 18 -27 32

Breaking League News

Injury Update: Defender In, Defender Out
Arsenal : 18/04/2014 17:02:00
Match Discussion - Hull City (a)
Arsenal : 18/04/2014 16:55:00
Liverpool: Reds Dominate PFA Awards Shortlists
Liverpool : 18/04/2014 15:02:00
Dylan Tombides - RIP
West Ham : 18/04/2014 14:58:00
Something For The Weekend (459)
Aston Villa : 18/04/2014 14:52:00
Lawro Fence Sitting - Doom Returns For Mystic Mug
Aston Villa : 18/04/2014 14:46:00
How Many Points Will Villa Get To End Of Season?
Aston Villa : 18/04/2014 14:45:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Villa v Southampton will:
Suggested By:  Mystic Mug
Win 37%
Lose 50%
Draw 13%