Vital Football

Latest Aston Villa News

Why So Many Potential Villa Sales?

Why So Many Potential Villa Sales?

astvil123 asks 'Why so many potential sales?'

Surely now that we have finished 6th for the past 3 seasons we should be looking to bolster what we already have in the squad. However it looks as though a lot of players will be leaving the club this summer; but should all of them really be leaving?

To free up some room on the wage bill we should be looking to ship out the dead wood such as Salifou, Harewood, Beye, Marshall and Heskey. But there are a few players who have been dead certain to move on this summer, but shouldn't we be looking to keep them?

Nicky Shorey was going to leave us this summer, but now Bouma has left leaving us with just Shorey and Warnock as our left back options. Surely this could mean how important it is to keep Shorey at the Villa. When he played for us he always played well, good at getting forward supporting the winger and has a good cross on him. We would only get £2M-£3M for him. This makes you wonder, why should we sell him?

The same goes for Luke Young, one of the most unfortunate players at Villa this season. Extremely impressive in the right back position when called upon yet kept out of the team by an out of position Carlos Cuellar. Yet he was and still remains our best full back and surely would have played more games if it wasn't for the success of the clubs defense. I think the majority would rather Luke stay rather than receive £3M for him.

Nigel Reo-Coker and Steve Sidwell. These 2 players are impressive on their day, however I don't think it is just a coincidence that both players have there better games in a 4-5-1 formation. Surely we will see this formation more next year after all of the success we had using this system with Gabby as the lone striker? (I Hope) Sidwell was impressive and consistent in the midfield alongside Gareth Barry and Stan Petrov. The same can be said for Reo-Coker when he is called upon against the big sides when we beef up the midfield. Surely these 2 players, despite being in the final year of their contracts should not be sold.

We have a squad at present capable of a top 6 finish at least, a squad that was contesting the final Champions League place on the final weekend of the season; why tear apart the squad and rebuild it now?

We should be looking to add to the squad, not sell our current fringe stars who can do a job for us.

And Curtis Davies, unlucky with injuries, but there is no way we should be selling him! If we do then MON should be shot on sight! A future England international. If we sold him then it will be a big Deja Vu! (Gary Cahill) With money from a few sales, Craig Gardner's sale to Brum, a few of Randy's millions and the £11.5M from prize money for finishing 6th in the league, surely that is enough cash to add 2 or 3 quality additions to the squad we now have and push on next year. The question is though, should we really be looking to sell Reo-Coker, Sidwell, Shorey, Young and Davies?

I wouldn't.

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Date:Tuesday June 8 2010
Time: 8:00AM


just natural wastage I think. Can't second guess MON on Shorey (who I liked) or Luke Young (who I think most of us loved?) + I'd have had NRC in the team more but the boss is the boss, he obviously has his reasons and will live and die by his decisions. I'd get shot of the other fringe players including Sidwell but would certainly keep NRC and Young, I'd also keep Shorey but plenty here will tell you he was rubbish, so what do I know!?
The Fear
07/06/2010 20:52:00
Most of the ones wanting to leave either aren't good enough or they have spoken out of turn to him who must be obeyed
07/06/2010 21:14:00
Nige has taken the stance that he is willing to let his contract run down for a big pay day at another club, so he can ***** off. Agree about Sidwell in a 3 man midfield and the fact that it should be used more. Heskey almost plays that role for us anyway. As you say ant1, none of the above want to sit on the bench for another season.
08/06/2010 09:08:00
Davies has got to stay and I totally agree with ASTVIL123 on that point. Would be excellent if Young stayed too. Shorey always look unhappy, just like Nigel. I don't envisage NRC is good for the dressing room. I would get shot of him in an instant for that reason. I've always liked Sidwell and it is sad he hasn't made the cut against the lovies like Petrov. Realistically Beye was bought because MON didnt believe another CD was on the market and then came up trumps with Dunne, so Beye can go. So can Salifou, a heated blanked would offer better bench warming and cost less to run! Heskey bye, but only if Carew stays and only if we buy another striker. But we do need to trim and then replace with quality will evenly split playing time as much as possible.
08/06/2010 10:25:00
Harry is "reportedly" trying to sign Agbonlahor for £22
Irish Blue
08/06/2010 10:42:00
We need to sell to buy, because O'Neill has spent all the money. We also have a fair few unhappy players, and unhappy players end up getting sold if they can't/won't be made happy. Finally, you could probably make a case for a dozen players who, for one reason or another, might think they were better off somewhere else, either because Villa aren't 'big' enough, because they aren't getting on the pitch, or because they are playing out of position.
08/06/2010 11:25:00
I would let Sidwell go - he's pony. As for Reo Coker- whats the point??! Get rid of him too and find a player who can challenge (not moan) his way to a starting place. I agree about Shorey/Young.
08/06/2010 11:59:00
So many sales --- is it realy that many? - fringe/squad players on way out, as well as improving the squad - think it seems about reasonable -- bearing in mind its silly season as well, so be unlikely that we get rid of as many as the papers reckon.....
08/06/2010 13:28:00
This is a big issue for M'ON and is at the root cause of some of the concerns of Villa supporters. Okey Cokey, Curtis Davis, Luke Young, Shorey, Beye, Sidwell, Harewood and Salifou have cost the club £40m in transfer fees. The wages for these players is likely to be around £300K per week. The transfer fee and wages of these players over the course of their contracts is around £100m. The probable return is in the region of £20M in transfer fees and a saving off the wage bill. The question to be asked is could M'ON have done better with that £100M? Personally I think the signings in the main were good ones. I don't think we needed Beye and Salifou was a gamble. Sometimes they work and sometimes they do not. This is no different for any manager. However the problem has been his ability to utilise all of his players and keep them happpy, whilst at the same time keeping the squad fresh and happy. Our four centre halfs should have been used as centre halfs and used accordingly to keep them all on top of their game and injury free. Dunne carried an injury for the last month of the season. It is madness that he wasn't rested for a couple of weeks with either Cuellar or Davies covering the role. Young should have been right back. Simple as!! Petrov struggled with injury all through March and April, Okey Cokey should have been simply been used as a direct replacement. After all he was back from injury, fresh and raring to go. He would have been a major boost at the tired end of the season. Despite all the relative success of the season, it is these nagging problems that still means M'ON has yet to convince many that he can push us on to the very top level. I believe he can. Saunders took 7 years. He built a team, dismantled it and built it again. He purchased journey men and unsung heroes. He built a team without stars, but who all worked together. Even through rose tinted spectacles, we were not the most attractive team to watch. But we were very efficient. M'ON will rebuild the Villa, provided he is not hounded out first. Possibly not as everyone would like, but he will do it. He must though, take control of this player situation as every penny is going to count in the future.
08/06/2010 16:58:00
Sod it, get rid of them. If last season is anything to go by, we may as well get rid of them as they won''t play anyway. Stick the kids on the bench and give them the chance to possibly experience Premier League football. The only 1 I'm not sure about is Luke Young, but he wants to play so let him leave. A couple of big signings (someone who can dictate the pace of the game in Midfield as well as finding that killer ball, and a striker who can come deep, lay the ball off, drift out wide, has a good touch and can get some goals IMO) and we'll have some experienced quality pro's to call on as well. I'm not a big believer in the whole squad rotation thing, but it's good to have these players available so it pushes the first team to improve in the knowledge they may lose their place.
08/06/2010 17:54:00
Page 1/2
  1. 1
  2. 2

Login to post a comment

Best of Vital Network

Recent Aston Villa Articles

Villa's International Injury Update

Another tired and boring international break in the world of football, so here's an update from Bodymoor Heath on our walking wounded.

The Villa Times - 24/03/2017 (Aston Villa News Round-up)

The latest Aston Villa news and views via the uno fish ial one...

Videos. Inside The Aston Villa Dressing Room

Hate international breaks, so hey, thought some of you might have missed these. Quite good fun some of them.

Villa Replicate Reading Offer

With Reading charging our fans (season ticket holders or members) only £20 for our trip to the Madejski Stadium earlier in the season, Villa have reciprocated the deal...

Archived Vital Villa Articles

Vital Villa articles from

Site Journalists

J P Fear
Editor email
Mike Field
Editor email
Steve Wade
no email
no email
Turkish Penguin
no email
no email
Chris Heath
no email
M Calucar
no email
JuanPablo Angel
no email

Current Poll (see more polls)

I have nothing to ask! I hate international breaks!
Suggested By: ;o)
Whatever 5%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
1 Newcastle 38 24 6 8 78 38
2 Brighton 38 23 8 7 77 30
3 Huddersfield 37 22 5 10 71 4
4 Leeds Utd 38 21 6 11 69 16
5 Reading 38 20 7 11 67 2
6 Sheff Wed 38 18 8 12 62 9
7 Fulham 38 16 13 9 61 19
8 Norwich 38 16 9 13 57 9
9 Preston 38 15 12 11 57 6
10 Derby County 38 14 11 13 53 3
11 Barnsley 38 14 9 15 51 0
12 Aston Villa 38 13 12 13 51 0
13 Cardiff 38 14 9 15 51 -1
14 Brentford 38 14 8 16 50 3
15 Q.P.R. 38 14 8 16 50 -5
16 Wolves 37 12 9 16 45 -2
17 Ipswich 38 10 15 13 45 -9
18 Birmingham 38 11 12 15 45 -16
19 Bristol City 38 11 8 19 41 -3
20 Forest 38 11 8 19 41 -11
21 Burton 38 10 11 17 41 -14
22 Blackburn 38 9 13 16 40 -11
23 Wigan 38 8 10 20 34 -13
24 Rotherham 38 4 5 29 17 -54
Write for Vital Football
Latest F1 News
2017 Australia GP - Race
Latest Vital Boxing News
Taylor v Joubert – Meadowbank, Scotland
The Vital Football Members League

Recent Aston Villa Results (view all)

Aston Villa Fixtures (view all)

Apr 1 2017 3:00PM : Norwich City (H)
Sky Bet Championship
Apr 4 2017 7:45PM : Queens Park Rangers (H)
Sky Bet Championship
Apr 8 2017 3:00PM : Burton Albion (a)
Sky Bet Championship
Apr 15 2017 3:00PM : Reading (H)
Sky Bet Championship
Apr 17 2017 2:45PM : Fulham (a)
Sky Bet Championship
Apr 23 2017 12:00PM : Birmingham City (H)
Sky Bet Championship

Vital Members League Table

1.The Fear369
3.Pride of Lions292
8.Melon Donkey156
Vital Football Comment