UK time is: 01:38:34
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

How Happy Are You With Transfer Window?

Vital Villa asked what you thought of the transfer window just closed.

55% voted that it had been a good one.

19% felt it was 'ok' and 12% average.

9% voted it 'great' and as we've spent more net than any club other than Man City, I can see their point but I guess people are judging who we've signed as well as how much has been spent and we all have wildly different opinions on players, always have and always will!

That left only 3% feeling it was poor and 2% less than average.

Our latest poll asks who should be our regular centre backs!?

Related article: Thanks To Randy Lerner

Acorns


Bookmark and Share




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!



*Try Vital Mobile FOR FREE for the latest news, scores, fixtures and so much more*

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer: J P Fear Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Thursday September 3 2009

Time: 11:28AM

Your Comments

I cannot complain too much, think he identified a requirement of 5 players, he brought in 7 and sold 3 + Laursen, so he has three more than last season. Dunne and Warnock are good buys, Downing is a top buy and Delph is one for the future, Collins, Beye and Marshall are average to poor though. The money IS there. Still surprised we didn't go in for Bent. Definately need one more striker
young_jonah
I cannot complain too much, think he identified a requirement of 5 players, he brought in 7 and sold 3 + Laursen, so he has three more than last season. Dunne and Warnock are good buys, Downing is a top buy and Delph is one for the future, Collins, Beye and Marshall are average to poor though. The money IS there. Still surprised we didn't go in for Bent. Definately need one more striker
young_jonah
Incidentally, what is the difference between average and ok?
young_jonah
Incidentally, what is the difference between average and ok?
young_jonah
I know football is not this ideal but roughly in a decent squad of 23 for worldcups etc. you are looking for roughly 3 GKs and 2 in every other position. For the first time in quite a while we have that. The strange thing is, just like the poll shows, there is not that much difference in quality - obviously Milner is currently head and shoulders above Albrighton but others like some of our centre-midfielders or defenders dont leave too much between them. The first XI does not pick itself. Im not going to go through the squad individually, but BOTH options for each position would easily start for most PL clubs and indeed have. Look at the four centre-backs! All played most games for their previous clubs. Shorey and Beye now considered 'back-up' were first teamers! Any combo of Petrov, Sidwell, Reo-Coker, Delph, Gardner would walk into most PL teams. Heskey, Downing etc. I could go on. Our squad of 23/24/25 is very talented. We could put two starting XI teams out who could finish in the top8 injuries permitting!! Im very happy with the squad....other than Heskey of course!! Thats why I really did not see the benefit in being linked with Jenas, Huddlestone etc. would they have added more?? I think with our squad now O'Neill just needs to but one or two per window who would be considered first XI. I think our windows will be much different from here on in!!
deano.avfc
I know football is not this ideal but roughly in a decent squad of 23 for worldcups etc. you are looking for roughly 3 GKs and 2 in every other position. For the first time in quite a while we have that. The strange thing is, just like the poll shows, there is not that much difference in quality - obviously Milner is currently head and shoulders above Albrighton but others like some of our centre-midfielders or defenders dont leave too much between them. The first XI does not pick itself. Im not going to go through the squad individually, but BOTH options for each position would easily start for most PL clubs and indeed have. Look at the four centre-backs! All played most games for their previous clubs. Shorey and Beye now considered 'back-up' were first teamers! Any combo of Petrov, Sidwell, Reo-Coker, Delph, Gardner would walk into most PL teams. Heskey, Downing etc. I could go on. Our squad of 23/24/25 is very talented. We could put two starting XI teams out who could finish in the top8 injuries permitting!! Im very happy with the squad....other than Heskey of course!! Thats why I really did not see the benefit in being linked with Jenas, Huddlestone etc. would they have added more?? I think with our squad now O'Neill just needs to but one or two per window who would be considered first XI. I think our windows will be much different from here on in!!
deano.avfc
Deano i agree with most of what you say, but i disagree we could make two top teams if we had no injuries... unless your on about playing 4-5-1 because i dont think having Harewood or Heskey partner either Agbonlahor or Carew making a top 8 team, therfore we dont have 10 good midfielders to play 4-5-1, I think the transfers window for us has turned out good, I think Dunne might be the deciding factor in our top 6 positon, In Jan we need to buy two TOP CLASS players, one clinical striker and a creative midfielder and i reckon we might be able to finally challenge the top 4 again.
Villa 4 Ever
Deano i agree with most of what you say, but i disagree we could make two top teams if we had no injuries... unless your on about playing 4-5-1 because i dont think having Harewood or Heskey partner either Agbonlahor or Carew making a top 8 team, therfore we dont have 10 good midfielders to play 4-5-1, I think the transfers window for us has turned out good, I think Dunne might be the deciding factor in our top 6 positon, In Jan we need to buy two TOP CLASS players, one clinical striker and a creative midfielder and i reckon we might be able to finally challenge the top 4 again.
Villa 4 Ever
not sure re: centre backs, obviously that is down to MON, I'd guess Dunne and Carlos at the moment, there hasn't been an update on the injury for Davies, he sees a specialist this week
The Fear
not sure re: centre backs, obviously that is down to MON, I'd guess Dunne and Carlos at the moment, there hasn't been an update on the injury for Davies, he sees a specialist this week
The Fear
Very good window, better when Downing available obviously, BUT I think it could have been a GREAT window if we had also signed Tuncay.
krfeskivilla
Very good window, better when Downing available obviously, BUT I think it could have been a GREAT window if we had also signed Tuncay.
krfeskivilla
I think the window has been pretty good when looking back in hindsight. It's been a while since we've had this many defenders. The size of the squad is encouraging when you look at last season especially with the young lads chipping in. Am I the only one who doesn't think that Beye was a bad signing?
Villian1
I think the window has been pretty good when looking back in hindsight. It's been a while since we've had this many defenders. The size of the squad is encouraging when you look at last season especially with the young lads chipping in. Am I the only one who doesn't think that Beye was a bad signing?
Villian1
young_jonah, I did also wonder about the average/ok.
Villian1
young_jonah, I did also wonder about the average/ok.
Villian1
Just heard that FIFA have banned Chelskov from signing any new players for the next two transfer windows. A breach of rules is the reason apparently. That is going to be like a new signing for many of their rivals. The margins for error in the PL are so small these days. Any advantage the Villa can get is positive, and this is a big advantage.
VillaWillRiseAgain
Just heard that FIFA have banned Chelskov from signing any new players for the next two transfer windows. A breach of rules is the reason apparently. That is going to be like a new signing for many of their rivals. The margins for error in the PL are so small these days. Any advantage the Villa can get is positive, and this is a big advantage.
VillaWillRiseAgain
Villa 4 Ever-Agree with you about the priorities for the January window. The club has only two does-what-it-says-on-the-tin forwards, Carew and Agbonlahor. Defour was linked to Everton on deadline day. If the Villa are flying high in Jan (in other words, in the top four), RL might provide the funds for some top players, and they might also want to come. Would like to see Defour at VP.
VillaWillRiseAgain
Villa 4 Ever-Agree with you about the priorities for the January window. The club has only two does-what-it-says-on-the-tin forwards, Carew and Agbonlahor. Defour was linked to Everton on deadline day. If the Villa are flying high in Jan (in other words, in the top four), RL might provide the funds for some top players, and they might also want to come. Would like to see Defour at VP.
VillaWillRiseAgain
I think Beye is a good signing, he is a very very good squad player that can fill in that right back spot when luke young is injured
All hail MON
I think Beye is a good signing, he is a very very good squad player that can fill in that right back spot when luke young is injured
All hail MON
got to say I don't know whether i'm happy or not, and that just sums up being a villa fan. one day we might just be able to say wow i didn't expect that signing, not sure that will ever come under MON
eltoro
got to say I don't know whether i'm happy or not, and that just sums up being a villa fan. one day we might just be able to say wow i didn't expect that signing, not sure that will ever come under MON
eltoro
i'm happy. We've strengthened almost all the areas, except striker. GK, RB, CBs, LB, RW, CM, y'know. I'm happy.
footy_fans
i'm happy. We've strengthened almost all the areas, except striker. GK, RB, CBs, LB, RW, CM, y'know. I'm happy.
footy_fans
Happy. Although slightly confused as to which site I'm on!?! Where has all this positivity suddenly sprung from! ;) Bring on The Bloose. UTV
Adam Deuce
Happy. Although slightly confused as to which site I'm on!?! Where has all this positivity suddenly sprung from! ;) Bring on The Bloose. UTV
Adam Deuce
Why not form an opinion eltoro, or are you waiting to see how we do before you hop off the fence? I'd say i'm pretty happy - we're now where I think we really need to be in terms of squad building. Next transfer windows for me (Jan maybe, July definitely) will be the big ones, as I think from here on it it should all be about upgrading what we have to a higher quality - so i'm expecting less signings, but if we make 2 or 3 they need to be more of the 'wow' type signings. Surprised players like Defour and Witsel haven't moved on as mentioned...
YatesyVillain
Why not form an opinion eltoro, or are you waiting to see how we do before you hop off the fence? I'd say i'm pretty happy - we're now where I think we really need to be in terms of squad building. Next transfer windows for me (Jan maybe, July definitely) will be the big ones, as I think from here on it it should all be about upgrading what we have to a higher quality - so i'm expecting less signings, but if we make 2 or 3 they need to be more of the 'wow' type signings. Surprised players like Defour and Witsel haven't moved on as mentioned...
YatesyVillain
It's nothing to do with being on the fence Yatesy Villan, I can't say it's been a great transfer window nor can I say its been poor! it's just when I look at the window I would have hoped for more class arriving than middle of the road. Dunne is a good signing, Warnock is a decent signing, Collins is Knight's replacement not sure why, Delph is one for the future, Downing? still not sure why we spent 12m on him, far better to spend that on a striker in my opinion, it just feels like we're driving along in a Nissan Micra because it won't let us down, but I want a go in the Alfa Romeo because it has some class and style, but like I said under MON it's the Nissan all the way!
eltoro
It's nothing to do with being on the fence Yatesy Villan, I can't say it's been a great transfer window nor can I say its been poor! it's just when I look at the window I would have hoped for more class arriving than middle of the road. Dunne is a good signing, Warnock is a decent signing, Collins is Knight's replacement not sure why, Delph is one for the future, Downing? still not sure why we spent 12m on him, far better to spend that on a striker in my opinion, it just feels like we're driving along in a Nissan Micra because it won't let us down, but I want a go in the Alfa Romeo because it has some class and style, but like I said under MON it's the Nissan all the way!
eltoro
Have to agree with nearly everything young_jonah said! Disappointed about Bent - Spurs spent way too much, but 10m would have been a good price (and he's english, and only 25; anyway spilt milk, Agbonglahor will thrive I have faith). I think Collins could be a lot better than people think! It's no mean feat to get on to the west ham team as a defender - they have enough of them! They lack money and attacking options, but in defence they've got a LOT of talent and competition. Definitely, willing to give him more than three chances - PLEASE don't boo him! I'm amazed Man City left Dunne go! Amazed! Think, if and more to the point when, MON manages Dunne and gives him that bit of confidence, patience and calming influence he'll bring out the Dunne from a few years ago! I am one of the 9% for definite! Hugely pleased with the transfer window (and a little on the happy side shorey stays for competition reasons and because he has shown some good play this season).
johnproche
Have to agree with nearly everything young_jonah said! Disappointed about Bent - Spurs spent way too much, but 10m would have been a good price (and he's english, and only 25; anyway spilt milk, Agbonglahor will thrive I have faith). I think Collins could be a lot better than people think! It's no mean feat to get on to the west ham team as a defender - they have enough of them! They lack money and attacking options, but in defence they've got a LOT of talent and competition. Definitely, willing to give him more than three chances - PLEASE don't boo him! I'm amazed Man City left Dunne go! Amazed! Think, if and more to the point when, MON manages Dunne and gives him that bit of confidence, patience and calming influence he'll bring out the Dunne from a few years ago! I am one of the 9% for definite! Hugely pleased with the transfer window (and a little on the happy side shorey stays for competition reasons and because he has shown some good play this season).
johnproche
Always been a huge fan of dunne so very happy with that one and with the rest i can see what MON is doing, he is building a squad for all competitions. Still agree with 1 more striker and a high quality creative midfielder.
goodb_2
Always been a huge fan of dunne so very happy with that one and with the rest i can see what MON is doing, he is building a squad for all competitions. Still agree with 1 more striker and a high quality creative midfielder.
goodb_2
Have to agree with most comments, been a decent enough window. Best signings for me are delph and dunne. Was a bit worried when i thought Dunne had slipped through the net on deadline day tho!!
Ericols_Son
Have to agree with most comments, been a decent enough window. Best signings for me are delph and dunne. Was a bit worried when i thought Dunne had slipped through the net on deadline day tho!!
Ericols_Son
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Aston Villa Articles

Lambert Looking For QPR Response (Friday October 24 2014)

QPR Injury Update (Friday October 24 2014)

The Villa Times - 24/10/2014 (Friday October 24 2014)

Lambert - Time To Change Our Focus (Thursday October 23 2014)

Vlaar Wants A Return To Winning Ways (Thursday October 23 2014)

Drennan Returns - So Time For A Round Up (Wednesday October 22 2014)

Okore Not Ready For Premiership Action (Tuesday October 21 2014)

Nathan Baker Picks Up Hamstring Injury (Tuesday October 21 2014)

Archived Aston Villa Articles

List All Vital Villa Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Pride of Lions 711
2. The Fear 692
3. ClivetheVillan 582
4. thefacehead 465
5. HeathfieldRoad1874 238
6. sirdennis 230
7. kefkat 216
8. Villan Of The North 158
9. DeanoVilla 142
10. Clubpaver 138

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
9. Spurs 8 3 2 3 -1 11
10. Stoke 8 3 2 3 -1 11
11. Hull City 8 2 4 2 0 10
12. Aston Villa 8 3 1 4 -8 10
13. Everton 8 2 3 3 0 9
14. WBA 8 2 3 3 -1 9
15. Leicester City 8 2 3 3 -2 9

Breaking League News

Going for Three Points This Time!
Chelsea : 24/10/2014 22:00:00
Liverpool: Lawro Predicts 2014-15 - Hull (Home)
Liverpool : 24/10/2014 20:00:00
Villa to Sign Cleverley in January!
Man Utd : 24/10/2014 18:43:00
Pearson On Competition amp; Swansea Threat
Leicester City : 24/10/2014 18:31:00
Pellegrini Expecting Tough West Ham Test
Man City : 24/10/2014 18:17:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Villa v QPR (away) will:
Suggested By:  Mystic Mug
Win - whoop! 40%
Lose - we go again! 41%
Draw - meh! 19%