Vital Football

Latest Aston Villa News

Make Or Break Time For Martin O'Neill

Make Or Break Time For Martin O'Neill

Make or break time for Martin O'Neill

Another season done and dusted and a strange season in was in many respects. First half well exceeded my expectations, second half fell well short of them. Which pretty much sums up my divided view of Martin O'Neill - is he brilliant or is he an idiot? A brilliant idiot perhaps, like one of those autistic types that can't tie their shoelaces but can solve hugely complex mathematical problems in seconds. After over three years in charge I really don't know, I still find MON an enigma.

Two top-six finishes must say something, the man is obviously doing something right, but whatever it is seems handicapped, dragged down, by MON's weaknesses - his timidy and lack of imagination in the transfer market, his schoolboy tactics and his almost insane team selections.

Last season I think his blank refusal to drop Carson cost us fifth place, since January he has persisted with the ineptitude of Heskey and Gabby and refused to return to the 4-3-3 system that worked so well. Meanwhile Sidwell, Gardner and Fonz remained bit-players. Perhaps Albrighton could have made a similar impact as the young Lee Hendrie. We will never know. Again we lost out to Everton for fifth, an Everton who were in crisis last summer, Moyes stalling on contract talks and the chairman offering to sell the club to any passing Arab or Russian billionaire. An Everton, moreover, who were without a recognised striker for half the season.

As far as the media are concerned we have had another successful season, (or over-achievement, as some of the London press claim), all down to O'Neill's genius. As fans we can see things a little deeper but also we feel things a little sharper, it is easy to be over critical. I remain happy with the general direction of the club, we only have to look at the shambles at Newcastle and the continued under-achievement of Spurs to see things could be a whole lot worse.

For me, and I am sure for many of you, this summers transfer activity and the 2009-10 season will once and for all decide my opinion on Martin O'Neill and perhaps even define his career as a manager. He himself called our exit from Uefa 'a debacle' and I'm pleased he used those words because our lame surrender to CSKA must have hurt him as it did us. He has stated time and again the need to enhance the quality of the squad, so he knows as well as we do what needs to be done. Everton may have been in crisis last summer but they still managed to buy Fellaini for £15m which is considerably more than Aston Villa have ever spent on a single player. Spending big doesn't necessarily bring results (ask Spurs or Man City) but then neither does 'bargain' buys such as Emile Heskey.

There will be numerous threads about who we should buy, what we need, the effect of losing Laursen and probably Barry, (nevermind the possibility of receiving a huge offer for Ashley Young) I'm not going into all that, I have written enough. It's time for you Mr O'Neill to finally define yourself as either a top manager or a talented but fatally flawed one. He is hugely ambitious, he wants to be up there with Ferguson and Wenger and most of all his idol Brian Clough. Well Martin, to use a well-worn cliché, it's now or never.

I hope he realises it.



For the very latest Premier League odds

For massive weekly jackpots - Play the Football Pools Online




Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:J P Fear
Date:Monday May 25 2009
Time: 10:37AM

Comments

0
Excellent.
ASPINALL
25/05/2009 10:52:00
0
Excellent.
ASPINALL
25/05/2009 10:52:00
0
Brilliant article. i think it sums up where we are right now perfectly. Let's hope a good summer in the transfer market and a long rest for the squad can galvanize us for next season!! UTV!!
Bobby Norman
25/05/2009 11:12:00
0
Brilliant article. i think it sums up where we are right now perfectly. Let's hope a good summer in the transfer market and a long rest for the squad can galvanize us for next season!! UTV!!
Bobby Norman
25/05/2009 11:12:00
0
Good article. Except we have been saying "this window is vital for MON " for to long. I think we know what were going to get. an unknown who will flop , re( Cuellar, Salifou) 1 big name, and a couple of £4m players. Its time to get off the fence, for all his good work in stabilizing the club - he is pretty crap in the transfer market. For me he leaves it all far to late - then ends up paying way over for dross. I don't think we are going any further with MON - and I expect to be gone by Christmas.
graydon
25/05/2009 11:31:00
0
Good article. Except we have been saying "this window is vital for MON " for to long. I think we know what were going to get. an unknown who will flop , re( Cuellar, Salifou) 1 big name, and a couple of £4m players. Its time to get off the fence, for all his good work in stabilizing the club - he is pretty crap in the transfer market. For me he leaves it all far to late - then ends up paying way over for dross. I don't think we are going any further with MON - and I expect to be gone by Christmas.
graydon
25/05/2009 11:31:00
0
Agree 100% with that - one of the most balanced and articulate articles i've read on this topic in recent weeks. I think this is spot on. MON has taken us upwards season on season - FACT. Some of his signings have been excellent (Carew, A.Young, L.Young), some have borne fruit over time (Petrov) and some are as yet still unproven but show great promise (Davies, Cuellar, Milner). Some have been signed to bolster the squad, and have done just that - adequately but not spectacularly (Reo Coker, Sidwell, Shorey, Knight). Then there are another bunch that haven't quite worked out as well....I think most of us know who they are. So mixed transfer dealings for sure, and that's without even considering talent that we've let go in the same time, and for various reasons (Davies, Cahill, Mellberg). However I think we can wrap all of the activity of the last 3 seasons into what I would call "enhancing numbers and developing the squad". I think MON has made a decent job of that - evidenced by the 2 top 6 placings you've mentioned. Interestingly, our closest competitors at present are the Toffees, whose manager has adopted a very similar approach, and you'd have to say we've been catching up on in recent seasons. I wholeheartedly agree that now we need to start seeing a different type of signing - the odd 12m or 15m player to really take us up a notch. Fellaini has been outstanding for Everton this year from what i've seen - that's what you need to take the next step. So please God no more Salifou, Routledge, Harewood, Heskey signings. No more bargains, cheap has-beens, or cheap-about-to-be-has-beens. Let's plump for real quality. This is the big challenge. How do Villa attract the sort of players that we want, given (in theory) the 'Top4' clubs would also be looking in their direction? Young talent that is emerging, wants to come play in the Premiership and not sit on the bench. That's what we can offer them (are you listening Defour?). Don't write off our stint in the Top4 this season as a waste of time - if nothing else that helped put us on the footballing map in a big way, and can only help us continue to push the profile of AVFC within Europe and beyond. Hopefully MON can use that, and needs to do everything he can to attract some of these top talents and sign them up. I for one will be judging him on that basis over the coming weeks, and should he fail - then maybe it's time for us to consider whether he is or is not the right man to take us up a notch further. It's a fair question for sure, but I strongly believe given what he's done for us thus far that he's earned the right to have a crack at it!
YatesyVillain
25/05/2009 11:32:00
0
Agree 100% with that - one of the most balanced and articulate articles i've read on this topic in recent weeks. I think this is spot on. MON has taken us upwards season on season - FACT. Some of his signings have been excellent (Carew, A.Young, L.Young), some have borne fruit over time (Petrov) and some are as yet still unproven but show great promise (Davies, Cuellar, Milner). Some have been signed to bolster the squad, and have done just that - adequately but not spectacularly (Reo Coker, Sidwell, Shorey, Knight). Then there are another bunch that haven't quite worked out as well....I think most of us know who they are. So mixed transfer dealings for sure, and that's without even considering talent that we've let go in the same time, and for various reasons (Davies, Cahill, Mellberg). However I think we can wrap all of the activity of the last 3 seasons into what I would call "enhancing numbers and developing the squad". I think MON has made a decent job of that - evidenced by the 2 top 6 placings you've mentioned. Interestingly, our closest competitors at present are the Toffees, whose manager has adopted a very similar approach, and you'd have to say we've been catching up on in recent seasons. I wholeheartedly agree that now we need to start seeing a different type of signing - the odd 12m or 15m player to really take us up a notch. Fellaini has been outstanding for Everton this year from what i've seen - that's what you need to take the next step. So please God no more Salifou, Routledge, Harewood, Heskey signings. No more bargains, cheap has-beens, or cheap-about-to-be-has-beens. Let's plump for real quality. This is the big challenge. How do Villa attract the sort of players that we want, given (in theory) the 'Top4' clubs would also be looking in their direction? Young talent that is emerging, wants to come play in the Premiership and not sit on the bench. That's what we can offer them (are you listening Defour?). Don't write off our stint in the Top4 this season as a waste of time - if nothing else that helped put us on the footballing map in a big way, and can only help us continue to push the profile of AVFC within Europe and beyond. Hopefully MON can use that, and needs to do everything he can to attract some of these top talents and sign them up. I for one will be judging him on that basis over the coming weeks, and should he fail - then maybe it's time for us to consider whether he is or is not the right man to take us up a notch further. It's a fair question for sure, but I strongly believe given what he's done for us thus far that he's earned the right to have a crack at it!
YatesyVillain
25/05/2009 11:32:00
0
fantastic article, sums up my feelings brilliantly... This summer is massive and next season will surely define MON?
The Fear
25/05/2009 11:48:00
0
fantastic article, sums up my feelings brilliantly... This summer is massive and next season will surely define MON?
The Fear
25/05/2009 11:48:00
Page 1/4
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4

Login to post a comment

Recent Aston Villa Articles

Stats: Leeds v Aston Villa

All the stats from Leeds (2) vs (0) Aston Villa, Elland Road, 3/12/16 Att: 32,648

Leeds United v Aston Villa - Team Sheets

Aston Villa go to Elland Road as the visitors to Leeds for the latest Championship game.

Leeds United v Aston Villa - Follow On Twitter

Aston Villa go to Elland Road as the visitors to Leeds today, this will be a 5:30pm kick-off.

The Villa Times - 03/12/2016 (AVFC News Round-up)

The latest Villa news, coming thick and fast at the moment, via the fishy one...

Archived Vital Villa Articles

Vital Villa articles from

Site Journalists

J P Fear
Editor email
Profile
Mike Field
Editor email
Profile
Steve Wade
no email
Profile
Villa_Grizzly
no email
Profile
Turkish Penguin
no email
Profile
Glensider
no email
Profile
Chris Heath
no email
Profile
M Calucar
no email
Profile
JuanPablo Angel
no email
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

Leeds MotM
Suggested By: Site Staff
Gollini1%
Hutton33%
Elphick0%
Chester0%
Amavi0%
Westwood0%
Jedinak33%
Gardner0%
Adomah33%
Gestede0%
Kodjia0%
Sub - Grealish0%
Sub - Ayew0%
Sub - Agbonlahor0%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
1 Newcastle 19 13 1 5 40 21
2 Brighton 18 11 5 2 38 17
3 Reading 18 10 4 4 34 6
4 Birmingham 18 8 7 3 31 5
5 Leeds Utd 18 9 2 7 29 1
6 Huddersfield 18 9 2 7 29 -3
7 Sheff Wed 18 8 4 6 28 0
8 Norwich 18 8 3 7 27 -1
9 Derby County 18 7 5 6 26 3
10 Fulham 18 6 7 5 25 4
11 Aston Villa 18 5 10 3 25 3
12 Preston 18 7 4 7 25 2
13 Forest 19 7 4 8 25 1
14 Bristol City 18 7 3 8 24 2
15 Ipswich 18 6 6 6 24 0
16 Q.P.R. 19 6 5 8 23 -8
17 Brentford 18 6 4 8 22 3
18 Barnsley 18 6 4 8 22 0
19 Wolves 19 5 6 8 21 -3
20 Burton 18 4 7 7 19 -5
21 Blackburn 18 5 4 9 19 -7
22 Wigan 18 4 6 8 18 -4
23 Cardiff 18 5 3 10 18 -12
24 Rotherham 18 1 4 13 7 -25
Vital Football Comment
Latest F1 News
What next for Mercedes?
Latest Vital Boxing News
BBBoC to Hold Hearing After Blackwell Incident
Write for Vital Football

Recent Aston Villa Results (view all)

Aston Villa Fixtures (view all)

Dec 3 2016 5:30PM : Leeds United (a)
Sky Bet Championship
Dec 10 2016 3:00PM : Wigan Athletic (H)
Sky Bet Championship
Dec 13 2016 7:45PM : Norwich City (a)
Sky Bet Championship
Dec 18 2016 12:00PM : Queens Park Rangers (a)
Sky Bet Championship
Dec 26 2016 3:00PM : Burton Albion (H)
Sky Bet Championship
Dec 29 2016 7:45PM : Leeds United (H)
Sky Bet Championship

Vital Members League Table

RankNamePoints
1.The Fear65
2.JuanPabloAngel45
3.sirdennis37
4.HeathfieldRoad187435
5.BodyButter29
6.TuBBz20
7.Wurzel20
8.Stephen Jay Hawkings17
9.DeanoVilla15
10.Sasquatch13
The Vital Football Members League