UK time is: 19:15:32
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Why Villa should NOT play 4-4-2

Being English, a lot of us seem to think that 4-4-2 is the way to play. But I really don`t think it is. I have mentioned it a few times in my, 'The Week In Villa` column, and our results can also point to my argument.

Here are ten reasons why I believe we should play 4-3-3/4-5-1.

1. Plenty of teams play it, so when we play 4-4-2, the opposition have the extra man in the middle. It was extremely evident against Chelsea, and if we play 4-4-2 against Liverpool, Gerrard will probably end up with the freedom of the pitch. Even teams that DO play 4-4-2 have creative 'in-the-hole` kind of strikers. Looking at our most recent opponents, Robbie Keane is a perfect example.
2. Petrov and Barry. Two cracking players, who would get in many teams in the Premiership. However, they have one negative point in common - both of them lack pace. With three central midfielders this is less of a problem, as they are generally in tighter situations with less ground to cover. When it is just the two of them, the gaps are larger, there is more ground to cover and their lack of pace becomes more of an issue. This is especially a problem when the opposition are on the counter attack.
3. We win the ball higher up the pitch most the time - this is perfect for our counter attacking style of play.
4. Offensively, it offers a lot more fluidity than the 'tram-lines` of a 4-4-2. It is harder to mark players, and it is so much more difficult for defenders to pick up the likes of Ashley Young and James Milner.
5. That also makes us more threatening on the counter, as generally, the wide players play 10/20 yards further inside than in the tram-line of a 4-4-2.
6. The starting position of a striker can be better, depending on whom it is. In terms of Gabriel Agbonlahor, he is more suited to the lone striker role because it is easier to make use of his pace. It is easier to run off the full-back and involves more 'coming in from the outside` - something Thierry Henry used to do at Arsenal all the time. Agbonlahor is nowhere near the class of Henry, but he is damn sure in the same league when it comes to speed.
7. Petrov generally plays the holding role. However if he does decide to push on, it leaves us less vulnerable as there are two midfielders to potentially slip in behind.
8. With Petrov playing that role, it also generally means it is Gareth Barry supporting the forwards when we play 4-4-2. With the lone striker formation, Barry has another midfield partner pushing on which keeps the defenders guessing more on who to pick up.
9. It also means that as they are coming from deep, they are harder to pick up.
10. The system also gives more freedom to the full-backs to push on. Of course, our full-backs are a source of frustration for most of us but in theory, it should mean that the full-backs - who get a LOT of the ball in the English game - can go forward with more confidence.

So, suffice it to day, I really do not believe we should 4-4-2! Yes there are times when it is appropriate (a plan B is important, and something we seem to be lacking) and I would love to see us sign a real top-class striker and if we do then it raises the question of what to do there, but to be honest I would like us to bring in another midfielder, one who has real offensive flair, but that is another discussion for another time.

Bottom line - if we play 4-4-2 against Liverpool tomorrow, I am convinced we will lose. Not saying I am confident we will win with one up top, but we stand a better chance of getting something out the game with that formation.




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!



For the very latest Premier League odds


Free 15 bet when you spend 5 on The New Football Pools




Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer: Sheriff Kimbo Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Saturday March 21 2009

Time: 5:50PM

Your Comments

By all means at Anfield but sorry I was bored stiff with one up front at home it never worked if you remember? Plus it has turned Gabby into a player who has gone from looking for the ball through the gaps or over the top to one that tries to play with his back to goal but doesn't have the touch to do it. His pace being his only real asset he needs to be looking for the ball over the top not playing with his back to goal. Just because we fluke a few away wins when JC was out doesn't mean we should return to it now we have 4 fit strikers.
Villan57
100% agree with this post. The players we have at our disposal are definitely best suited to it. As for at home, we should play it but not with Gabby. It should be with Carew when fit and Heskey if not. I am convinced that we would now be at least six points ahead of Arsenal if we MON had not tried fix (by playing Heskey) something that wasn't broken!
Nigel-not-Reo
I think you're bored at home cause most teams come to Villa Park to defend & we aint great at breaking them down, regardless of formation. I'm also not saying there is NO place for 4-4-2, just explaining why it's NOT a fluke that we had better results with that formation.
Sheriff Kimbo
thats the most sensible post i've seen on here. your right about home too but to fix that we need a creative midfielder.
themightyatom
I feel the 4-5-1 is the way to go. It makes us harder to breakdown and makes it easier for young and jimmy to get on the ball and do what they do best. I cant stand the long ball game we use so much when Carew is playing as they are all aimed for him to get his head on, but with just Gabby up top the long ball, when used is much more dangerous as they are aimed in behind the back and Gabby's pace allows him to nip in and get scoring chances.
Tallaght Villan
Agree entirely and can't argue with any of those well put points Sheriff. MON must see the light.
Villan444
Youre so right, you were in a title challenge when you played 4-5-1, with Barry Nigel + Stan in midfield. Why you bought Heskey and changed a winning system ive no idea!
HuddersfieldYiddo
HY, please tell this to MON as he's the only one that has missed it!
Nigel-not-Reo
Interesting article, obviously well thought out, and it clearly provides food for thought. Cant say that I fully agree with it, although I can appreciate and understand exactly where Sheriff Kimbo is coming from.
glensider
I personally think that playing with two out and out front men, John Carew and Gabby Agbonlahor for arguments sake, see's us provide much more of a threat to the opposition, certainly in games played at Villa Park. We lack creativity in midfield as it is, to curb our goalscoring potential too, would in my mind, be a big mistake. Interesting.
glensider
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Articles

Something For The Weekend (459) (Friday April 18 2014)

Deeney In, Helenius Out? (Thursday April 17 2014)

Lambert Upbeat Ahead Of Saints Clash (Thursday April 17 2014)

Randy In Praise Of Lambert (Wednesday April 16 2014)

Villa Confirm Suspensions (Tuesday April 15 2014)

Archived Articles

List All Vital Villa Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Pride of Lions 856
2. The Fear 762
3. ClivetheVillan 299
4. Barney2004 245
5. Villan57 222
6. Villan Of The North 199
7. tarzan 193
8. sirdennis 187
9. Sussex Villan 177
10. BlackCountry Villa 174

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
11. Crystal Palace 34 12 4 18 -14 40
12. West Ham 34 10 7 17 -9 37
13. Hull City 33 10 6 17 -6 36
14. Aston Villa 33 9 7 17 -14 34
15. Swansea 34 8 9 17 -5 33
16. WBA 33 6 15 12 -11 33
17. Norwich 34 8 8 18 -27 32

Breaking League News

Vital Preview: Norwich City vs. Liverpool
Liverpool : 18/04/2014 18:49:00
Vital Preview: Cardiff v Stoke
Cardiff : 18/04/2014 18:04:00
Injury Update: Defender In, Defender Out
Arsenal : 18/04/2014 17:02:00
Match Discussion - Hull City (a)
Arsenal : 18/04/2014 16:55:00
Liverpool: Reds Dominate PFA Awards Shortlists
Liverpool : 18/04/2014 15:02:00
Dylan Tombides - RIP
West Ham : 18/04/2014 14:58:00
Something For The Weekend (459)
Aston Villa : 18/04/2014 14:52:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Villa v Southampton will:
Suggested By:  Mystic Mug
Win 35%
Lose 51%
Draw 14%