Vital Football

Latest Aston Villa News

Is Harewood Really So Bad?

Is Harewood Really So Bad?

It's been a funny old day.

One moment I'm sat peacefully at work, occasionally sneaking a glance at NewsNow when no-one's looking, reading the same old rumours from TribalFootball recycled and re-quoted across hundreds of sites, wondering when the hell we're going to see a rumour with a glimmer of truth in it.

I go home for lunch early, have a sandwich or two, finally manage to exorcise the ghost of Saturday nights' mixed grill kebab (much to my relief), drop down at my desk, hit my favourite Internet Explorer bookmark...

...and my blood turns cold.

Three words scream and bounce around inside my skull, I'm in a state of shock, oblivious to the world around me.. a client calls, trying desperately to give me his credit card details and all I can think is:


...but as the afternoon progresses, somewhere in between reading rants and raves and abuse and grown men attempting to make a former Marine cry, I start to think to myself..

'Is this really such a bad move?'

And for all the negativity I'm reading, and my own personal dislike of the player - I've never been a Harewood fan, nothing to do with the lad himself, more due to the fact that he hasn't stopped scoring against us since West Ham arrived in the Premiership - I can see all kinds of logic in his signing.

I remember him bulldozing his way through Villa's defence not once, not twice but three times in a recent match at Villa Park. He could have scored more.

I check Wikipedia, to see he has a career record of roughly one goal every three appearances (104 goals in 341 appearances) . Not bad, not brilliant, but not bad. For reference, Craig Bellamy, who is a year older and the player the Hammers have signed for twice Harewood's reported fee, has approximately one in four (94 goals in 373 appearances). Darren Bent has one goal every 2 1/2 games (78 in 190).

I remind myself that at the moment, Carew is the only one of our forward line who has a real physical presence, and that should we lose him through suspension or injury, we've got no real options to replace him.

I realise that Michael Chopra, a player who struggled in the Premiership with Newcastle, had one good season in the Championship, has recently changed clubs for £5million, Nugent, untried at Premiership level, for £6million and everyones favourite golfer, Craig Bellamy, for £7.5million. Darren Bent, a player who was relegated with his club, for £16.5 million. Hell, Kieran Richardson has just moved for £5.5million. In a world of ludicrous figures like these, I start to think what a bargain the reported £3.7 million could be.

I wonder how many goals each of these players is going to net this coming season, and whether when all is said and done there really is over £11million pounds worth of difference between them. And the more I think about it, the more of the reaction I read on the forums starts to sicken me.

Even if we were in a position to do so, even if we had the carrot of European football to dangle in front of prospective signings, not every player we sign would be a world beater.

This is a player who can come in for a realistic fee and do a solid job for us at a time when we need bodies in the squad. I don't remember Doug Ellis being barracked into hiding when we signed Julian Joachim. He never played every game, never set the world on fire, but gave us options and scored some important goals.

Harewood could quite easily do a similar job. I see him as direct competition and cover for Carew - however the pair of them played together could wreak havoc on a tiring defence, and give us another option. And his arrival's not likely to put Moore or Gabby's noses out of joint, either.

I'm not going to try and persuade you that Harewood's arrival would be a coup, that it would be a fantastic signing, or that he can be the man to fire us into Europe. Nor am I going to comment any further on the player until I've seen a: if he signs and b: how well he does. What I will say is that anyone who was thinking we are going to go out and splash £10 million each on players to replace those who have left, or who thinks that without European football we can attract players WORTH that kind of money - is deluding themselves.

Harewood would be a solid signing. Not awe-inspiring, not gasp-inducing, not bums-on-seats megastar, but ham and cheese, work hard, run all day, knock you over solid. And at for that type of player, for £3.7million, is the kind of reaction - no, scratch that, backlash - we've seen today really justified?

So I'm not particularly pleased to see him in talks with the Villa, I'm not overly annoyed either. I'm willing to give him a chance to win me over, and I'll support him while he tries to take that chance. Can't you?


Just as an addition, Neil Baker posted these facts in the forum:

From 05/06 season:

Shots on target/goals (excl. pens)

1 Henry (Arsenal) 58/20
2 van Nistelrooy (Man Utd) 64/19
3 Bent (Charlton) 40/14
4 Rooney (Man Utd) 72/14
5 Bellamy (Blackburn) 32/12
6 Harewood (West Ham) 32/12
7 Keane (Tottenham) 37/12
8 Drogba (Chelsea) 34/11
9 Lampard (Chelsea) 62/11
10 Crespo (Chelsea) 27/10
11 Mido (Tottenham) 27/10
12 Yakubu (Middlesbrough) 35/10
13 Pedersen (Blackburn) 17/9
14 Giannakopoulos (Bolton) 20/9
15 Camara (Wigan Athletic) 27/9
16 John (Fulham) 28/9
17 Cole (Man City) 30/9
18 Nolan (Bolton) 31/9
19 McBride (Fulham) 37/9
20 Moore (Aston Villa) 15
21 Hasselbaink (Middlesbrough) 22/8
22 Beattie (Everton) 28/8
23 Ronaldo (Man Utd) 41/8
24 Defoe (Tottenham) 44/8
25 Owen (Newcastle) 13/7
26 Viduka (Middlesbrough) 22/7
27 Roberts (Wigan Athletic) 25/
28 Luis Garcia (Liverpool) 29/7
29 Vassell (Man City) 29/7
30 Baros (Aston Villa) 33/7
31 LuaLua (Portsmouth) 40/7

Date:Tuesday July 17 2007
Time: 9:44AM


I have to agree. I actually voted i wasn't keen on his arrival, but having seen him tear us apart with those 3 goals, i always dreaded seeing him play against us. For his price, he certainly could be a "decent" signing and we as fans owe him at the least, the chance to do a job for us.
17/07/2007 09:50:00
Is Harewood so bad? Yes. A top Championship player.
17/07/2007 09:55:00
I agree 100% with the article. Excellent writing.
17/07/2007 09:56:00
For me Mido might have been a better option. It isn't wrong to say top players won't come to a club who aren't in Europe - however what has Storey-Moore been doing all of last season? presumably he was scouting potential targets. Where are they? Not all of them would turn us down because we aren't in Europe. I have to believe there are better options out there than Harewood. He gave no 'options' the the'ammers last season - what makes you believe he'll give us any - I just hope MON can bring something out of him. He truely would be a magician if he could.
17/07/2007 09:58:00
My initial thoughts were exactly the same as BBB's, as were many other peoples I expect. BUT, the bloke hasn't kicked a ball for us yet, the time to decide is at the end of the season, not the beginning. Only time will tell if he will be a good or bad signing.
17/07/2007 10:03:00
He's not a good enough squad player. If he is, then how come the ammers don't think so? His goals have come in the lower leagues. Come on - lets hope he opts for wigan
17/07/2007 10:07:00
Good points BBB. Agree totally.
17/07/2007 10:08:00
A thought for a second here, say he does sign...comes off the bench in the local derby and puts a brace past the bluenoses!?! Scoring goals is one thing scoring the goals that count is another.If we WERE to buy him and he did nothing but score the winning goals against the blues I would be more than happy. Team game guys, we need numbers and he would help make them up.
17/07/2007 10:08:00
An excellent article with some very valid points. Good stuff BBB, it made for an enjoyable read. However, these points can only be used a couple for a couple of players in a squad before the quality of the players at our disposal starts to slip backwards. I won’t be unhappy if MH signs but I will if we fatten our squad out with lots of his calibre purely to get the numbers on board.
17/07/2007 10:19:00
that is the thing isn't it Beefy, we do need quality, need to see we are aiming higher. Harewood might be ok, his scoring record apart from last year (was he injured all the time or just rubbish?) is ok but do we just want ok now? I think the anger isn't about Harewood, rather that our expectations are higher now. Maybe they can't bring in who they actually want? Targets might have had better offers, offers from clubs in Europe or might just not fancy us until we progress a bit more. Maybe next season is another consolidation season where we hopefully push further and harder in the top half? Would be good to see 2-3 quality signings, if that happens then Harewood or not, it won't have been a bad summer and I don't think any of us will mind if Harewood is in the team and is scoriing. Just would prefer Moore/Gabby, so hope they don't get pushed to one side. Still, it is MON who makes the decisions and whose job is on the line if they go wrong. The success done the Leicester way won't fit the modern game or Villa though and Celtic are a different proposition I think!
The Fear
17/07/2007 10:24:00
Page 1/3
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3

Login to post a comment


Recent Aston Villa Articles

Something For The Weekend (512)

From Rotterdam to Götterdämmerung, in a generation?

Lescott Talks Watford & Injury Update

Joleon Lescott has spoken about Watford and Jores Okore and we also have the weekly injury update.

Audio - Richards & Gregory Talk Villa

Skipper Micah Richards has spoken about the first time he realised Villa were in trouble, and former gaffer John Gregory gives his thoughts.

The Aston Villa Injury Table...

Our weekly update looking at the injury table for Aston Villa and also comparing with all our competitors in the Premier League.

Archived Vital Villa Articles

Vital Villa articles from

Site Journalists

J P Fear
Mike Field
Steve Wade
Turkish Penguin
Chris Heath
M Calucar
JuanPablo Angel

Current Poll (see more polls)

Aston Villa v Watford will:
Suggested By: Mystic Mug
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
1 Leicester City 13 8 4 1 28 8
2 Man Utd 13 8 3 2 27 10
3 Man City 13 8 2 3 26 14
4 Arsenal 13 8 2 3 26 12
5 Spurs 13 6 6 1 24 13
6 West Ham 13 6 3 4 21 4
7 Everton 13 5 5 3 20 8
8 Southampton 13 5 5 3 20 5
9 Liverpool 13 5 5 3 20 2
10 Crystal Palace 13 6 1 6 19 1
11 Stoke 13 5 4 4 19 -1
12 WBA 13 5 2 6 17 -5
13 Watford 13 4 4 5 16 -2
14 Swansea 13 3 5 5 14 -4
15 Chelsea 13 4 2 7 14 -6
16 Norwich 13 3 3 7 12 -8
17 Newcastle 13 2 4 7 10 -12
18 Sunderland 13 2 3 8 9 -12
19 AFC Bournemouth 13 2 3 8 9 -13
20 Aston Villa 13 1 2 10 5 -14
Vital Football Comment
Latest F1 News
2015 - Abu Dhabi Grand Prix - FP2
Latest Vital Boxing News
AUDIO: Fury to 'deal with' Klitschko on Saturday
Write for Vital Football

Aston Villa Fixtures (view all)

Nov 28 2015 3:00PM : Watford (H)
Barclays Premier League
Dec 5 2015 3:00PM : Southampton (a)
Barclays Premier League
Dec 13 2015 1:30PM : Arsenal (H)
Barclays Premier League
Dec 19 2015 5:30PM : Newcastle United (a)
Barclays Premier League
Dec 26 2015 3:00PM : West Ham United (H)
Barclays Premier League
Dec 28 2015 3:00PM : Norwich City (a)
Barclays Premier League

Vital Members League Table

1.Pride of Lions1014
2.The Fear619
The Vital Football Members League