Vital Football

Latest Aston Villa News

Spurs and Villa To Swap Keepers?

Spurs and Villa To Swap Keepers?

This should get the reactions flowing!

Villa, according to The Mirror - the bastion of all things true in football rumours... (cough cough) - have linked us with none other than Spurs and England keeper Paul Robinson.

Villa were linked with the England No1 during the David O'Leary reign but he ended up moving from Leeds to Tottenham, but now according to the paper, Martin O'Neill will pay anything up to £5million to secure his services.

I must admit, I think he is a far better keeper than our current on-loan (from Liverpool as if you didn't already know) keeper Scott Carson who seems to be unable to command his box, much like the criticism levelled at Thomas Sorensen.

Robo has certainly had his share of high profile errors this season but then, what keeper doesn't go through that? Anyone remember some of David James mistakes? Yes, me too but he is still the best keeper in the league!

Funny that we should be linked to Robo because my information - and it is only a rumour, not concrete - is that Spurs are willing to pay the £10million that Liverpool want for Scott Carson and that he will be White Hart Lane bound in the summer.

Usually I'd see that as a backward step for Villa, allowing a young, up and coming player to leave only to be replaced by another teams 'cast off'. However I can't say that Carson has impressed anyone that I've spoken to this season and so would it be such a big loss to see him not taken on permanently?

So what do you reckon?! Spurs fans, who would you prefer between your posts, Carson or Robinson?



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Join the Vital Fantasy Football League - its Free!

Writer:J P Fear
Date:Friday March 21 2008
Time: 9:18AM

Comments

0
I'd take Robo. Ok so he's had a dip in form but that is one reason you have a reserve keeper, to keep things going when the dip comes as it does for all keepers. Heck, even Schmiechal, the best keeper I've ever seen anywhere, had dips in form and made some momentous errors. As for James being the best keeper in the league, please!! He might well be the best English keeper but surely Chech is better not to mention a few other possibilities.
Villain Of The North
21/03/2008 09:31:00
0
You're 'avin a laugh! If you are planning on a footballing suicide as a club - then surely you must go for Robbo! Carson is not a brilliant goalkeeper, but from what I have seen from him is an excellent shotstopper and can only get better. His "lack of command" in the area is an aspect of the game that he can improve but! Robbo has serious issues with crosses, kicking, positioning, narrowing down angles etc. Actually the only things he has no issues with are PIES!! Loads of them. Do not be silly and even contemplate this "trade".
G4L
21/03/2008 09:48:00
0
Carson £10m Robbo £5m. Definatly take Robbo!!! To be honest if we were quoted the same price for both I would have a hard time choosing!!! I think under MON, Robinson would be the better choice to be honest!!!
deano.avfc
21/03/2008 09:50:00
0
1st routledge, now robbo!...im glad to see we have a dumping ground in AVFC for our *****e!....cheers lads!
lillywhites101
21/03/2008 09:53:00
0
lillywhites101 be carefull what you say as comments like that have a habbit of comming back to bite you in the arse. I know it has happened with us on many occasions.
Villain Of The North
21/03/2008 10:05:00
0
I would take neither. Having an english goalie is a pain in the butt!
shelf16
21/03/2008 10:11:00
0
Why don't we sign a good keeper instead
stennyvilla
21/03/2008 10:14:00
0
i would take him he has world cup experience and if he could get back to hs old form then he is a top goalie.
british84
21/03/2008 10:35:00
0
AVFC, the dumping ground for spurs.... (who also happen to be higher in the league than you after monumental spending last summer) BIG THUMBS UP!
johnnyuk
21/03/2008 10:36:00
0
If you base your entire judgement on the last 5 minutes with everything Johnny you'll end up being a very sad and mixed up boy.
jmd
21/03/2008 10:53:00
Page 1/3
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3

Login to post a comment

Best of Vital Network

Vital F1 - Sympathy for Kvyat?

Recent Aston Villa Articles

Cup Of Traditions Heads To Villa

Aston Villa played two 45 minutes friendlies out in Germany earlier today at the Schauinsland Reisen Arena and we kicked the day off with a three nil victory over...

Friendly Final Against Hertha

Little late here, I thought kick off was 4pm which just proves I'm a plank - a stream for today's 45 minute friendly final out in Germany.

Gardner Linked With Forest Return

It was being reported yesterday that midfielder Gary Gardner was a fresh target for Nottingham Forest.

Sunderland Track Villa Duo

With centre half Tommy Elphick linked with a move to Sunderland the other week, it's now being suggested that Ross McCormack is a target as well.

Archived Vital Villa Articles

Vital Villa articles from

Site Journalists

J P Fear
Editor email
Profile
Mike Field
Editor email
Profile
Steve Wade
no email
Profile
JuanPablo Angel
no email
Profile
Glensider
no email
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

Glenn Whelan?
Suggested By: JP Fear
Good signing70%
Average signing 20%
Poor signing 10%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites
Write for Vital Football
Latest F1 News
Sympathy for Kvyat?
Latest Vital Boxing News
Holyfield Has Some Advice for Joshua
The Vital Football Members League

Recent Aston Villa Results (view all)

Aston Villa Fixtures (view all)

Vital Members League Table

RankNamePoints
1.The Fear356
2.col8279
3.Pride of Lions238
4.JuanPabloAngel234
5.sirdennis233
6.mike_field189
7.DeanoVilla151
8.1958Villan140
9.Fulford140
10.HeathfieldRoad1874124
Vital Football Comment