Aston Villa - We're Not Singing Anymore...
UK time is: 17:58:35
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

We're Not Singing Anymore...

continue in their efforts to try and achieve a common sense solution to the issue of standing in our football grounds it would seem from the feedback that reaches us that more and more supporters are increasingly disgruntled with many other issues; draconian and sometimes excessive stewarding, arrests for reasons that many would deem trivial (and a waste of tax payers money) that have lead to banning orders, atmospheres that are akin to visiting your local library, match day announcers and music drowning out traditional chanting and the increasing manipulation of fans to support their clubs in ways officialdom feel appropriate.

Fans of some clubs are fighting back with varying degrees of success. Arsenals’ Red Action are given absurd “health and safety” reasons against their having a large flag whereas Abramovich contributed financially so a group of supporters at Stamford Bridge could have a new flag made up. Middlesbrough have a 12Th Man group that their club approve of, but the efforts of the Ultras at Leeds were thwarted at every turn by Bates and the management at Elland Road. Liverpool fans have started a “Reclaim the Kop” group to educate what they call the Sky generation in the traditions of their club but a determined bunch of Man Utd fans are fighting against petty restrictions at Old Trafford that would see them taking in their large flag just once a season. Apparently, the club just don’t have the resources for them to display their flag…

On arrival at my club, West Ham, the norm now is to be greeted not by friendly stewards but burly and surly teams of “security” who rudely demand to look in your bag or search you. Similar applies to away fans, no warm East End welcome, just hauled out of the que for a full search regardless of your age or appearance. I for one find it alarming that these stewards and teams of security personnel have more powers than the police and many, I’m sure, delight in exercising their power rather than use it appropriately.

Once you’ve surrendered your bottle tops, umbrellas or any other item that could be deemed an offensive weapon or potential missile and made it to your seat don’t waste your breathe and try to start singing; within seconds you’ll be battling against a sound system as powerful as any night clubs as it blasts out the latest hit! You may have been given inflatable sticks to knock together or a pre-approved, safety passed small flag could have been left on your seat for you to wave around as your players make their way to the pitch. How goals are celebrated are invariably dictated to by the club as Tom Hark is blasted out the second the ball hits the back of the net, if there is no music, be careful how you celebrate a goal in case a steward deems you over zealous! And as for wanting to stand up, well we all know what happens then!

Don’t even bother directing any song or gesture towards the away fans, you may be hauled out by several coppers clad in riot gear; woe betide you if you start singing something that may be deemed racist, sexist or any other “ist” by the stewards. A set of northern supporters who were being derogatory about East London when Leyton Orient were the opposition were told they were being racist as were the supporters who sung that Newcastle was “just a small team from Scotland”. Of course there are always two sides to every story but with depressing regularity we get to know of fans who’ve either been ejected or threatened with ejection for behaviour that was not only accepted but considered part of being a football fan for us not to take their indignant claims seriously and as truthful.

Why is this? What is behind this relentless drive to turn our stadiums into serene havens where our emotions are controlled by music and stewards? Some say those in power won’t be happy until the working classes no longer comprise the majority of supporters. Some may feel that perhaps such thinking is the result of an over active imagination but given the ticket prices of many clubs perhaps there is an element of truth is this argument. Certainly if you consider that we’re apparently in need more ‘education’ when it comes to matters of race and domestic violence you could consider that we’re collectively viewed as a bunch of knuckle dragging, partner abusing racists like no other group in society! I bet the crowds at Twickenham or Lords aren’t on the receiving end of notes in programmes and displays by local school kids reminding them racism and ‘partner abuse’ is not only wrong but against the law.

If the behaviour of the modern fan was akin to that of 20 odd years ago, they’d be plenty of justification of how we’re treated today but the crowds now are so far removed from those times that every incident involving supporters (or even club managers!) is guaranteed more headlines and commentary than people blowing each others brains out at nightclubs or on the streets!

The Government is determined that every leisure activity from visiting an old wreck of an ancient castle to a football ground should be accessible and welcoming to all. Is this behind the increasing efforts to sanitise the game? Football is unique and just not comparable to any other sport or past time. Fans are tribal and in my experience all that matters to fans is that those next to them are wearing the same shirt as they are. Certainly as a woman I’d have no qualms about travelling to a game on my own as I’ve done a couple of times; I feel safer more comfortable surrounded by my fellow fans than I do in other circumstances. Certainly, I get served at the bar very quickly as I’m pushed to the front by the blokes around me!

Indeed a rather ‘well to do’ female columnist in the Times wrote in amazement at how well she was treated by fans and how much she enjoyed the atmosphere when she very reluctantly accompanied her young son to a Premiership game. Another woman journalist, also attending her first game last week wrote with enthusiasm at how entertained she was by the “fight” between Wenger and Pardew and that going to live games was much more fun that going to the theatre and yet these type of woman are supposedly terrified at the mere thought of going to a match hence the apparent desire to rid those who don’t sit quietly for 90 minutes from the stands completely.

Is it really necessary to treat supporters in such contempt just so fans new to the game can attend? Surely while the fans have moved on with the vast majority behaving, the authorities view us as if from a time warp and they continue to so at their peril. If this drive to apparently alienate the “traditional” fan from the game by either pricing them out or deciding their behaviour isn’t appropriate nor welcome continues then sooner or later these same people will be scratching their heads and wondering where we all are.

At least once a season, dropping attendances will hit the headlines; to thousands of us the solution is simple, bring back standing areas, stop manufacturing the atmosphere and let fans continue doing what they’ve done for over one hundred years.. supporting their teams vocally and passionately while on two feet. Stadiums are plenty big enough to accommodate both the sitters and the standers, lets start talking before it is too late.

By Amanda Matthews

Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer: J P Fear Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Wednesday November 15 2006

Time: 11:20AM

Your Comments (oldest first)

Change to most recent first
Agreed. It almost seems like an attempt to destroy the atmosphere at football matches.
Report Abuse
15/11/2006 11:51:00

At the Liverpool game someone who brought a drum was threatened with being kicked out because one person in 60,110 complained. I wouldn't mind but the drummer was sat in the Red Action area which was purposely created for the Vocal fan!
Report Abuse
15/11/2006 12:02:00

I had this a few weeks ago at Villa, I was told by a steward (not one of the usual ones who are great) that he'd escort me out if I carried on rattling the advertising board. Not long after I told him someone was clapping really loudly and asked him to remove them. What do these people think we are watching, the ballet?
The Fear
Report Abuse
15/11/2006 12:27:00

I feel a major letter campaign to Mr Dein coming on!!!
Report Abuse
15/11/2006 12:32:00

I can not believe Arse fans are so bothered. Emirates is the new 'Library'. It is unbelievable how a collection of 60,000 supporters can be so quite. But maybe it is just a London thing because Spuds fans are even quieter (other than the occasional chant of 'come on you spuds'). And Moanalotio complained about the lack of vocal backing from Chelski fans at the Rouble Arena. This following Villa supporters humbling of their Chelski counterparts despite being 4 - 0 behind in a midweek Carling Cup game. Maybe I am being harsh on London clubs though, because up north the 'Theatre of Prawns' is always like a morgue. As for Goodison Park, the Church in the corner of the ground is obviously the stimulus for the complete lack of atmosphere. Probably why all away fans sing 'it's just like being in church'. Even Villa Park struggles at time. It is either rocking from the rafters or flat as a pancake. So I agree with the original thread. Lets get safe standing areas back in to football stadia. UTV
Report Abuse
15/11/2006 13:07:00

The great thing about standing was you could pick which area of the Holte you wanted to be in and it was easier to start new chants because of the like minded people beside you, the left side right side geeing each other up was a great laff, I miss standing on the left side.
chris the villan
Report Abuse
15/11/2006 13:10:00

wow a girl writing on vital, i am shocked, but applaud the article, although i will have to say, like most women trying to emphasise a point, a bit long winded. but like the post, good article and was able to finish my M&S sarnie whiel reading.
Report Abuse
15/11/2006 13:39:00

Chris the villan - You were a left side? You tart. The Right side! The Right side! Left side, left side give a song. Shhhhhhh. Arghhhhhhhh
Report Abuse
15/11/2006 16:28:00

As a Yank and never attended a match oversees, I have always admired the singing that goes on during your matches, although I have absolutely no idea what is being sung. I have always wondered, in some of the South American matches, though, how the people sitting behind those with unbelievably huge flags ever get a chance to actually see the game! In Cleveland (yes, the same town from which Randy Lerner's Browns hail from), the baseball team has a standing area and it's quite popular. I do not know about the Browns, however. We did get a chance to sign a coulpe line from a popular song in response to some other fans at an away game in Los Angeles, but otherwise, we're really too scattered to join together and sing...
Report Abuse
15/11/2006 17:23:00

mikeinsb. You do not know what you are missing. Get your self on a plane to Birmingham and join theAston Villa fans in the 'Holte End' of the ground.
Report Abuse
15/11/2006 17:53:00

Woot! Send me a ticket and I'm on my way!!!!! Until then, it's simply getting up early in the morning on Saturdays (sometimes Sundays)and hoping Fox Soccer Channel is carrying AV that day!
Report Abuse
15/11/2006 17:58:00

Can you hear the right side sing i can't here a ....
chris the villan
Report Abuse
15/11/2006 18:24:00

Chris. lol :-]
Report Abuse
15/11/2006 20:52:00

Knees up mother Brown, knees up mother Brown, under the table we must go, e....o, e....o, e i o. If we catch you........ I remember singing this as a young lad in the Holte with the crowd surge sending you forward about 20 foot and then the recoil sending you backwards at great speed. Arrrrr, jumpers for goalposts, young children being passed overhead to the front. The good old days.
Report Abuse
15/11/2006 20:58:00

I would love to see standing returned to the Holte End, seats removed and the red crash barriers returned to their rightful place. What a sensation it "used to be" moving along in a sea of euphoric supporters jumping for joy when Villa scored. Will it ever return I doubt it but its worth fighting for.
Report Abuse
16/11/2006 03:37:00

It wasn't just at the Holte End that used to get crowd surges. I remember watching the dildo sales men from Somali Heath on Star Soccer one Sunday. Surprisingly they scored and the surge of three people from the top to the bottom of their 'Kop' , was truly a sight to behold. When a player jumps into the 'crowd' at Sty Andrews they count him in the attendance figures. UTV
Report Abuse
16/11/2006 09:09:00

The option to stand should be available to those who want it. Its a spectator sport after all, one that should be catering to the needs and demands of its public.
Report Abuse
17/03/2007 02:43:00


Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Aston Villa Articles

Ilori Makes Move On Loan (Tuesday September 1 2015)

Bennett Gets Cherries Loan (Tuesday September 1 2015)

Lescott On Joining Boyhood Club (Tuesday September 1 2015)

Lescott, Bennett & Ilori (Tuesday September 1 2015)

Lescott Seals Villa Move (Tuesday September 1 2015)

Lescott Shortly? (Tuesday September 1 2015)

Anderlecht Keeper Joins On (Tuesday September 1 2015)

Archived Aston Villa Articles

List All Vital Villa Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Pride of Lions 115
2. ClivetheVillan 110
3. Bonker 45
4. kefkat 44
5. The Fear 38
6. 1958Villan 30
7. BarosBarryBouma 22
8. goode9 21
9. littleburtonvilla 20
10. hanboroughvilla 13

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
9. Everton 4 1 2 1 1 5
10. Southampton 4 1 2 1 0 5
11. AFC Bournemouth 4 1 1 2 -1 4
12. Aston Villa 4 1 1 2 -1 4
13. Chelsea 4 1 1 2 -3 4
14. Norwich 4 1 1 2 -3 4
15. WBA 4 1 1 2 -3 4

Aston Villa Fixtures (view all)

Breaking League News

Jarvis Joins Norwich
West Ham : 02/09/2015 17:50:00
Adebayor Didn`t Come
West Ham : 02/09/2015 17:35:01
Rooney Closing in on Charlton`s England Record
Man Utd : 02/09/2015 17:28:01
Reed On Window amp; Wanyama
Southampton : 02/09/2015 17:24:01
Forster Sold Southampton To Me - van Djik
Southampton : 02/09/2015 17:18:01

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Aston Villa Player Of August?
Suggested By:  JP Fear
Guzan 5%
Clark 0%
Richards 1%
Amavi 17%
Westwood 2%
Gueye 23%
Sinclair 38%
Gabby 1%
Sanchez 13%
Other 0%