UK time is: 21:01:45
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Chelsea Fans Opinion On Ranieri

With Ranieri linked to Villa, I thought I'd ask Merlin at the Vital Chelsea site what he thought of all the idea of the tinkerman moving to Villa!

1) So, Ranieri has been linked to sleeping giant Aston Villa. Could he wake us up?

Difficult question that one. Ranieri came to Chelsea soon after we'd just won five trophies in two seasons under Gullit and Vialli. He wasn't received very well at first but after we'd gone a couple of season's without winning anything he suddenly found himself to be well liked. He has a good pedigree of turning around small clubs, not that I'm calling Villa small, but the success tends to come after he's left. Both Valencia and ourselves went on to win top flight titles. His methods are certainly interesting but he could be the one to stir Villa into life, there again he could mirror another ex-Chelsea manager, Gullit, who was a major failure at a second English club, Newcastle.

2) Would the original 'tinkerman' be able to cope with having a squad so small that there was nothing to tinker with?

It was only in his last season that he had a large squad. In the season leading up to the takeover by Abramovich Chelsea had no money to spend and a squad that was stretched due to injury and old age. His only signing was a free signing in the form of Quique De Lucas who hardly set the world alight. The tinkering only came when he'd spent wildly in that final season, some likened him to a kid in a sweet shop unable to resist anything.

3) How do you think he would get on with Herbert Douglas Ellis? No one else has ever managed to last long, what would Claudio bring to the party to suggest he could last?

If he survived for three / four years with Ken Bates he could, using his good nature, last with Ellis. You have to remember that Bates is a chairman who promised both Gullit and Vialli jobs for life after they'd ended our barren run only to sack them shortly after. He's a genuinely nice guy who, after a sticky start, worked well with the media.

4) Should Ranieri have been given more of a chance at Chelsea?

Difficult! He finished second in his final season and got to the Champions League semi-finals. At most clubs that would have guaranteed him at least another three season's. However, it has to be remembered that he was always living on borrowed time, his biography entitled Dead Man Walking is testament to that. New owners like their own people in charge.

5) Could we not have Mourinho instead please!?

Someone will get him, why not you? Despite the announcements that he is staying at Chelsea there is this wave of rumour that suggests otherwise. Personally, I hope he does stay for another ten years. He's that good despite the current press campaign to slur him.

6) With your knowledge of Ranieri, what is your opinion, would he succeed or fail at Villa?

Let's just say you wouldn't be looking anxiously over your shoulders at West Brom and Birmingham thankful that you're ten points ahead of them. Who knows, the UEFA Cup may be a viable target next year.

For the magic of Merlin, visit the Chelsea site! Click Here




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!


Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer: J P Fear Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Tuesday April 4 2006

Time: 1:40PM

Your Comments

If he cant succeed with the squad he had at Chelsea, how the hell is he going to do well with our squad? For me, Ranieri is a big no no!
soccerstef@hotmail.c
If he cant succeed with the squad he had at Chelsea, how the hell is he going to do well with our squad? For me, Ranieri is a big no no!
soccerstef@hotmail.c
I'd welcome him with open arms. O'Neill is going to Newcastle.
leelindsay
I'd welcome him with open arms. O'Neill is going to Newcastle.
leelindsay
Soccerstef, depends what you call succeed. He qualified for Europe every year and in the year we were skin managed 4th. So by Villas current standards he succeeded very well. If you looking for a league title hes not your man, but is that realistic expectation? Saying that I never warmed to him and thought his football negative and he was prone to tactical gaffs and weird substitutions. But he would not be a bad manager for you. Who else is in contention?
BlindJak
Soccerstef, depends what you call succeed. He qualified for Europe every year and in the year we were skin managed 4th. So by Villas current standards he succeeded very well. If you looking for a league title hes not your man, but is that realistic expectation? Saying that I never warmed to him and thought his football negative and he was prone to tactical gaffs and weird substitutions. But he would not be a bad manager for you. Who else is in contention?
BlindJak
As a true BLUE, many of us feel that after getting us to 2nd and into the semis in the ECL, he was worth another season. One must remember that in his final season, he was dead man walking. From the moment the season had started, he was on his way out, yet he achieved what most BLUE fans thought was a remarkable achievement given the incredible pressure he must have endured. That pressure culminated when observing Jose sitting alongside Kenyon in Monaco, he just thought this is too much and 'deliberately' made suicidal substitutions which gave the mother of all negative slurs to his Tinkerman nickname. As Merlin said, at Valencia and at CFC, he built a foundation for almost immediate success. With the BLUES, he ensures the purchases of English players (still making headlines today for the right reasons). So if the Villa are looking for solid and sustainable foundations for greatness, Ranners is not a bad choice whatsoever. BB
Blue Buddhist
As a true BLUE, many of us feel that after getting us to 2nd and into the semis in the ECL, he was worth another season. One must remember that in his final season, he was dead man walking. From the moment the season had started, he was on his way out, yet he achieved what most BLUE fans thought was a remarkable achievement given the incredible pressure he must have endured. That pressure culminated when observing Jose sitting alongside Kenyon in Monaco, he just thought this is too much and 'deliberately' made suicidal substitutions which gave the mother of all negative slurs to his Tinkerman nickname. As Merlin said, at Valencia and at CFC, he built a foundation for almost immediate success. With the BLUES, he ensures the purchases of English players (still making headlines today for the right reasons). So if the Villa are looking for solid and sustainable foundations for greatness, Ranners is not a bad choice whatsoever. BB
Blue Buddhist
He was superb at Chelsea, but i dont think he could cope with the Villa. The place is TOO middle of the road and lacks desire. Would take more than the tinkerman to put Villa back on the map, you will need a new Manager, a new Chairman, and some new blood
Terence
He was superb at Chelsea, but i dont think he could cope with the Villa. The place is TOO middle of the road and lacks desire. Would take more than the tinkerman to put Villa back on the map, you will need a new Manager, a new Chairman, and some new blood
Terence
Terence says it all, however how high do we set our sights as fans after the last 18 months. Would being in the shake up for European football do for a couple of seasons or would that be unrealistic. I think a new manager with new ideas and impetus could get our current squad into that position, with a little money to invest then who knows. What I convinced of is that the current incumbent is not capable
fatloser
Terence says it all, however how high do we set our sights as fans after the last 18 months. Would being in the shake up for European football do for a couple of seasons or would that be unrealistic. I think a new manager with new ideas and impetus could get our current squad into that position, with a little money to invest then who knows. What I convinced of is that the current incumbent is not capable
fatloser
Not for us I don't think.
Tierney
Not for us I don't think.
Tierney
Not my first choice but hey, not a bad one either. I would think that with our current squad he'd have us in the top 8, which right now would be very welcome. It's not that I lack ambition but without Abramovic type investment, we need to build a good solid foundation of top half finnishes in order to move on through sensible buying an utilising what is showing itself to be an excellent youth academy.
Villain Of The North
Not my first choice but hey, not a bad one either. I would think that with our current squad he'd have us in the top 8, which right now would be very welcome. It's not that I lack ambition but without Abramovic type investment, we need to build a good solid foundation of top half finnishes in order to move on through sensible buying an utilising what is showing itself to be an excellent youth academy.
Villain Of The North
Surely there has to be a lot better options out there than Ranieri? Personally he'd be way down on my list, so way down he wouldnt even figure. I just think though that until Ellis is history, it wouldnt matter who (if anyone) replaced O'Leary, success would be minimal, certainly nowhere near the level of success that we are all craving for. Mind you as of right now I guess, any new face couldnt fail to improve on the total trash that we are witnessing week after week.
glensider
Surely there has to be a lot better options out there than Ranieri? Personally he'd be way down on my list, so way down he wouldnt even figure. I just think though that until Ellis is history, it wouldnt matter who (if anyone) replaced O'Leary, success would be minimal, certainly nowhere near the level of success that we are all craving for. Mind you as of right now I guess, any new face couldnt fail to improve on the total trash that we are witnessing week after week.
glensider
He was never given a chance by Abramovic. Even if he'd won the premiership he'd still have gotten the elbow. Roumor has it that Sven was choosing the players they bought in anticipation that he'd be the new manager. Can't imagine that he'll do a whole lot for us under present circumstances. ELLIS OUT!
ooahPaulMcGrath
He was never given a chance by Abramovic. Even if he'd won the premiership he'd still have gotten the elbow. Roumor has it that Sven was choosing the players they bought in anticipation that he'd be the new manager. Can't imagine that he'll do a whole lot for us under present circumstances. ELLIS OUT!
ooahPaulMcGrath
Was quite bouyed by the Chelsea fans comments, but then again, this is only press talk at the moment, I guess we need to wait for DOL to leave before talking about the next poor bugger to take on Doug!
The Fear
Was quite bouyed by the Chelsea fans comments, but then again, this is only press talk at the moment, I guess we need to wait for DOL to leave before talking about the next poor bugger to take on Doug!
The Fear
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Aston Villa Articles

The Villa Times - 21/08/2014 (Thursday August 21 2014)

Villa Have A Fox In The (Directors) Box (Thursday August 21 2014)

Bennett Makes Loan Move (Wednesday August 20 2014)

Former Villa CEO Linked To Forest (Wednesday August 20 2014)

Arsenal Man Linked As Villa's New CEO (Wednesday August 20 2014)

17th Minute Applause For Two Toon Fans (Wednesday August 20 2014)

U21s - Villa 1 1 Stoke (Tuesday August 19 2014)

Ins and Outs Still For Villa? (Tuesday August 19 2014)

Vlaar In BBC Team Of The Week (Tuesday August 19 2014)

Archived Aston Villa Articles

List All Vital Villa Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. The Fear 764
2. Pride of Lions 522
3. ClivetheVillan 450
4. Villan Of The North 303
5. Barney2004 246
6. mike_field 203
7. DeanoVilla 200
8. sirdennis 200
9. gator 190
10. Juan Mourep 188

League Results (view all)

Latest Results
Stoke 0 - 1 Aston Villa

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
3. Arsenal 1 1 0 0 1 3
4. Liverpool 1 1 0 0 1 3
5. Swansea 1 1 0 0 1 3
6. Aston Villa 1 1 0 0 1 3
7. Hull City 1 1 0 0 1 3
8. Spurs 1 1 0 0 1 3
9. Everton 1 0 1 0 0 1

Breaking League News

Hammers seek Belgian Defender
West Ham : 21/08/2014 18:40:00
What if we bought Pogba?
Chelsea : 21/08/2014 18:30:00
Metz in for Maiga?
West Ham : 21/08/2014 18:05:00
Feruz Russia Bound
Chelsea : 21/08/2014 17:46:00
They Played for Both - Leicester City
Chelsea : 21/08/2014 17:38:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Aston Villa v Newcastle (home) will:
Suggested By:  Mystic Mug
Win 54%
Lose 19%
Draw 27%