Vital Football

Latest Aston Villa News

'Unrealistic Fans' Lied To?

'Unrealistic Fans' Lied To?

RIGHT. Just who is lying to who here? (Or is it to whom?!).

David O'Leary said at the weekend that Gary Cahill wasn't going to be able to make his Premiership bow against Portsmouth because he wasn't 'match fit' despite reports earlier saying he was going to make his debut due to our defensive crisis.

However reports in the Birmingham Mail today say something quite different. In fact it implies that the centre back was given an ultimatum by David O'Leary to sign a new contract or be withdrawn from the squad. Cahill apparently refused to be blackmailed and hence wasn't played.

The quicker the club issue a statement on this matter the better, because IF O'Leary has lied about this, on top of the constant moaning about the board, the players, the fans and everyone else apart from himself, it really is time for him to be run out of Villa Park with his tail between his legs.

According to the report Cahill has 16 months left on his current deal but is looking for improved terms. O'Leary said Cahill was 'not match fit' for the Portsmouth match after a week earlier suggesting he would play.

Over to the club to clear this up.


Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:J P Fear
Date:Wednesday March 8 2006
Time: 3:11PM

Comments

0
Surely this is no more than paper talk. DOL wouldn't hold a player to Ransom.
still skeggy
08/03/2006 15:18:00
0
Surely this is no more than paper talk. DOL wouldn't hold a player to Ransom.
still skeggy
08/03/2006 15:18:00
0
He bloody would! DOL OUT!!!!
DeanoVilla
08/03/2006 15:21:00
0
He bloody would! DOL OUT!!!!
DeanoVilla
08/03/2006 15:21:00
0
Let's get this straight from the start. Cahill wasn't match fit. We weren't lied to. We weren't told the whole story, but for keeping an internal contract dispute private, O'Leary should not be criticised. Also, O'Leary had, it seem, two option for the defence on Saturday. 1. Play a recently signed Dutch international defender with vast experience. This player is very short of fitness but has a good defensive brain and plays away from the centre of defence so his shortfall in fitness may not be so apparent. If this lack of fitness is a problem during the game, and things go wrong, the player is old enough and experienced enough to let this one instance not effect him too much. 2. Play a 19 year old defender in his first Premiership game. This player has some experience of first team football with a Championship side, but his single first team appearance for Villa resulted in the team shipping 3 goals in the first half. This player is also very short of match fitness and plays in the centre of defence. Chances are that if this fitness shortage is exposed, it will be done by Lua Lua who is strong and pacey and will run through the centre of defence to cause problems for Villa. Also, given the player's age and lack of experience, it could damage his confidence irrevocably and forever be an albatross around the young man's neck. I know which one I would prefer the manger to have done. Good choice O'Leary. Game won, clean sheet secured.
GaztonVilla
08/03/2006 15:23:00
0
Think we need to wait for the club to clear this one up. If he has lied then ........... ?
The Fear
08/03/2006 15:23:00
0
Let's get this straight from the start. Cahill wasn't match fit. We weren't lied to. We weren't told the whole story, but for keeping an internal contract dispute private, O'Leary should not be criticised. Also, O'Leary had, it seem, two option for the defence on Saturday. 1. Play a recently signed Dutch international defender with vast experience. This player is very short of fitness but has a good defensive brain and plays away from the centre of defence so his shortfall in fitness may not be so apparent. If this lack of fitness is a problem during the game, and things go wrong, the player is old enough and experienced enough to let this one instance not effect him too much. 2. Play a 19 year old defender in his first Premiership game. This player has some experience of first team football with a Championship side, but his single first team appearance for Villa resulted in the team shipping 3 goals in the first half. This player is also very short of match fitness and plays in the centre of defence. Chances are that if this fitness shortage is exposed, it will be done by Lua Lua who is strong and pacey and will run through the centre of defence to cause problems for Villa. Also, given the player's age and lack of experience, it could damage his confidence irrevocably and forever be an albatross around the young man's neck. I know which one I would prefer the manger to have done. Good choice O'Leary. Game won, clean sheet secured.
GaztonVilla
08/03/2006 15:23:00
0
Think we need to wait for the club to clear this one up. If he has lied then ........... ?
The Fear
08/03/2006 15:23:00
0
Lets just wait and see what comes out from the club tomorrow. I'm sure DOL will tell us one thing and then maybe another the day after ;)
Aronno7
08/03/2006 16:01:00
0
Lets just wait and see what comes out from the club tomorrow. I'm sure DOL will tell us one thing and then maybe another the day after ;)
Aronno7
08/03/2006 16:01:00
Page 1/2
  1. 1
  2. 2

Login to post a comment

Recent Aston Villa Articles

Vitesse Arnhem Cancelled - New Game Arranged

Aston Villa have confirmed a change to our second scheduled fixture out in Germany this pre season.

39th Game Abroad Not Yet On The Agenda

Premier League chairman Richard Scudamore has said that whilst he believes a 39th Premier League fixture list is still an option, it's not on the agenda just yet.

Samba Bags Villa Deal

A short time ago tonight, Aston Villa announced the signing of free agent Chris Samba.

New Season Ticket Packs On The Way & New Rewards

New season ticket and new rewards scheme news

Archived Vital Villa Articles

Vital Villa articles from

Site Journalists

J P Fear
Editor email
Profile
Mike Field
Editor email
Profile
Steve Wade
no email
Profile
JuanPablo Angel
no email
Profile
Glensider
no email
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

Glenn Whelan?
Suggested By: JP Fear
Good signing66%
Average signing 26%
Poor signing 8%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites
Vital Football Comment
Latest F1 News
Sympathy for Kvyat?
Latest Vital Boxing News
Date Set for Callum Smith WBSS Fight with Skoglund
Write for Vital Football

Recent Aston Villa Results (view all)

Aston Villa Fixtures (view all)

Vital Members League Table

RankNamePoints
1.The Fear307
2.col8234
3.JuanPabloAngel212
4.Pride of Lions205
5.sirdennis205
6.mike_field141
7.DeanoVilla138
8.1958Villan131
9.HeathfieldRoad1874108
10.Fulford102
The Vital Football Members League