Vital Football

Latest Aston Villa News

Stand Up - Sit Down

Stand Up - Sit Down

Press release from Stand Up - Sit Down (make up your minds?!)

Since our inception in July 2004, Stand Up Sit Down have always concentrated on current arguments in our case for a return to safe standing and have sought not to invoke terrible memories of the Hillsborough Disaster.

This is not a stance that those so against the return of standing adopt; within 5 minutes of sitting down in the ffices of the Football Licensing Authority we were told 'well, we can't have another Hillsborough, can we?' More recently, Sports Minister Richard Caborn, adopting emotive language used the disaster, during a debate in the Guardian newspaper with Stand Up Sit Down as virtually a carte blanche reason not to even have a debate on the issue. It seems that by using the words safety and Hillsborough the authorities give the impression that the case for the return to standing is an open and shut one.

We now wish to dispel the all too convenient myth that Hillsborough was caused because of terracing; we would prefer the authorities stop insulting our intelligence and using the tragic deaths of the Liverpool supporters as a debate stopper. We do not seek to cause offence but in light of the continuing refusal of the authorities to pay us little more than lip service, feel that it is timely to counter a stronger argument and hope now that the authorities will comprehensively address the fact that a large minority of supporters wish to stand at football matches and that rather hiding in the shadow of Hillsborough, an honest and open debate should ensue.

When responding to supporters who and supporter organisations who are campaigning for a return to standing, we would like to know why the following are never mentioned by the Government, the Football Licensing Authority and others.

That:

Sheffield Wednesday had no current safety certificate for the ground

The one they did hold had not, despite various changes to the ground, been updated since it was issued in December 1979!

For the police officer in charge that day, it was his first football match

In 1981 the police had advised that the overall figure of 10,100 for the Leppings Lane terrace was too high and yet the capacity was not reduced.

The police did not divert supporters from the packed pens into ones either side of the central one where supporters were congregating

A front barrier was corroded and under the pressure of the excessive and uncounted number of fans allowed in, it collapsed directly causing a number of deaths.

A crush barrier had been removed from pen 3 in 1986 leaving a clear fall through to the front

A second barrier had had a gap inserted in it in 1985

Lord Taylor rejected the idea drunk fans caused the disaster but instead was certain that the chief reason was police failure to handle the mass of supporters.

That seats should replace terracing was one of 76 recommendations that Taylor made and was not included in his interim report.

This recommendation was amended by the then Home Office Minister, David Mellor, in July 1992 when he agreed that some standing accommodation could be retained by clubs in the lowest two divisions of the Football League

Could it be all too convenient for the above not to be used in the short sighted and narrow minded arguments against standing as it detracts from their mantra that 'we can't have another Hillsborough'. Nobody wants another Hillsborough but this is simply not a good enough reason not to discuss with an open mind, the introduction of modern, safe standing.

It is clear that a disaster was waiting to happen at Hillsborough, but not simply or just because the club had terraces. Indeed, in a disaster in a modern, all seater stadium in South Africa in April 2001 that took the lives of 43 and injured over 100 football supporters, bore frightening similarities to the Hillsborough disaster in that the Inquiry found that 'how a litany of mistakes and errors of judgement could have contributed to the deaths of 43'.

Stand Up Sit Down need to be very clear indeed that we fully support the vast number of improvements made to football stadia in this country post Hillsborough; it is obvious that they were long over due, but question why it took the deaths of many and the 9th report (that was Taylor) into spectator safety to produce the benefits of modern stadia that we all enjoy today.

Notwithstanding the above we need to be equally clear that we think these benefits are yet another all too easy get out clause not to bring back managed standing. Richard Caborn recently 'spun' a Premier League fan survey by stating that 'fans see their safety as a hugely important part of going to a game - and that they are happy with the current all seater arrangements' . Supporters who took part on this survey were not asked about whether or not they wished to sit or stand!! They were asked about how important they rated safety and of course the overwhelming majority of responders said that they rated safety as 'extremely important' as any right minded individual would.

In our experience surveys on the subject of standing (mostly found on unofficial club websites) indicate that a high proportion of respondents wish to see safe standing areas reintroduced - even if they don't want to use them personally and rarely do supporters ask for return of the terracing as it was pre Taylor!

Looking at our European cousins, especially those in Germany (where incidentally all stadiums bar one hosting preliminary rounds of the forthcoming World Cup, have designated safe standing areas for domestic games) English supporters recognise and understand that standing and/or terraces do not have to be unsafe and for them to be reintroduced would not necessarily make attending football matches any more or less safe than it is currently.

While the main aim of this article was to dispel the myth that to stand in a football ground automatically means danger or disaster we must also touch on the view that is held by many, that a introduction to modern, safe standing areas would automatically herald a return of hooliganism. Do the people who so disparagingly seem to think that those who wish to stand are would be criminals not take into account that tens of thousands of supporters have persistently stood in front of their seats without such behaviour occurring since the inception of all seater stadiums? We struggle to think of any other minority group in society who would be so easily and conveniently stereotyped and are saddened that law abiding, genuine football supporters of both sexes, all ages and backgrounds who want to stand are thus thought of and portrayed as would be hooligans merely because they prefer to stand.

We're sure that this is a hugely contributory factor as to why the authorities will not entertain the return of standing in any form. We are routinely policed and 'stewarded' before, during and after games as if we are on perpetual brink of a riot and incapable of controlling ourselves unless the boys in blue or orange are there to contain, moderate and censor our behaviour.

Indeed, in a paper by the Norman Chester Centre for Football Research entitled 'Football and Football Hooliganism' no mention was made that being allowed to stand encourages deviant behaviour. It is a pity that those in authority choose to rely on patronising assumptions and ill informed opinions rather than proper academic research.

The Government and FLA have so manipulated Hillsborough and pandered to the idea that standing automatically equates to football violence that they refuse to listen to reason and continually use feeble arguments against us that do little more than suit their own agenda.

We are not sure what is worse: this twisting of the truth or the shameful hiding behind the deaths of ordinary, decent football supporters.

www.standupsitdown.co.uk


Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:J P Fear
Date:Tuesday February 21 2006
Time: 2:07PM

Comments

0
Would be great if a part of the stands were once again open terracing. Used to love standing in the Holte and have never returned to the stand since it went all seater. The atmosphere was 10 times better in those days!! Right side.
The Fear
21/02/2006 14:20:00
0
Would be great if a part of the stands were once again open terracing. Used to love standing in the Holte and have never returned to the stand since it went all seater. The atmosphere was 10 times better in those days!! Right side.
The Fear
21/02/2006 14:20:00
0
Same goes for Swansea, teams used to hate visiting our old ground the Vetch because it was so hostile and the fans were so close to the pitch. We used to create more atmosphere there with 5,000 than we are now with 12,000. It's got better recently though.
KevinE
21/02/2006 14:39:00
0
Same goes for Swansea, teams used to hate visiting our old ground the Vetch because it was so hostile and the fans were so close to the pitch. We used to create more atmosphere there with 5,000 than we are now with 12,000. It's got better recently though.
KevinE
21/02/2006 14:39:00
0
Oooh fear was a righty! I was always left side, we were the loudest! Seriously tho, 90% of my best villa memories are stood on the Holte, it's just not the same anymore. I definately think 1 end at every ground should be made standing room only. it's the way forward.
DeanoVilla
21/02/2006 15:12:00
0
Oooh fear was a righty! I was always left side, we were the loudest! Seriously tho, 90% of my best villa memories are stood on the Holte, it's just not the same anymore. I definately think 1 end at every ground should be made standing room only. it's the way forward.
DeanoVilla
21/02/2006 15:12:00
0
From games i have seen on video the holte looked like a fantastic place to be and it dosen't hve that same specialty as it did
Vince_AstonVilla
21/02/2006 17:36:00
0
From games i have seen on video the holte looked like a fantastic place to be and it dosen't hve that same specialty as it did
Vince_AstonVilla
21/02/2006 17:36:00
0
i love standing up iit makes the game especially away but then again i do feel jaded after a while lol
was_danrenshaw
21/02/2006 18:58:00
0
i love standing up iit makes the game especially away but then again i do feel jaded after a while lol
was_danrenshaw
21/02/2006 18:58:00
Page 1/2
  1. 1
  2. 2

Login to post a comment

Recent Aston Villa Articles

The Aston Villa Fan Consultation Group Minutes 14/02/2017

The minutes of the Fan Consultation Group meeting on Feb 14 2017

More Reliable Than A Championship Octopus? (22/2/17)

Time for the new special computer that crunches the numbers to determine the final Championship positions for 2016/17.

The Villa Times - 21/02/2017 (Aston Villa News Round-up)

The latest Aston Villa news and views via the fishy one..

Video Highlights - Fans/Bruce Reactions - Stats - Tweets

Post match ... arrgghhhh basically. Video, stats and the rest.

Archived Vital Villa Articles

Vital Villa articles from

Site Journalists

J P Fear
Editor email
Profile
Mike Field
Editor email
Profile
Steve Wade
no email
Profile
Villa_Grizzly
no email
Profile
Turkish Penguin
no email
Profile
Glensider
no email
Profile
Chris Heath
no email
Profile
M Calucar
no email
Profile
JuanPablo Angel
no email
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

Staying Up
Suggested By: JP Fear
yes, staying up43%
no, going down25%
too close to call at the moment32%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
1 Newcastle 32 22 3 7 69 37
2 Brighton 32 20 8 4 68 28
3 Huddersfield 32 20 4 8 64 8
4 Reading 33 18 6 9 60 5
5 Leeds Utd 33 18 4 11 58 11
6 Sheff Wed 33 17 7 9 58 10
7 Fulham 32 14 10 8 52 17
8 Norwich 33 15 6 12 51 11
9 Barnsley 33 14 7 12 49 4
10 Preston 33 13 10 10 49 4
11 Derby County 32 13 9 10 48 7
12 Cardiff 33 13 6 14 45 -2
13 Ipswich 33 10 11 12 41 -7
14 Brentford 32 11 7 14 40 0
15 Q.P.R. 33 11 7 15 40 -10
16 Birmingham 33 10 10 13 40 -14
17 Aston Villa 32 8 12 12 36 -8
18 Forest 33 10 6 17 36 -12
19 Wolves 31 9 8 14 35 -4
20 Burton 33 9 8 16 35 -13
21 Bristol City 32 9 5 18 32 -6
22 Wigan 33 7 9 17 30 -10
23 Blackburn 31 7 8 16 29 -13
24 Rotherham 33 4 5 24 17 -43
The Vital Football Members League
Latest F1 News
Williams adds new head of aerodynamics
Latest Vital Boxing News
Washington Aiming to Beat Wilder this Saturday
Vital Football Comment

Recent Aston Villa Results (view all)

Aston Villa Fixtures (view all)

Feb 25 2017 3:00PM : Derby County (H)
Sky Bet Championship
Feb 28 2017 7:45PM : Bristol City (H)
Sky Bet Championship
Mar 4 2017 3:00PM : Rotherham United (a)
Sky Bet Championship
Mar 7 2017 7:45PM : Huddersfield Town (a)
Sky Bet Championship
Mar 11 2017 3:00PM : Sheffield Wednesday (H)
Sky Bet Championship
Mar 18 2017 3:00PM : Wigan Athletic (a)
Sky Bet Championship

Vital Members League Table

RankNamePoints
1.The Fear371
2.JuanPabloAngel350
3.sirdennis326
4.Fulford211
5.Melon Donkey189
6.Silhillvilla182
7.villasince67178
8.Villan57140
9.McParlandTheGreat137
10.kefkat135
Write for Vital Football